16 yo verbally assaulted for wearing a MAGA hat

TBD, are you seriously claiming that some white supremacists do not use it independently of its historical and political origins? Pretty strong Poe, even for you.
 
TBD, are you seriously claiming that some white supremacists do not use it independently of its historical and political origins? Pretty strong Poe, even for you.

That isn't an even remotely reasonable reading of his post.
 
Only in your mind. Many in my family wear them and they are not white supremacists in any way.

Look around, even on this very thread. Its not exactly just me.

My very conservative stepfather wears a Pepe the frog pin sometimes. He has no idea what it means either. Society does have some say in what the meaning of a given symbol means, and MAGA hats are solidly swinging towards white supremacy (a littly unfairly, IMO)
 
Has the second Thug who was filming the attack been identified.

He ought to be charged with being an accessory.
 
Comparing a MAGA hat to a Swatiska is so profoundly ignorant of history, so exaggerated that in fact doing so that it actually energetically diminishes the horrors of the Nazi regime, indeed in doing so one is metaphorically dumping a glass of coke on the heads of holocaust survivors.

Not surprised that the tolatarian left is melting down like this.

You got off to a great start, then stumbled right before the finish line.
 
TBD, are you seriously claiming that some white supremacists do not use it independently of its historical and political origins? Pretty strong Poe, even for you.

Oy vey.

I was talking about people comparing MAGA hats to the swastika.

Talk about a strong poe, smdh
 
Well, no. First off, while white supremacists in the US like to appropriate the swastika, its prior meaning as a symbol for the Nazi party is still its primary association, and that primary association is sufficient to make it reprehensible. Its use by white supremacists doesn't make it more reprehensible than it already was.

Second, while white supremacists have also used the MAGA hat, that isn't how it originated either. And white supremacists aren't the only people who use the hat. It seems to me that you want to make it into a white supremacist symbol by stigmatizing it in the hopes that only white supremacists will be left wearing it.

You're black-and-whiting the issue. Yes, both symbols had different origins. In one socially very visible context, they have become associated with white power. That's a taint, fairly or not. I could just as well say I wear a swastika hearkening its good luck origins. But no one else will perceive it that way.
 
Last edited:
MAGA hats have come to be a generic symbol of white supremacy, much as the swastika has evolved to be. To pretend not to understand this is quite profoundly ignorant.

MAGA hats mean different things to different people. Blacks and Hispanics own and wear MAGA hats and it is not a symbol of white supremacy to them.

I think it depends on where you live. Out my way (Orange Co., CA), there are plenty of minorities who support Trump.
 
Democrats are violent by nature. It helps Republicans get elected, but they are just not disciplined enough to refrain from violence. Recall after the violent leftists at the 1968 Democrat Convention were beat down by Mayor Daley's police, and fake news talked about it daily right up to the election, the country elected Nixon. After Kent State, which was the worst thing that ever happened according to Rolling Stone and the rest of fake news, Nixon was reelected. Democrats want anarchy, the rest of us want law and order.
 
MAGA hats mean different things to different people. Blacks and Hispanics own and wear MAGA hats and it is not a symbol of white supremacy to them.

A handful of black/Hispanic/Catholic people also insist that the KKK weren't a hate group. Lots of people insist that the Confederacy had nothing to do with slavery.

Both were/are still white supremacist, though.

Just like Dolt 45 is a white supremacist, today. Some people ignoring his open hostility to nonwhite people doesn't change matters. I won't attack you for wearing a MAGA hat, but don't expect me to trust anyone wearing one.
 
Let's take the scenario of a teen wearing a MAGA hat, minding their own business in a public place...

What might that confrontation consist of? What benefit might it achieve? Given human nature, do you think the hat-wearer is apt to be more or less likely to support Trump after being confronted?

I would politely inform the youngster that the hat he's wearing is a symbol of hate and oppression for many people, and that I hope he doesn't really want to be associated with that. I would likely be flipped off.

I would then leave it at that, having made my point.

/ETA: If he was using racist language, I would be much more aggressive in my approach, stopping short of getting physical.
 
Last edited:
I would politely inform the youngster that the hat he's wearing is a symbol of hate and oppression for many people, and that I hope he doesn't really want to be associated with that. I would likely be flipped off.

How do you feel about Che t-shirts?
 
MAGA hats have come to be a generic symbol of white supremacy, much as the swastika has evolved to be. To pretend not to understand this is quite profoundly ignorant.

Aren't you the same guy who argued with me for weeks that antifa symbols don't really have the meaning associated with their history?
 
Aren't you the same guy who argued with me for weeks that antifa symbols don't really have the meaning associated with their history?

Don't forget his arguments that their beliefs were diverse and you couldn't stereotype them.
 
Aren't you the same guy who argued with me for weeks that antifa symbols don't really have the meaning associated with their history?

Just think about that for a moment. Nah, I'll do it for you.

I argued that antifa symbols had lost their original meaning in favor of the new, looser alternate.

I am now arguing that MAGA hats are losing their original meaning in favor of the new, looser alternate.

You were saying?
 
I am now arguing that MAGA hats are losing their original meaning in favor of the new, looser alternate.

No, you aren't. The alternate meaning you are proposing isn't looser at all. It's significantly narrower.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom