16 yo verbally assaulted for wearing a MAGA hat

Are we sure he is a 'leftist'? Lots of people hate the President and even more detest what the MAGA hat has come to be associated with. It's being framed as right v left when it should properly be right MAGAs v everyone else

If it's magas vs everyone else, kind of a clear punch down. Hypocrisy is fun.
 
I've noted before this is what happens with tribalism, the people most emotionally invested in it have to start outdoing each other to prove they are the causest of the cause.

This, broadly, goes through 3 stages:

1. I hate X.
2. I hate people who don't hate X.
3. I hate people who don't hate X enough.

And if the cause reaches stage 3 without resolution, stage 3 will get refined over and over to define "don't hate enough" more and more stringently as the "Keepers of the Cause" all try to outdo each other to keep the Cause's Bloodline Pure.

This is how you get to the point that a kid being harassed over wearing a hat makes sense to you.

I don't punch every try-hard edge lord wearing a Che Guevera shirt I see despite I personally guarantee you disagreeing with the politics of Che Guevera as much or mor than anyone here disagrees with the politics of Donald Trump. It ain't that hard.
 
well he was a member of the green party, so....

But under the circumstances perhaps it should be Kino and his inexplicable supporters v. everyone else, no?

Why the **** am I agreeing with you?

Yes it should be, but somehow enough people think there is wiggle room in harming kids that there is a debate.

And it's likely the same people who were wearing the abortion shirt (or is subculture variant, "**** the police" as one example) with me 20 years ago. Funny how when it's kids doing different stupid **** than you suddenly the "ban it, rough em up and teach em a lesson" logic becomes so appealing.
 
Some fraudsters claimed an "eyewitness" claimed the kids were making racial comments and the like before Kino started his attack..

This story is a complete hoax
 
I've noted before this is what happens with tribalism, the people most emotionally invested in it have to start outdoing each other to prove they are the causest of the cause.

This, broadly, goes through 3 stages:

1. I hate X.
2. I hate people who don't hate X.
3. I hate people who don't hate X enough.

And if the cause reaches stage 3 without resolution, stage 3 will get refined over and over to define "don't hate enough" more and more stringently as the "Keepers of the Cause" all try to outdo each other to keep the Cause's Bloodline Pure.

This is how you get to the point that a kid being harassed over wearing a hat makes sense to you.

I don't punch every try-hard edge lord wearing a Che Guevera shirt I see despite I personally guarantee you disagreeing with the politics of Che Guevera as much or mor than anyone here disagrees with the politics of Donald Trump. It ain't that hard.

What kills me is it is my tribe. The same folks that were protesting to wear DRI ,misfits , gwar, Tupac, etc. Gear when they were that age now actually have to think "is it okay to do that to a kid if they are doing something I don't like? " before answering for fear of not being true enough to the cause.

If the cause tells you is okay to harm a kid, find a new *********** cause. I can think of two ww2 movies in which saving a Nazi kid from that life was a major plot point because it was obvious morality. What the **** changed with us?
 
Maybe it's because I'm Canadian but as someone who disliked both parties (Clinton and Trump) during the election I simply don't understand where the ties to nazism and white supremacy are coming from. Also concentration camps for children lol.

Is my ignorance and/or confusion and/or disagreement evidence that I'm one of the nazis or something?

So here's one sequence of events that might give some background context. I don't think this is a comprehensive answer to your question, though.

During the 2016 presidential campaign, in private events with donors, Hillary Clinton had a bit she liked to do, about Trump supporters being in three camps, or "baskets".

One was the basket of Republican die-hards - people who will vote for anyone with an (R) after the name. Another was the basket of people who'd lost their jobs or livelihoods. And the third was the infamous basket of racists, homopobes, etc. - the "deplorables"

Now, this is not a particularly problematic categorization. It's a little broad-brushed, but whatever. And in private, among friends, the bit played well. People understood and appreciated the point she was making.

But. A month or two later, at a public event, battling pneumonia and probably a little worn out, she offered a modified version of the bit, with only two baskets - half of Trump voters were now "deplorables". This wasn't private, off the record. This was in public, and the press reported on it. The campaign immediately realized it was a mistake, but the damage was already done.

(Source. Convenience source.)

We had a slapfight here a few months ago, about whether non-deplorable conservatives should rightly feel insulted by Clinton's "deplorables" remark, since she did say they were only half of Trump voters. The counter-argument was that the "basket of deplorables" was a kind of dog whistle, and that those with eyes to see and ears to hear would understand that she meant all Trump voters. I thought the counter-argument was correct, but after learning a bit more about the origin of the "baskets of voters" idea, I think that Hillary was probably trying to make a good-faith disinction. "You also had some very fine people on both sides,” so to speak.

Anyway, fast forward a couple months, and we see the idea continues to mutate. Where there were once three, nuanced "baskets", now we have a single "everyone who supports Trump is objectively a Nazi". This is coupled with a growing enthusiasm on the left for political violence. Calling someone a Nazi makes it moral to physically assault them for their politics - regardless of their actual politics.

That's how I understand it, anyway. Others may see things differently. I expect you'll see a lot of outraged replies to my analysis, but no actual rebuttals, and a lot of excuse-making in favor of more political violence from the left.
 
Last edited:
well he was a member of the green party, so....

But under the circumstances perhaps it should be Kino and his inexplicable supporters v. everyone else, no?

True, Kino is pretty lonely in his corner right about now. I meant that the MAGA hat has more of a social meaning than a political one, IMO anyway. Rather than symbolizing traditional Republican principles of fiscal responsibility, strong defense, et al, it has come to represent the more negative and divisive elements in Conservativism. That us what I perceive a punk like Kino railing against.
 
Some fraudsters claimed an "eyewitness" claimed the kids were making racial comments and the like before Kino started his attack..

This story is a complete hoax

Don't care, they are kids they will yell ****. You are an adult grow the **** up, no excuse. True or no, it has no bearing.

If a kid is coming at you with a weapon, by all means stomp the little nazi to death. But if you are not in immediate fear for your life as an adult you walk away.
 
Don't care, they are kids they will yell ****. You are an adult grow the **** up, no excuse. True or no, it has no bearing.

If a kid is coming at you with a weapon, by all means stomp the little nazi to death. But if you are not in immediate fear for your life as an adult you walk away.

To clarify, there is a hoax going around that the three kids were making racist remarks, which story was absolutely and completely false.
 
So here's one sequence of events that might give some background context. I don't think this is a comprehensive answer to your question, though.

During the 2016 presidential campaign, in private events with donors, Hillary Clinton had a bit she liked to do, about Trump supporters being in three camps, or "baskets".

One was the basket of Republican die-hards - people who will vote for anyone with an (R) after the name. Another was the basket of people who'd lost their jobs or livelihoods. And the third was the infamous basket of racists, homopobes, etc. - the "deplorables"

Now, this is not a particularly problematic categorization. It's a little broad-brushed, but whatever. And in private, among friends, the bit played well. People understood and appreciated the point she was making.

But. A month or two later, at a public event, battling pneumonia and probably a little worn out, she offered a modified version of the bit, with only two baskets - half of Trump voters were now "deplorables". This wasn't private, off the record. This was in public, and the press reported on it. The campaign immediately realized it was a mistake, but the damage was already done.

(Source. Convenience source.)

We had a slapfight here a few months ago, about whether non-deplorable conservatives should rightly feel insulted by Clinton's "deplorables" remark, since she did say they were only half of Trump voters. The counter-argument was that the "basket of deplorables" was a kind of dog whistle, and that those with eyes to see and ears to hear would understand that she meant all Trump voters. I thought the counter-argument was correct, but after learning a bit more about the origin of the "baskets of voters" idea, I think that Hillary was probably trying to make a good-faith disinction. "You also had some very fine people on both sides,” so to speak.

Anyway, fast forward a couple months, and we see the idea continues to mutate. Where there were once three, nuanced "baskets", now we have a single "everyone who supports trump is objectively a Nazi". This is coupled with a growing enthusiasm on the left for political violence. Calling someone a Nazi makes it moral to physically assault them for their politics - regardless of their actual politics.

That's how I understand it, anyway. Others may see things differently. I expect you'll see a lot of outraged replies to my analysis, but no actual rebuttals, and a lot of excuse-making in favor of more political violence from the left.

I didn't know about the 3 categories in private settings context before. That is interesting, thanks.
 
Well, one of them was wearing a MAGA hat so why wouldn't they be making remarks?

Not all wearers of MAGA hats go around spouting Trump-like rhetoric on a constant basis, that's why. Some of them (most of the ones I spot) simply wear them out and about to evince silent support.

Unless/until there is definitive proof that these kids were spouting rhetoric, I prefer to err on the side of them not saying anything. There is evidence for the verbal/physical attack on the kid wearing the hat; there is none to prove they were spouting Trumpish rhetoric prior to the incident happening.
 
Look, if you wear a hat with the logo of a filthy bigot, it's not too hard to believe that you're also a the kind of person who makes racist comments. Why would he have the hat on if he weren't a racist?
 
People do get that pushing the "They're a Trump supporter, there is nothing they aren't capable of" rhetoric further and further doesn't make you a better Liberal right?

Political Tribalism is not a dump stat in an RPG. You're not going to unlock a new ability when you put enough points into it.
 
Well, one of them was wearing a MAGA hat so why wouldn't they be making remarks?

Couple of points, they were not actually making the remarks so it was a lie, indeed they were not all wearing such hats, but to add insult to injury someone took the time to spread the lie that they were all making racist violent comments (which they were not) which only further led to numerous more threats against them.

But I am getting from your question that you consider that a feature and not a bug.

Free Kino, huh?
 
Look, if you wear a hat with the logo of a filthy bigot, it's not too hard to believe that you're also a the kind of person who makes racist comments. Why would he have the hat on if he weren't a racist?

Oh, i think anyone sporting that cap is likely racist. Many keep it quiet, though, and the cap is more like a dog whistle. Kind of pointless now, as its meaning is out in the open. But I doubt seriously that these scrawny kids were being vocal in public. I believe this because they appear to have their teeth where they belong.
 
If someone has an a KKK white sheet, I'm not going to have a hard time believing they used the "N word".

Yeah, this wasn't a white sheet, and it turns out that people were flat out lying lying, but I get that you would prefer to accept the hoax against the three kids because one had a MAGA hat.

That being said it is pretty clear that even without the hoax, the mere act of wearing the hat is enough to justify the attack, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom