14 Years of Catholic School

Nim Chimpsky

Thinker
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
153
I really felt the need to share this paper with the world. The very quick back story:

Dad (me) and mom married in 1989, daughter born in 1990. We were both regular Sunday Catholics. Mom had a totally wacked out conversion in 1993. Became a crazed catholic: daily mass, adoration, relics, paranoia, mysticism....she bought the whole whole farm. Dad becomes atheist because of mom.
Separated in 1999, daughter goes with mom back to CO where her family is from.
Dad moves back to CO in 2005, daughter comes to live with me and current partner (she's atheist too).

After 14 years of Catholic education, in her senior theology class, she was required to write an "I Believe" paper. Of course the school is hoping that they turn out nice robotic catholics and want the kids to write about it. They then re-affirm their mission armed with all these wonderful little missives.

My kid took the road less traveled and told the truth. She paid the price, a nice big ole fat "D". It was factored into her final exam grade and took her from an A to C on that test and lowered her overall grade from an A to a B+.

For your reading pleasure, the paper:

(my favorite parts are bolded)




My life, thus far, has been somewhat of a roller coaster ride. I’ve been told exactly what to think and exactly what not to think. I’ve been told how I should live and how I should not live. It was only until recently I became aware that I had none of my own thoughts, opinions, or beliefs. I was a melange of input and guidance from my parents, friends, and teachers simply trying to fulfill the life they all told me I should be living. About two years ago, I moved in with my father, a devout atheist and self-proclaimed skeptic. This was quite a remarkable change from living with my strict, Roman Catholic mother my entire life. The transition threw my very persona into a whirlwind. Ever since then, I have begun to question things I have always thought to be fact. I have developed my own beliefs and become my own person. I feel it’s sort of like a coming of age thing since I’m about to turn eighteen. I feel like I’m finally maturing and developing my mind. I believe that facts should be questioned and beliefs challenged, and if they can’t overcome challenges, maybe they aren’t facts or beliefs at all.
I, like many of my fellow classmates in the senior class at St _______'s High School, am about to complete my fourteenth year of Catholic schooling. I feel very grateful but sometimes a little disappointed for all of these years. There is no doubt that the education I received will lead me, very well prepared, into a successful future. However, my only criticism of Catholic schooling is the very fact that it is Catholic schooling. Maybe that is contradictory, but I’ll explain. I feel that first through twelfth grade is the time of ultimate development and growth for anyone in which the mind absorbs more than it will ever again. These developmental years are the years that children should be taught to create their own opinions and strengthen their morals. They shouldn’t be forced to learn to practice a certain relgious lifestyle, because the religion one practices absolutely becomes his life. This is a decision in which young children are neither capable nor informed enough to make. I respect my mother, and all parents, for trying to guide their children into the path which most suits them, but it isn’t right. Personally, I went on through eighth grade memorizing prayers that didn’t mean a word to me and sitting lackadaisically and less than enthused in church every Sunday. I was confirmed that year, but don’t ask me why. I still couldn’t even tell you the importance that event holds in my life. It was just what you did in eighth grade. To my mother’s dismay, I stopped going to Church about two years ago because I realized it served absolutely no purpose in my life. I believe that if I became aware of Catholicism on my own terms and at a time when I could truly understand what I was practicing, I could possibly be a much more enthusiastic Catholic right now. But I’m not. Maybe I’m just worn out on Catholicism, or maybe I don’t believe it all. I don’t know. What I do know is that when I make a decision, it will be my own.
I think it’s naive to believe that Catholicism is the “one true religion.” There are hundreds of relgions in this world that make the very same claim. How does anyone know that they are right and the others are wrong? I could never get over this fact. One thing I have learned over the years is that it is useless to argue with a Catholic, specifically my mom. I wouldn’t dare start that argument with her ever, ever again. For a lot of people, religion is a crutch. They use it as a method of searching for someone to blame and hopelessly scrambling for an easy way to solve their own problems. This is certainly not true for everyone, but I have learned firsthand that it is, sadly, quite common. Generally, Catholics are stubborn and quite narrow-minded and will not have anything you say that is not what they believe. This has pushed me further and further from the Catholic Church. I couldn’t understand how a group of seemingly kind and normal people could be so ignorant and resistant to challenges to their religion. Perhaps I’m a little bitter considering my childhood consisted of saying novenas and rosaries and going to morning mass every day during summer. I hate the fact that I was forced into that life.
Maybe I will return to Catholicism one day, or maybe I will travel down an entirely different path. I have no idea what my future holds, but Catholicism is not on the agenda in my near future. I am diving head-first into a time of confusion, growth, discovery, and hopefully a life of happiness, whatever I decide. I believe that a sharp and skeptical mind is the single most important tool I can have with me on my road to becoming an all-around successful person. I have strong morals, and a sturdy head on my shoulders. I don’t know if I’ve exactly fulfilled the task of the “this I believe” essay, but this is a small taste of my life. I’m confused, but ready for anything the world can throw at me. I feel that it’s my time now.




All I did when she moved in with me was tell her to challenge things, read both sides of an argument and then make up your own mind. I put very few of these thoughts into her mind DIRECTLY, but obviously, through osmosis, she picked up a healthy skepticism.

I couldn't be prouder.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like you did a good job. I feel the same way, that the best way to change someone's mind on this topic is not to jam atheism down their throat in the same manner that religion has been. Usually presenting someone with some ideas and allowing them space to decide for themselves is a better idea for them in the long run.

I had a similar situation with my wife, who was raised in a religious family (Jehovah's Witnesses). She was 16 when I met her, on the cusp of possibly being baptised. Even though she decided not to, she spent about the first 5 years we were together not really agreeing with my religious views. I never pushed anything on her, just gave her the experience of seeing it through an outsider's eyes.

The only downside is I actually get along with her family. I'm pretty non-confrontational, and we just leave it unspoken that we hold different religious views, but they've welcomed me into their family. There are times, however, that they'll mention something in passing about their beliefs, and while I sit quietly trying to mind my own business, my wife will say something like "don't you ever stop to think about if that really even makes any sense?" That's usually when it gets a bit awkward.
 
Your daughter is fortunate to have you as a father, and she will be fine, now. She is very mature for her 18 years. A "C" is a very minor price to pay for the gift of reason, compared to the price in integrity that the teacher pays for awarding the grade. It was a well written and sincere work.
 
Was there a justification for the 'D'? I'm not an English teacher, but it appears to be a well-written essay and fulfilled the assignment.

Of course, the assignment should truthfully be "What I'm Supposed to Believe".

Catholic school brain-washing doesn't always take as I can personally attest to. Your daughter sounds like a very mature young lady ready to embark on making her way in the world.
 
Congratulations on raising your daughter well.

Remember, even a "C" student can grow up to be President one day...wait...bad example, never mind. :o
 
Was there a justification for the 'D'? I'm not an English teacher, but it appears to be a well-written essay and fulfilled the assignment.

I was wondering this myself. In public school, wouldn't the teach have to point out the errors that made it deserving of a D? Is that different in private school?

Also, in the spirit of fairness, we should point out the contributions that Catholic Schools have made to the world.

I'll start:
The uniforms (!!!)
 
I went on through eighth grade memorizing prayers that didn’t mean a word to me and sitting lackadaisically and less than enthused in church every Sunday. I was confirmed that year, but don’t ask me why. I still couldn’t even tell you the importance that event holds in my life. It was just what you did in eighth grade


I was raised as Catholic, but attended public school, and only Sunday school for the whole indoctrination thing. My experience of confirmation was pretty much the exact same, which really amazes me. You'd think being a full-time Catholic, they'd actually be able to take five minutes and explain what it actually meant, or at least give a bit more info than I had, as a part-time, might-as-well-be-protestant Catholic.
 
Last edited:
Was there a justification for the 'D'? I'm not an English teacher, but it appears to be a well-written essay and fulfilled the assignment.

Full Disclosure: I'm not an English teacher but my degree is in Speech Communications and English. I work in the communications field for a living. I have taught a literature course in the past, but only the one.

Assumptions: Without more than Nim Chimpsky, I assume the author met all other criteria of the assignment such as page minimum and maximums, source requirements, citations, etc. I would guess this is not the case, since it was such a large part of the author's grade. But this has not factored into my review.

While the sentiments the author is conveying are well conceived the overall structure of the essay is not. The theses statements (there are multiple) come in the middle and the end of the essay when, given the length, a single thesis should have been refined from the multiple ideas and been presented in the very first paragraph. The support for the statements is found throughout the body of the essay, but without a single theme to drive them this is more of a shotgun pattern, rather than cohesive and plainly stated contentions leading to a logical conclusion. The conclusion should be a summation of the entire essay, drawing together the main and supporting points and leading directly back to the opening thesis. It does not. In fact, the final paragraph reads as what should have been the author's first paragraph, which then would have better defined and driven the overall essay.

While it does convey the author beliefs, as a senior-level high school essay turned in as an assignment for a grade of this magnitude, in my opinion, it is a below-average (D-level) effort at best.

Catholic school brain-washing doesn't always take as I can personally attest to. Your daughter sounds like a very mature young lady ready to embark on making her way in the world.

Yes, she does sound very mature, and her willingness to turn this essay in, with its sentiments so boldly stated should be applauded. It was a brave thing for her to do, and not something I would have bent my own will to do at her age under the same strictures.
 
Last edited:
Your daughter is fortunate to have you as a father, and she will be fine, now. She is very mature for her 18 years. A "C" is a very minor price to pay for the gift of reason, compared to the price in integrity that the teacher pays for awarding the grade. It was a well written and sincere work.

Thank you very much. I quit my job in San Fran and dragged my significant other with me kicking and screaming. But in the end, we are both so glad that we moved to get her through HS.

Was there a justification for the 'D'? I'm not an English teacher, but it appears to be a well-written essay and fulfilled the assignment.

Of course, the assignment should truthfully be "What I'm Supposed to Believe".

Catholic school brain-washing doesn't always take as I can personally attest to. Your daughter sounds like a very mature young lady ready to embark on making her way in the world.

Ironically, she turned in their "major" or big paper in theology a couple of weeks ago. She did stem cell research and basically said that the Catholic church is wrong to prevent embryonic stem cell research. On that paper, she got the highest grade in the class. Even though it was a 90.5, nobody did better than 82.

Your daughter is the kind of person that I would hire over any mind-locked dogmatist. You have every reason to be proud.

Congratulations. :D

It has all been worth it. Thanks fnord.

Full Disclosure: I'm not an English teacher but my degree is in Speech Communications and English. I work in the communications field for a living.



While it does convey what the author beliefs, as a senior-level high school essay turned in as an assignment for a grade of this magnitude, in my opinion, it is a below-average (D-level) effort at best.



Yes, she does sound very mature, and her willingness to turn this essay in, with its sentiments so boldly stated should be applauded.

What's so funny Robroy, is that I gave her almost the same exact critique as you did. I pointed out a few contradictions, the lack of structure and few other minor grammatical errors. I did this AFTER I told her how proud I was and asked her permission to critique. (she really didn't HAVE to hear it as she still did well in the class and was done, but did so because she really does want to learn.)


The "D", what I was told by the instructor, was NOT his doing. The theology teacher they have is not the typical Catholic school theology teacher. He really does have an open mind and encourages discourse in the class. As I said about the stem cell paper, he realized that she did have cogent arguments, good support and better structure.

This paper was graded by the principal. Spindrift hit on it:

Of course, the assignment should truthfully be "What I'm Supposed to Believe".


This new guy that they brought in as principal just in the past few weeks is going to get the school "back in line" with catholic tradition. The last few principals were career "head administrators" who really weren't all that catholic. They emphasized academics as the #1 priority. The dress code was fairly relaxed and it was a fairly fun school.

The new guy is bringing back white shirts and ties for the boys and skirts and blouses for girls. They used to do a monthly mass, but I hear they are talking about doing AT LEAST a weekly mass. And I have heard that he intends to bring back as many nuns as possible. There are currently zero teaching now.

His comment on the paper (2nd hand info) was that it didn't say enough about catholicism and he didn't think that she really believed what she wrote.

I have no intention whatsoever of arguing or contesting it. I just want her to graduate next week and get the h e double tooth picks out of there.
 
While it does convey the author beliefs, as a senior-level high school essay turned in as an assignment for a grade of this magnitude, in my opinion, it is a below-average (D-level) effort at best.


Well, RR, I guess I think less of high school students than you do. I found the grammar and sentence structure superior to the average high school effort. The essay also managed to stay on point and there were few digressions.

Of course, your criticism is correct. The overall structure is poor. Still, I have found that most college students can't properly structure an essay.

Depending on what the assignment actually was, I would have graded it as roughly a B.

It should be noted, however, that as a parent, I would never make an issue of this with the school. The child is hours away from graduating and being done with the place forever. As a private school, they could expell her five minutes before her last exam. The chance of harm to the girl's future is far, far too great to even contemplate challenging the grade on this assignment.


n.b. Nim should be very proud of having raised such an independent and thoughtful child.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me if the principal changed the grade that this could be seen as discrimination(I'm not suggesting you make a federal case about it but still). If the Theocracy teacher thought it deserved a higher grade but was downgraded because of religous differences that's, well, discrimination isn't it? Before you say that they have a right to grade how they want to in a Private school I'd say that this is like marking a paper in math wrong because they believe that 2+2 = 5. Anyway, sounds like you have very intelligent daughter, congratulations.
 
I was wondering this myself. In public school, wouldn't the teach have to point out the errors that made it deserving of a D? Is that different in private school?

Also, in the spirit of fairness, we should point out the contributions that Catholic Schools have made to the world.

I'll start:
The uniforms (!!!)

CATH-O-LIC Girls

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVPIwTwGz8o





NSFW
 
Last edited:
Seems to me if the principal changed the grade that this could be seen as discrimination(I'm not suggesting you make a federal case about it but still). If the Theocracy teacher thought it deserved a higher grade but was downgraded because of religous differences that's, well, discrimination isn't it? Before you say that they have a right to grade how they want to in a Private school I'd say that this is like marking a paper in math wrong because they believe that 2+2 = 5. Anyway, sounds like you have very intelligent daughter, congratulations.


The way I interpreted what the theology teacher told me was that the principal actually graded the papers, not the teacher. He sort of stepped in to gauge what the kids have learned in 4 years.

But again, I have zero interest in pushing this any further. That school alone has sucked $30,000 out of my wallet the past 4 years and I really don't want to spend another dime nor ounce of energy dealing with them any further than the grad ceremony. I just want them to send out the final transcript and send her a diploma.
 
What's so funny Robroy, is that I gave her almost the same exact critique as you did. I pointed out a few contradictions, the lack of structure and few other minor grammatical errors. I did this AFTER I told her how proud I was and asked her permission to critique. (she really didn't HAVE to hear it as she still did well in the class and was done, but did so because she really does want to learn.)

Good. Glad to hear we're on the same page. I was hoping I didn't come off mean or anything like that. Just a legitimate critique of an essay.

The "D", what I was told by the instructor, was NOT his doing. The theology teacher they have is not the typical Catholic school theology teacher. He really does have an open mind and encourages discourse in the class. As I said about the stem cell paper, he realized that she did have cogent arguments, good support and better structure.

This paper was graded by the principal.

Interesting. What would the instructor have given her?

His comment on the paper (2nd hand info) was that it didn't say enough about catholicism and he didn't think that she really believed what she wrote.

Now, that's a bold statement to make. I wonder how he determined what she actually believes from what she states she believes?

Loss Leader said:
Well, RR, I guess I think less of high school students than you do. I found the grammar and sentence structure superior to the average high school effort. The essay also managed to stay on point and there were few digressions.

Could be. Or perhaps I just think that the concept of an introductory paragraph with thesis and three main points shouldn't be that tricky to knock out of the park. But then, admittedly, this is my bread and butter.

I do note that her grammar and sentence structure is pretty solid. Not great, but there is potential there if she can find structure. I should have mentioned this in the critique. :D
 
These developmental years are the years that children should be taught to create their own opinions and strengthen their morals

Um morals are opinions. If you don't want to inforce opinions on the kids the closest you can get to that statement would be along the lines of "increase their understanding of the dominant ethical code within their societly and the penalties for not following it".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom