I'll give my own anecdote revolving around this exact method.
Camping with friends who know I have an interest in magic and have seen me on very infrequent occasions do the odd simple card trick (and one amazing mind reading effect in which I simply took advantage of the situation). They asked for a couple of card tricks, and I did only one, very simple in which I pull out two cards that are then matched by the cards they deal down to. Then they ask for something impressive and I said to do that I need to tell them a story (mind you, this is all completely made up on the fly, presentation-wise).
To start the story I said they needed to cut the deck, so I set up Cross Cut. Then I launched into a full five minute discussion on Houdini and how sometimes the most impressive people are foiled by the simplest of things, and I related the story of how when Houdini was performing one of his many jail escapes he found himself unable to pick the lock only to find after a long time of trying that he had been fooled by the fact that it hadn't been locked. (The story may be apocryphal, and I can't find details).
I embellished that story and wove it into something mysterious. Then, when everyone agreed that Houdini was impressive and the simple jailer who nearly foiled him was also impressive, I leaned back with my hands far from the deck and said, "But is it any more impressive that without touching the deck since you cut it I know that you cut to the nine of clubs?"
I got the campfire equivalent of a standing ovation.
Camping with friends who know I have an interest in magic and have seen me on very infrequent occasions do the odd simple card trick (and one amazing mind reading effect in which I simply took advantage of the situation). They asked for a couple of card tricks, and I did only one, very simple in which I pull out two cards that are then matched by the cards they deal down to. Then they ask for something impressive and I said to do that I need to tell them a story (mind you, this is all completely made up on the fly, presentation-wise).
To start the story I said they needed to cut the deck, so I set up Cross Cut. Then I launched into a full five minute discussion on Houdini and how sometimes the most impressive people are foiled by the simplest of things, and I related the story of how when Houdini was performing one of his many jail escapes he found himself unable to pick the lock only to find after a long time of trying that he had been fooled by the fact that it hadn't been locked. (The story may be apocryphal, and I can't find details).
I embellished that story and wove it into something mysterious. Then, when everyone agreed that Houdini was impressive and the simple jailer who nearly foiled him was also impressive, I leaned back with my hands far from the deck and said, "But is it any more impressive that without touching the deck since you cut it I know that you cut to the nine of clubs?"
I got the campfire equivalent of a standing ovation.