9/11 CTs in general

Of course I am saying that. And if you think about that for more than 2 seconds you might realize that eye-witnesses are worth nothing against millions of viewers on television.

Imagine a few thousand people claiming that Hurricane Katrina was summoned by 20 bearded men gathered in a circle. Who gives a damn about eye-witnesses?

You can claim anything you want. Have it on tape, have others see what you saw or your witnessing is worth nothing.

And please, don't give me a moral lesson now about calling people liars and all that crap... An eye-witness is, concerning a matter that big, an outmoded idea. Regardless of how your personal opinion towards eye-witnesses is, nowadays, one has to accept the fact that this has no value at all.

I know you are leaving, which is a shame, because in all likeliness you will not see nor answer my question, but I would like to ask it anyway.

Is this really, seriously, your vision of Al Qaeda?
 
I think the tables can be turned on you, andreasz.

Do you think it is possible for people as intelligent as you, just as world aware, just as moral, to hold a diametrically opposed world view to yours?
 
Is this really, seriously, your vision of Al Qaeda?

Certainly not. This was just something that got into my mind when I thought of the evil terrorist image that was called into existence. And it exists in so many heads by now, that I described it that way.
 
Certainly not. This was just something that got into my mind when I thought of the evil terrorist image that was called into existence. And it exists in so many heads by now, that I described it that way.

Do you actually believe there is such a thing as Islamic terror groups, seriously?
 
I think the tables can be turned on you, andreasz.

Do you think it is possible for people as intelligent as you, just as world aware, just as moral, to hold a diametrically opposed world view to yours?

Of course it can. I think everybody gets into discussions like these all the time, unless he or she avoids it. The question is not if the people can have the same impression of a world or the exact opposite. There are too many factors playing a role here. The media, your social network, your personal impression of a situation... There are many people who just keep these opinions to themselves because they want to avoid confrontation, because they are well aware of how different impressions cause different points of view.

I am really sick of people not having any opinion and never giving any statements, just because they're afraid they might offend others with that and no longer be everybodys darling...

But I don't need to tell you that ;) You know it by now.
 
staetofgrace you are getting into some serious issues asking somebody like andreasz a question like that.

Islamic terror, and terror in general, while obviously existent has to be minimized in his eyes.

I predict his answer will be "yes, but they're not the threat they're made out to be. And besides, it's America's fault they exist in the first place"
 
Do you actually believe there is such a thing as Islamic terror groups, seriously?

I know for a fact that there are. I even have a friend that was indirectly involved with one without even knowing it.

But most of the islamic terror acts I know are acts of desperation. People who lost their socail life, their family, their pride. These are most likely the ones blowing themselves up in front of an embassy. As you may know, we have a lot of turkish people here in germany. Some of them practising islamic faith, some of them not practising anything but calling themselves muslims anyway.

Many people coming from islamic families get a feedback from their home countries and also many of them know about terrorist organizations. But as I said before, I consider them very unprofessional and desperate. And desperation and loss of hope is most likely the reason for an act of terror.
 
I know for a fact that there are. I even have a friend that was indirectly involved with one without even knowing it.

But most of the islamic terror acts I know are acts of desperation. People who lost their socail life, their family, their pride. These are most likely the ones blowing themselves up in front of an embassy. As you may know, we have a lot of turkish people here in germany. Some of them practising islamic faith, some of them not practising anything but calling themselves muslims anyway.

Many people coming from islamic families get a feedback from their home countries and also many of them know about terrorist organizations. But as I said before, I consider them very unprofessional and desperate. And desperation and loss of hope is most likely the reason for an act of terror.

While terrorists like you describe DO exist, there is also a large network of professional terrorists who ply their trade for other reasons than purely emotional ones.

Americans, and Westerners in general aren't the only people on Earth who worship money, and who do things that on the outside appear to have relatively honorable motives but actually are just about the cash and power.

There are imperialistic terrorists, there are idealistic terrorists, there are greedy terrorists, every motive under the sun.

Al Queda is a professional terrorist organization. The are a force to be reckoned with and a serious threat to me and my family no matter what 'reason's they have to kill us.
 
And besides, it's America's fault they exist in the first place"

blah. It's no countrys 'fault', how would that be possible? Germany is just as capitalist as the united states. Though we do have a social network with public health insurance and welfare. But the principle is quite similar.

Germany would be quite an easy target, don't you think?

I wouldn't say that they are not a threat. I am just not giving them as much credit as many of you do. Maybe, because I know a lot of people of islamic faith and their networks.

I don't really like any kind of religious attitude. In my opinion, people go to war way too often because of religious hatred. George Carlin put that into words in one of his shows really perfectly.

But, just to get back to the point... Yes, I do think, that those terrorists you are talking about are just as dangerous as any american who could just walk into a store and buy a gun and ammunition.
 
I know for a fact that there are. I even have a friend that was indirectly involved with one without even knowing it.

But most of the islamic terror acts I know are acts of desperation. People who lost their socail life, their family, their pride. These are most likely the ones blowing themselves up in front of an embassy. As you may know, we have a lot of turkish people here in germany. Some of them practising islamic faith, some of them not practising anything but calling themselves muslims anyway.

Many people coming from islamic families get a feedback from their home countries and also many of them know about terrorist organizations. But as I said before, I consider them very unprofessional and desperate. And desperation and loss of hope is most likely the reason for an act of terror.

This is the point. Do you agree the US; through her foreign policies have fuelled this desperation? Would you say that this desperation is so highly charged that individuals would subscribe to the ideology of Al Qaeda?

Please remember that it is the sworn goal of this ideology not only to drive the
US from Saudi Arabia but to actually bring the Islamic struggle to the global stage.

So would desperation, driven by US foreign policy fuel this ideology or are there other factors involved?
 
Germany would be quite an easy target, don't you think?

Quite frankly, if Germany would have been the lucky recipient of a 911-style attack the attitude of the average German would be quite different than it is today.

But, just to get back to the point... Yes, I do think, that those terrorists you are talking about are just as dangerous as any american who could just walk into a store and buy a gun and ammunition.

That American who walked into a store to buy a gun wouldn't have the capacity of killing thousands of people. There are domestic terrorists whom I fear, but it's the virulent Islamic type that is the one that scares me the most.
 
Last edited:
Al Queda is a professional terrorist organization. The are a force to be reckoned with and a serious threat to me and my family no matter what 'reason's they have to kill us.

Due to its structure of semi-autonomous cells, al-Qaeda's size and degree of responsibility for particular attacks are difficult to establish. However, this may also be because its size and degree are exaggerated. Although the governments opposed to al-Qaeda claim that it has worldwide reach,[16] other analysts have suggested that those governments, as well as Osama bin Laden himself, exaggerate al-Qaeda's significance in Islamist terrorism.[17] The neologism "al-Qaedaism"[18] is applied to the wider context of those who independently conduct similar acts through political sympathy to al-Qaeda ideology or methods or the copycat effect. Wikipedia.

I think they are really made more of an actual threat than they really are. And I am also pretty sure that the introduction of the patriot act is not in any way responsible for them being less of a threat than they were 10 years ago.
 
I think they are really made more of an actual threat than they really are. And I am also pretty sure that the introduction of the patriot act is not in any way responsible for them being less of a threat than they were 10 years ago.

See. I said you would say that ;)

Also, can you prove that the reason there have been no other major attacks since 911 on US soil isn't because of the Patriot act.

Oh. Wait. You don't think 911 was perpetrated by Al Queda. We have a serious difference of opinion about that. See, I consider an attack like 911 to be a serious threat. Of course, if you think 911 was some sort of inside job, you can rationalize downplaying the threat.

It's almost too convenient, with all due respect.
 
Last edited:
That American who walked into a store to buy a gun wouldn't have the capacity of killing thousands of people. There are domestic terrorists whom I fear, but it's the virulent Islamic type that is the one that scares me the most.

Those are the kinds of sentences where I always think that you guys watched too much "24" or have a completely wrong impression of muslims. It's not that there are millions of muslims that think that way.

The problem with islam is, ALSO here in germany, that the development of that religion is way back, compared to christianity for instance.

With religion, moral standards develop, and so on, bla bla bla.

Many turkish women here wear coats and have their hair covered, just because they believe that their religion wants them to. Back in turkey, where these people once came from, they moved on. No woman wears those any more, in Istanbul it is even forbidden to wear them in universities, public places, etc.

That's exactly the point with fundamentalists. They disappear, one by one... People develop, like it or not. Sooner or later this will be gone. And the last thing you want is to have some fictive bearded muslim enemy image in your head once the dust has cleared.
 
Those are the kinds of sentences where I always think that you guys watched too much "24" or have a completely wrong impression of muslims. It's not that there are millions of muslims that think that way.

The problem with islam is, ALSO here in germany, that the development of that religion is way back, compared to christianity for instance.

With religion, moral standards develop, and so on, bla bla bla.

Many turkish women here wear coats and have their hair covered, just because they believe that their religion wants them to. Back in turkey, where these people once came from, they moved on. No woman wears those any more, in Istanbul it is even forbidden to wear them in universities, public places, etc.

That's exactly the point with fundamentalists. They disappear, one by one... People develop, like it or not. Sooner or later this will be gone. And the last thing you want is to have some fictive bearded muslim enemy image in your head once the dust has cleared.

Who said that? Is the war on terror against Muslims or the ideology of radicalised Muslims?

Could you reply please?


This is the point. Do you agree the US; through her foreign policies have fuelled this desperation? Would you say that this desperation is so highly charged that individuals would subscribe to the ideology of Al Qaeda?

Please remember that it is the sworn goal of this ideology not only to drive the US from Saudi Arabia but to actually bring the Islamic struggle to the global stage.

So would desperation, driven by US foreign policy fuel this ideology or are there other factors involved?
 
Those are the kinds of sentences where I always think that you guys watched too much "24" or have a completely wrong impression of muslims. It's not that there are millions of muslims that think that way.

Not once did I imply that I thought all Muslims think that way. I was referring to the minority of extremist islamists.

Not to burst your bubble, but not all Americans are stupid; I have a perfectly rational and realistic impression of the average Muslim, thank you very much.
 
This is the point. Do you agree the US; through her foreign policies have fuelled this desperation? Would you say that this desperation is so highly charged that individuals would subscribe to the ideology of Al Qaeda?

Please remember that it is the sworn goal of this ideology not only to drive the
US from Saudi Arabia but to actually bring the Islamic struggle to the global stage.

So would desperation, driven by US foreign policy fuel this ideology or are there other factors involved?

Fuelled yes, but not caused initially. The reasons for that go way back to the gulf war and before.

And no, I don't think individuals would join Al Qaeda due to that. As I said, most of them just blow themselves up. But this is just a desperate reaction and it's hitting the wrong guys. It's not the soldiers fault, that the people in Bagdad for example are left in this specific situation. But those suicide bombers did not know where else to attack but the closest thing they have to an enemy, regardless of how nice and friendly next doors Private Johnson has been to them.

The ideology of converting the whole world to islamic faith is widely known. But it has no substance. And people who believe that crap and actually try to bring their faith to others by force, even to those who are not religious at all, get fewer and fewer.

Religion is fading. Not only the christian one. Sooner or later, even people from Kansas will experience that.
 
Not to burst your bubble, but not all Americans are stupid; I have a perfectly rational and realistic impression of the average Muslim, thank you very much.

hehe, sorry... Might have sounded that way, but shouldn't be taken as an offense. The idea of the extremist you gave me seemed pretty much like the 'standard' american image I am used to by many americans.

It's also not about where you are from, germans, french, british... Take a look at the average population and you'll see that they're all equally stupid. You find some bright people and you find the dull minds. And there's the average joe, too... Upon that, you have different levels of sophistication, which have not necessarily anything to do with intelligence or stupidity.

I am just saying, that in many american heads, an image of the average muslim exists, which is with a fifty/fifty chance evil :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom