8-year-old Yemen girl asks court for divorce from 30 yo husband.

Empress

Piggish
Joined
Nov 28, 2007
Messages
2,210
Location
Blandings Castle
Not sure if this belongs here or in religion, but it's just too horrible a case not to bring up.

http://yementimes.com/article.shtml?i=1145&p=front&a=2

Seriously one of the most screwed-up situations I've ever read.

“Whenever I wanted to play in the yard he beat me and asked me to go to the bedroom with him. This lasted for two months," added Nasser. "He was too tough with me, and whenever I asked him for mercy, he beat me and slapped me and then used me. I just want to have a respectful life and divorce him.”

Fortunately, it does not appear that Court officials are going to return her to her family, for fear that in a few years she'll be married off again. So at least the future looks as bright as possible for the girl.
 
Wow. In a somber sort of way.

I am impressed by the actions of this poor young girl. I wonder what she will become as an adult - if this will affect her choice of education and livelihood. She certainly seems to have "what it takes" to do something amazing.

ps. Empress - love the avatar!
 
Last edited:
Little brat should be stoned to death for disrespecting her husband.

At least he wasn't smoking in the car with her.
 
Wow. In a somber sort of way.

I am impressed by the actions of this poor young girl. I wonder what she will become as an adult - if this will affect her choice of education and livelihood. She certainly seems to have "what it takes" to do something amazing.

ps. Empress - love the avatar!

Thanks. It was assigned to me in the "Let someone else choose your avatar" thread. I will avenge myself!

I agree about the girl's actions. Only eight and already able to manage to stand up for herself this way--go to the court alone, and verbalize her problems, what had happened to her, and what she needed. Absolutely incredible. I think when I was eight I had managed to become toilet-trained... :mglook
 
Instead of having sexual fantasies about an 8-year old girl, maybe you should focus on the fact that she stood up to a religious tyranny?

The relgious courts don't consider the marrage to be valid. Father appears to have been in less than ideal mental health. Given how limited goverment is in that area it is to be expected that it would take time for the authorities to catch on.
 
The relgious courts don't consider the marrage to be valid. Father appears to have been in less than ideal mental health. Given how limited goverment is in that area it is to be expected that it would take time for the authorities to catch on.

It's not a question of whether some court consider the marriage valid or not, or how long it would take for it to catch on.

It's a question of Scrut suggesting that an 8-year old girl, repeatedly raped, was seeking someone "better". Even as a joke, it is poor taste. Very poor taste.
 
Last edited:
Stick to the scenario.

Is that a "fact" or an "opinion"?

Oh, please.

Instead of hailing her courage, you chose to mock that she was raped repeatedly, by suggesting she wanted a divorce so she could find someone "better".

What the hell were you thinking?? That she liked being raped, but just weren't satisfied with the old man who was raping her?

Or maybe you don't even think this 8-year old girl was raped?
 
It's a question of Scrut suggesting that an 8-year old girl, repeatedly raped, was seeking someone "better". Even as a joke, it is poor taste. Very poor taste.

Not a joke. Given the laws and customs of the area she would have to be in the custody of some man or another so yes she would have been hopeing that the court chose someone better.

However given the lawyer's statement and the unlikelyhood of an 8 year old thinking of asking for a divorce I suspect there was an outside group involved we are not being told about.
 
Not a joke. Given the laws and customs of the area she would have to be in the custody of some man or another so yes she would have been hopeing that the court chose someone better.
Still a sick remark; the girl shouldn't be married at such an early age and she didn't want to. Kudos to her having the guts going to court.

As to the customs: a man doesn't mean a husband. Normally, she would still be at her parents. Seeing they're unfit, then what about foster parents?

Dutch late night news had a clip on this too. They showed, a.o., the judge saying that "not the laws are at fault, but the parents marrying their daughters at too early an age" :jaw-dropp

Furthermore, they added that the court awarded the ex-husband a compensation of 150 euros (200 dollars), and they showed someone eagerly paying it, handing a big wad of bills to the judge.
 
Last edited:
(Originally Posted by CFLarsen View Post
It's a question of Scrut suggesting that an 8-year old girl, repeatedly raped, was seeking someone "better". Even as a joke, it is poor taste. Very poor taste.)

Is that a "fact" or an "opinion"?

Whatever else it is, or whomever else's opinion it may be, it is my opinion. But, hey, I'm listening - try to change my opinion.
 
Off topic!

Thanks. It was assigned to me in the "Let someone else choose your avatar" thread. I will avenge myself!


You couldn't pay me enough to join that thread, even though I think that you got a good one! Well, now that I think of it, perhaps you could.
 
Oh, please.

Instead of hailing her courage, you chose to mock that she was raped repeatedly, by suggesting she wanted a divorce so she could find someone "better".

What the hell were you thinking?? That she liked being raped, but just weren't satisfied with the old man who was raping her?

Or maybe you don't even think this 8-year old girl was raped?

Climb down off your cross. I could use the wood.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom