10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oops. Wrong answer, chris. Admittedly, I am not a carpenter, but I know that you are wrong in saying that steel is always better than wood when it comes to fires.

Here's a hint: Ask a firefighter whether he would rather fight a fire in an older timber framed structure or a newer steel framed structure.


Correct. Large timbers (typically in excess of 6" thick") char on the outside, however this acts as protection for the inside which can then continue to act as a load bearing member. Steel, on the other hand, will weaken and fail without fire protection (or if the fire protection is compromised).

If you will, and of course if Chris is really a chippie then he will know this already, an intumescent coating on steel is designed to replicate this barrier layer effect in order to minimise the detrimetal effects of the fire on the steel.

Of course a real chippie would have noted that smaller timbers (note the terminology, Chris) such as floor joists and rafters (which are rarely more than 2 to 2.5" in width) do not benefit from this effect and hence "normal" timber (see, there it is again) framed houses can be very susceptible to fire. Also note that timber or wood (hahaha) surfaces tend to encourage a fast spread of flame without additional protective treatment.

In short, Chris, I think your bluffing about your qualification/expertise in an effort to bolster your strange, strange arguments here. But heck, that's just my opinion.
 
Funny. I read the appendix to which you link, and you seem to be missing its repeated use of the word "debris" throughout as a significant contributing factor in the intitating event.
They describe the damage but they never say the perimeter damage had any effect on the initiating event.

They acknowledge that "damage ..... of core framing is not known...".

They were wrong about "damage to elevator cars and shafts was reported to have occurred around columns 69 to 78 at floors 8 or 9."

That should read "columns 66 to 75"

wtc7fl8edit2ak2.png




3. The initiating event may have included a number of structural components. ....... Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75, 78 and 78A, ....."

They do not mention perimeter damage.

You do realize that "intiating event" refers to that event which began the actual collapse sequence--not the event that first damaged the building and first started the fires, right?
Right
 
Christopher7: You still haven’t addressed my question.
:deadhorse

You were correct the first time: Christopher7 is convinced that absolutely nothing that happened prior to the initiating event had anything to do with the collapse. Everything was fine until the initiating event, and had it not been for the initiating event, the building would have stood.
Therefore, the initiating event was CD.
Simple, huh?
 
Last edited:
They describe the damage but they never say the perimeter damage had any effect on the initiating event.


I sincerely appreciate your answering me. (I honestly expected to get laughed at. I'm a delicate little flower. ;))

But I still see this report as saying something different than you see.

I'm an expert, too, but not at buildings or construction, flying or demolition.
I'm an expert in English. And I read for comprehension.

When I want to understand complex writing, the first thing I read is the conclusion, and then I read the body. The conclusion summarizes everything nicely and helps you figure out what the body is saying. Now, I did read this whole document, this appendix. I scanned it from start to end first, then carefully read the conclusion, and then re-read the body with equal care (and now with higher comprehension). It's a reliable technique.

What's happening in this document, we call back-mapping. In this case, it is close to all you can do since the building is gone. These investigators know the ending--now they have to follow the ending backwards, in order to find the beginning.

And what they say is this:

NIST said:
L.3.2 Collapse Initiation Scenarios
For the collapse to have started, there must have been a component or group of components that failed first, referred to here as the initiating event, as shown in Fig. L–36. The initiating event may have included structural components severed or damaged by falling debris (I1.1) and/or structural components affected by fires (I1.2).

And this very plainly indicates damage from debris was a possible contributor to that intiating event. The use of careful language here ("may have," "and/or," and so forth) is because the building is gone. All they have are the same things we all have now: witness reports, photos, videos.... Artifacts. It is now, and has been since 2001, impossible to tell with 100% accuracy exactly what happened. But I'm betting they came very close.

Christopher7 said:
[/I]They acknowledge that "damage ..... of core framing is not known...".

They were wrong about "damage to elevator cars and shafts was reported to have occurred around columns 69 to 78 at floors 8 or 9."

These bits are taken out of context, and doing so can lend them the appearance of having a meaning they do not, in fact, have.

Here is the first snippet, in full context:

NIST said:
1. Debris damaged the south face of the perimeter moment frame and some interior core framing on the south side. The debris impact severed approximately a quarter to a third of the south face perimeter columns. The damaged floors are less certain, but reports indicate they occurred between the ground and up to Floors 15 or 20. The extent of damage, both structural and to fireproofing, of core framing is not known, but damage to elevator cars and shafts was reported to have occurred around columns 69to 78 at Floors 8 or 9

The sentence I have bolded above shows why taking this out of its context lends it a different meaning. Your quote, the italicized bits, "damage...is not known," is very different from "the extent of damage...is not known." The former says there is no damage, while the latter says "it was damaged, but exactly how much, we aren't sure."

Thus, your quote is disingenuous. I hope you didn't mean it to be.

As to your second quote, above:
Christopher7 said:
They were wrong about "damage to elevator cars and shafts was reported to have occurred around columns 69 to 78 at floors 8 or 9."
That should read "columns 66 to 75"


They were wrong that it was reported? Because that's all that says. It says those numbers were reported. Those reporting could have gotten the numbers wrong, true. But that would not be NIST's error. In fact, the language used is quite painstaking--the report is very careful to point out that a certain amount of this report is based on conjecture.

Christopher7 said:



3. The initiating event may have included a number of structural components. ....... Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75, 78 and 78A, ....."

They do not mention perimeter damage.

Yes, they do, but earlier. You have to read and accept the summary as a whole. You cannot separate a bit of it and say "X was never said!" If X was said in a previous paragraph, it doesn't need to be repeated in each of them. Once was enough, if you read the summary as a whole.

The entire paragraph in question reads:

3. The initiating event may have included a number of structural components, though the relative role of impact damage and fire need further investigation. Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75, 78, and 78A, the east transfer girder (which supports column 78A and frames into transfer truss #2), and adjacent framing and floor systems.

That is some tortuously careful language use there. And they openly admit the relative role of impact damage and fire needs further investigation. It is quite clear to me the writer of this document was doing his darnedest to say "Look, we will probably never know for certain, and we need to look at it some more. A lot of this is still conjecture. At the moment, however, this is our best guess."

In that case, Chris, I would not even begin to take this report as some kind of conclusive evidence of much, as you appear to be doing. It's far too iffy in this form, and at this time.

Again, pulling out snippets and making them dance the "absolutely certain" dance is disingenuous. This particular dog can't hunt.

I do thank you, however, for your respectful reply to me, and hope I have shown the same respect in replying to you.
 
Last edited:
I sincerely appreciate your answering me. (I honestly expected to get laughed at. I'm a delicate little flower. ;))

But I still see this report as saying something different than you see.

I'm an expert, too, but not at buildings or construction, flying or demolition.
I'm an expert in English. And I read for comprehension.

When I want to understand complex writing, the first thing I read is the conclusion, and then I read the body. The conclusion summarizes everything nicely and helps you figure out what the body is saying. Now, I did read this whole document, this appendix. I scanned it from start to end first, then carefully read the conclusion, and then re-read the body with equal care (and now with higher comprehension). It's a reliable technique.
.

THank you Thank yoiu Thank you!
As an engineer, used to this sort of thing, I read the stuff exactly as you are saying. Perhaps I missed some of what ChristopherX was doing because I knew what the report said, and was seeing the whole paragraph instead of the bit he grabbed.
"May have/could be the result of" is tech speak for "this is the most likely event, but there is a certain amount of uncertainty"
I think the twoofers are so poor at reading, and so good at cherry picking because they have to keep repeating things paragraph to paragraph. At least, that's how they get attention!
Did I say Thank you!?
 
Slingblade, as a non-technical observer, I also must say thank you. Chris is taking things out of context and trying to shove them down our throats.

You succintly stated why he is not only technically wrong, but wrong in his interpretation of the report as well.
 
And this is why they don't let engineers write papers without english people help. Good job slingblade.
 
And this is why they don't let engineers write papers without english people help. Good job slingblade.

I proofread some of the writing from our office for this very reason. Unfortunately one of my bosses is fond of sending off emails before I have a chance to check them, and he has possibly the worst spelling and grammar I've seen from a professional. Mine's not stellar, but at least I'm coherent.
 
I sincerely appreciate your answering me. (I honestly expected to get laughed at. I'm a delicate little flower. ;))

But I still see this report as saying something different than you see.

L.3.2
"The initiating event may have included structural components severed or damaged by falling debris. (I1.1)"

I1.1
"The initiating components may have included perimeter or interior columns that were severed or damaged by falling debris...."

I2.1
"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or south west facade."
I3.1
"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

I2.2
"Interior columns may have been severed or damaged by impacting debris."
I3.2
"If interior columns had been severed or severely deformed, they may have failed immediately."

And this very plainly indicates damage from debris was a possible contributor to that intiating event.
Yes, debris damage to the interior columns, not the perimeter columns.

It clearly rules out the damage to the perimeter columns as the cause of the initiating event.

They do not mention damage to the perimeter columns as a contributor to the initiating event.

They mention debris damage to the core columns and/or fire as the possible causes.

They separated the damage to the perimeter columns and the possible damage to the core columns for a reason.

They were in different areas of the building.

There is nothing in this section to suggest that damage to the perimeter columns contributed to the initiating event, quite the opposite.


These bits are taken out of context, and doing so can lend them the appearance of having a meaning they do not, in fact, have.

Here is the first snippet, in full context:
[see post 2365]
The sentence I have bolded above shows why taking this out of its context lends it a different meaning. Your quote, the italicized bits, "damage...is not known," is very different from "the extent of damage...is not known." The former says there is no damage, while the latter says "it was damaged, but exactly how much, we aren't sure."

Thus, your quote is disingenuous. I hope you didn't mean it to be.
You're right, i did take that out of context.
By including damage to fireproofing, they are pretty safe.
Damage to a core column is likely but not certain.

This is the only report of possible damage to core columns.

It is not in the area of the initiating event.

As to your second quote, above:

They were wrong that it was reported? Because that's all that says. It says those numbers were reported. Those reporting could have gotten the numbers wrong, true. But that would not be NIST's error. In fact, the language used is quite painstaking--the report is very careful to point out that a certain amount of this report is based on conjecture.
No, the people reporting the damage did not know the numbers of the core columns. They reported elevator cars in the hallway north of the elevator shaft.
Someone at NIST screwed up. They did not accurately compare the floor plan showing the column numbers with the one showing the location of the elevator shafts.

Yes, they do, but earlier. You have to read and accept the summary as a whole. You cannot separate a bit of it and say "X was never said!" If X was said in a previous paragraph, it doesn't need to be repeated in each of them. Once was enough, if you read the summary as a whole.
They ran the perimeter damage and the elevator cars in the hallway together, even through they were in different areas and non related.

By including the damage to the perimeter columns in the summary, they imply it contributed to the initiating event but they do not indicate what the connection was.

That is some tortuously careful language use there. And they openly admit the relative role of impact damage and fire needs further investigation. It is quite clear to me the writer of this document was doing his darnedest to say "Look, we will probably never know for certain, and we need to look at it some more. A lot of this is still conjecture. At the moment, however, this is our best guess."

In that case, Chris, I would not even begin to take this report as some kind of conclusive evidence of much, as you appear to be doing. It's far too iffy in this form, and at this time.
People here and elsewhere, say that this report is evidence to support the official story:

"WTC 7 collapsed due to debris damage and fire"

As you just stated, it's far to iffy in this form, and at this time.

I'm saying:

There is NO evidence that debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.


I do thank you, however, for your respectful reply to me, and hope I have shown the same respect in replying to you.
Yes, thank you.
 
I’ll try a forth time: Irrespective of whether or not it is supported by evidence, it is still by far and away the most parsimonious explanation. Don’t you think?

Answer the question CHRIS--It's a good one. If there were NO evidence of anything, which explanation makes the most sense?

eta: Chris we aren't using the report to prove our case, BTW, we're using it to describe why we think the official explanation makes the most sense. Yea, they might not be totally, 100% sure, but it kind of is the quintessential educated guess, I think.
 
Last edited:
Answer the question CHRIS--It's a good one. If there were NO evidence of anything, which explanation makes the most sense?

eta: Chris we aren't using the report to prove our case, BTW, we're using it to describe why we think the official explanation makes the most sense. Yea, they might not be totally, 100% sure, but it kind of is the quintessential educated guess, I think.


Absolutely. This really is a highly educated guess, and they aren't done investigating.

I don't live in the world of Absolute Certainty. I know how rare a thing that is. Most things in life don't come anywhere near "absolutely certain." I can accept that there are always going to be things we will never know about this. I can accept extrapolation.

The case is not so shaky that having to extrapolate certain things makes the report untenable. After having read the appendix as carefully as I did, I feel confident I have read the best and most parsimonious explanation of the events in WTC 7's collapse. That it was a natural event which followed from the severe damage suffered by the building. There was no CD, no intrigue, no plot. Nothing but tragedy.

Reading this appendix only reinforced my opinion.
 

Are you sure? Because if you are indeed stating that fire cannot cause serious damage to steel structures, then I'd like to open another thread where we can explore this issue further. This will save me clogging up your current WTC7 discussion.
 
Even if there isn’t (and I’m by no means agreeing on that point), it’s still by far and away the most parsimonious explanation. Don’t you think?
I looked up your $4 word and answered your question in the next post.

parsimonious: frugal
very frugal or ungenerous

bombastic: pompous language
language that is full of long or pretentious words, used to impress others
 
Are you sure? Because if you are indeed stating that fire cannot cause serious damage to steel structures, then I'd like to open another thread where we can explore this issue further. This will save me clogging up your current WTC7 discussion.
What part of 'no' don't you understand?

Your question was silly and argumentative. That's why i didn't answer it the first time.

slingblade is a serious person who makes thoughtful relevant posts.

You are not.
 
What part of 'no' don't you understand?

Your question was silly and argumentative. That's why i didn't answer it the first time.

slingblade is a serious person who makes thoughtful relevant posts.

You are not.


Okay then, put your money where your mouth is.

I shall start another thread; the basis for the discussion will be that structural steelwork is indeed susceptible to weaking, damage, and in extreme cases failure due to fires. You will make the case that this is incorrect and (if I understand correctly) that "normal" fires cannot cause sufficient damage to lead to significant problems.

Fair enough?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom