10 year old set on fire by bullies

Carnivore

Salad Dodger
Joined
Apr 12, 2006
Messages
1,898
Location
Manchester UK
Kayden Culp, who is described as having "special needs" and displaying autistic behaviour, was playing with some other other boys when they allegedly doused him in gasoline and set him on fire. Badly burned over 20% of his body, he is currently in an induced coma, fighting infection and on medication to stabilize his heart. His mother describes his alleged attackers as boys that Kayden considered his friends but who would routinely mock and bully him. Kaydens family assert that the attack was both deliberate and premeditated based on the reports of local children.
 
I'm missing the "social issue" aspect. Feels like gawking.

Maybe that's it. Maybe it's meta. The rise of tragedy porn.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry...come-tragedy-porn_us_57b5e672e4b095b2f5430806

I guess I can see that, I thought the social issue was the treatment of people not behaviourally "normal" by wider society. In the coverage of the recent case where the cops tried repeatedly to run over a man running on the highway and eventually cornered him and shot him 14 times, I read that a quarter of the 700 some people killed by US police this year suffered from some from some form of mental illness. Would these kids have burned any of their acquaintences? If not, why did they think Kayden was fair game?
 
I think for a thread to work there has to be at least some controversy, in this case I would hope that no-one would disagree that these 'friends' were sub-human little shirts who need to spend the next couple of decades somewhere with locks on the door and bars on the windows.
 
I think for a thread to work there has to be at least some controversy, in this case I would hope that no-one would disagree that these 'friends' were sub-human little shirts who need to spend the next couple of decades somewhere with locks on the door and bars on the windows.

I disagree. :boggled: Two decades seems too short. This kind of crime seems worse than murder, because there's a good chance the victim will live for years, maybe a normal life after a decade of care, horribly disfigured and in constant pain, needing ongoing family help. That seems worse than death, especially if it can be established the perpetrators were aware of the potential outcome. Young or mentally handicapped juveniles might not be aware, and there's not enough information on this case, but older juveniles and adults of normal intelligence surely know what happens when you set someone on fire.

If murderers would get life, and these juveniles are tried as adults, they should get life. That fits with Carnivore's question about what do we do with such people, because, on the other hand, what good does locking them up for life really serve, especially compared to a longer sentence like 20 years. Are they that much at risk of burning someone else? Could they be rehabilitated? But is a few years in jail, then free, a fair sentence when Kayden is still suffering then and for years later (guessing)? It's the age-old question about punishment, rehabilitation, social needs, etc., that's virtually unanswerable.

And then the tragedy porn aspect. Though I thought folks had been loving tragedy since before and after Shakespearean stabbings on stage, stereo photos of US Civil War bodies, public hangings, etc. Seems it's just ingrained.
 
The story is a little confusing. Investigators are saying it was an accident that happened when all the boys were playing with gasoline but a relative said Kayden was only friends with one of the boys and they poured the gasoline on him on purpose. The investigation continues.

Police Chief David Knight said the youngsters, all friends, had started a fire in the shed on a vacant lot in the 800 block of Wallace Street. One of them went to get some gasoline to make it burn better, and the boy now in custody poured the gas from a container onto the fire, igniting gas still in the container.

The boy then discarded the can, resulting in Kayden being splashed with the flaming liquid, Knight said.
<snip>
Tristyn Hatchett said Wednesday that a relative of one of the four or five boys present during the incident told her afterward that one boy had poured gasoline on Culp and another boy ignited it.

Also, she noted, "The other boys who were there have been telling kids at school that it was not an accident, that it was intentional."

http://www.mysanantonio.com/news/lo...e-charged-with-arson-after-boy-10-9870595.php

More here.
 
It's interesting watching the story trend through the media. So far slightly more news stories are presenting it as bullies intentionally setting Kayden on fire. They are also calling him a "special needs" child - he wears a hearing aid and has a speech impediment.

Two gofundme campaigns have collected about 44k so far. The comments in some of the news reports are horrendous, with many posters saying the kids should be set on fire.

I get that a story like this arouses emotions - I fumed too when I read the first story. But after learning that maybe Kayden wasn't hurt intentionally (the investigation isn't over yet) I was a little ashamed of some of my thoughts. I didn't want the kids set on fire :eek: but I had some choice judgements about parents who raise bullies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom