Digging through old stuff, who remembers this gem from Sofia Shafquat?

[cjnewson88]

My brain went Clunkity-Clunk when I first heard this.

 

[Oystein]

Oh! I had falsely ascribed "clunkety-clunk" in my head to Judy Wood

 

[Fonebone]

Oh! I had falsely ascribed "clunkety-clunk" in my head to Judy Wood

Twust the science, Twust the science -- The pseudo skeptics mantra


OK- here is some science.to consider....
If the floors cascaded down in a pancake fashion the noise of each collision would create a separate loud noise impulse.
A bang, a boom, a clunk of cascading floor slabs would create a cascade of loud noise impulses in a train of noise impulses. In theory, had the Twin towers hat truss roof structure sitting atop the 110th floor collapsed down upon the 110th floor slab the first pulse of noise would be created in the mechanical shock pulse of the collision. The falling mass of the hat truss roof structure combined with the mass of the first obstruction colliding with the 109th floor slab would create the second loud pulse of noise and the second shock wave pulse. Using crude approximations, the 110 story tower collapsed down to the 1st floor lobby in eleven seconds. Again, using rounded numbers, the 110 storied cascading down to the lobby in eleven seconds would generate a train of 110 shock pulses. Each shock pulse of the growing mass of floor slabs colliding with the solid mass of the lower
floor would create a separate but distinct loud noise pulse.
One hundred ten shock pulses of loud noise pulses created in a eleven
second collapse time would create 10 shock waves and 10 associated loud noise pulses per second during each collapse.
Truth-seeker Sofia Shafquat mis-labeled the shock wave noises as "clunkity clucnks" instead of a train of shock wave of sharp distinct noise impulses.


This link offers an audio approximation of ten square wave sound pulses per second.
https://www.szynalski.com/tone-generator/#10,squ,v0.5
Press the Play button to start and stop the pulse train.





Using the left and right arrows to raise or lower the square wave sharp pulses per second to adjust the pulse rate for both WTC tower one and tower two impulses per second.
Imploding a one hundred ten story buildings with explosive charges on all one hundred ten floors would generate the exact 10 explosive noise pulses
per second for eleven seconds.
Sofia was on the right path.

Trust the science and your thinking abilities combined.

 

[Myriad]

Twust the science, Twust the science -- The pseudo skeptics mantra


OK- here is some science.to consider....
If the floors cascaded down in a pancake fashion the noise of each collision would create a separate loud noise impulse.

"Pancake fashion" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here for such a vague metaphor. You might as well be calling out the suspicious lack of maple syrup in the debris.

 

[Oystein]

"Pancake fashion" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here for such a vague metaphor. You might as well be calling out the suspicious lack of maple syrup in the debris.

Pancakes are denser (have more mass per unit of volume) than steel-frame skyscrapers. I am pretty sure we ought to nudge the pancake model to a more realistic flatbread model.

*going to figure out if I can register "Flatbreading" and make out like a True $$$Truther$$$*

 

[Oystein]

Twust the science, Twust the science -- The pseudo skeptics mantra


OK- here is some science.to consider....
If the floors cascaded down in a pancake fashion the noise of each collision would create a separate loud noise impulse....

Whatabout if - just thinking out loud and theorizing heavily - the pancakes at the falling top TILTED before cascading down - would we still get 110 distinct clunkety-clunk noises?

 

[MBDK]

In theory, had the Twin towers hat truss roof structure sitting atop the 110th floor collapsed down upon the 110th floor slab...

Who would theorize THAT, other than an ignorant pseudoexpert?

 

[beachnut]

...
Imploding a one hundred ten story buildings with explosive charges on all one hundred ten floors would generate the exact 10 explosive noise pulses
per second for eleven seconds.
Sofia was on the right path.

Trust the science and your thinking abilities combined.

There were no explosives planted, Sofia is a delusional nut. Is she still a failed 9/11 truther, did she wake up to reality?

Who planted your, or her explosive charges?

If 9/11 cult of deniers of science and lovers of delusional conspiracy theories could do and understand the math, physics, and studied the structure of the WTC towers, they would not try to make up the fantasy of explosives used on 9/11. It is the dumbest claim made about 9/11 by conspiracy theorists who go by the name of 9/11 truth where the ignornace is embraced and learning is banned.

The WTC floors did not hold up other floors. The floors were attached to the core and shell. This structure truth is why she failed to realize each floor failed as the upper mass started down after the failure. The floors failed due to upper mass fall, and breaking essential instantaneously the floors connection to the shell and core.

Simple model, which appears to fool her, and you.

She has no tools to understand 9/11 and stop being a fantasy 9/11 truth believer.

She exposes she has no useful knowledge about the WTC structure that can help her avoid falling for or making up lies, fantasies and delusions about 9/11.

Are you trying to defend her massive ignorance?

Shafquat, Sofia, born in Pakistan, spreading lies about 9/11. Why does she make up lies and ignores the dolts who did 9/11. 19 murderers and she makes up disgusting lies and publishes movies fill with nonsense.

Did she make up the lies and nonsense to cover up the acts of 19 failed nuts mislead by UBL, like she misleads failed 9/11 truthers who have seen her propaganda.

Did her dumbed down propaganda fool you?

 

[Fonebone]

There were no explosives planted, Sofia is a delusional nut. Is she still a failed 9/11 truther, did she wake up to reality?

Who planted your, or her explosive charges?

If 9/11 cult of deniers of science and lovers of delusional conspiracy theories could do and understand the math, physics, and studied the structure of the WTC towers, they would not try to make up the fantasy of explosives used on 9/11. It is the dumbest claim made about 9/11 by conspiracy theorists who go by the name of 9/11 truth where the ignornace is embraced and learning is banned.

The WTC floors did not hold up other floors. The floors were attached to the core and shell. This structure truth is why she failed to realize each floor failed as the upper mass started down after the failure. The floors failed due to upper mass fall, and breaking essential instantaneously the floors connection to the shell and core.

Simple model, which appears to fool her, and you.

She has no tools to understand 9/11 and stop being a fantasy 9/11 truth believer.

She exposes she has no useful knowledge about the WTC structure that can help her avoid falling for or making up lies, fantasies and delusions about 9/11.

Are you trying to defend her massive ignorance?

Shafquat, Sofia, born in Pakistan, spreading lies about 9/11. Why does she make up lies and ignores the dolts who did 9/11. 19 murderers and she makes up disgusting lies and publishes movies fill with nonsense.

Did she make up the lies and nonsense to cover up the acts of 19 failed nuts mislead by UBL, like she misleads failed 9/11 truthers who have seen her propaganda.

Did her dumbed down propaganda fool you?

In the spoiler below Sophia delineates her Clunkity-Clunk evidence
delivered on the Truth Jihad interview

[excerpt]

4. Clunkity-clunk. <link>

[/excerpt]

[spoilert]Sophia: Right, people want me to be absolutely precise. Umm, I say that the demolition wave is moving faster than gravity itself. It is making the path for the demolition, which is falling at free fall speed. Virtual free fall speed. Again it is hard to determine how long did it take for the towers to fall visually, and I know there is seismic data that pegs it, you know, a little more accurately.

Regardless, I tell people, these buildings fell in 10 seconds, they’re 110 stories. Now let’s just use our mouth to demonstrate this. If a pancake collapse can be described as “clunkity clunk” How many times can you say that in 10 seconds? And if one floor is “clunkity clunk clunkity clunk” you cannot say that 110 times in 10 seconds. So let’s even give it the benefit of the doubt, let’s just take off the “clunk”. Let’s just say “clunkity”. You can’t say that in 10 seconds, 110 times.[/spoiler

 

[Fonebone]

There were no explosives planted, Sofia is a delusional nut. Is she still a failed 9/11 truther, did she wake up to reality?

Who planted your, or her explosive charges?

If 9/11 cult of deniers of science and lovers of delusional conspiracy theories could do and understand the math, physics, and studied the structure of the WTC towers, they would not try to make up the fantasy of explosives used on 9/11. It is the dumbest claim made about 9/11 by conspiracy theorists who go by the name of 9/11 truth where the ignornace is embraced and learning is banned.

The WTC floors did not hold up other floors. The floors were attached to the core and shell. This structure truth is why she failed to realize each floor failed as the upper mass started down after the failure. The floors failed due to upper mass fall, and breaking essential instantaneously the floors connection to the shell and core.

Simple model, which appears to fool her, and you.

She has no tools to understand 9/11 and stop being a fantasy 9/11 truth believer.

She exposes she has no useful knowledge about the WTC structure that can help her avoid falling for or making up lies, fantasies and delusions about 9/11.

Are you trying to defend her massive ignorance?

Shafquat, Sofia, born in Pakistan, spreading lies about 9/11. Why does she make up lies and ignores the dolts who did 9/11. 19 murderers and she makes up disgusting lies and publishes movies fill with nonsense.

Did she make up the lies and nonsense to cover up the acts of 19 failed nuts mislead by UBL, like she misleads failed 9/11 truthers who have seen her propaganda.

Did her dumbed down propaganda fool you?

In the spoiler below Sophia delineates her Clunkity-Clunk evidence
delivered on the Truth Jihad interview

[excerpt]

4. Clunkity-clunk. <link>

[/excerpt]

[spoilert]Sophia: Right, people want me to be absolutely precise. Umm, I say that the demolition wave is moving faster than gravity itself. It is making the path for the demolition, which is falling at free fall speed. Virtual free fall speed. Again it is hard to determine how long did it take for the towers to fall visually, and I know there is seismic data that pegs it, you know, a little more accurately.

Regardless, I tell people, these buildings fell in 10 seconds, they’re 110 stories. Now let’s just use our mouth to demonstrate this. If a pancake collapse can be described as “clunkity clunk” How many times can you say that in 10 seconds? And if one floor is “clunkity clunk clunkity clunk” you cannot say that 110 times in 10 seconds. So let’s even give it the benefit of the doubt, let’s just take off the “clunk”. Let’s just say “clunkity”. You can’t say that in 10 seconds, 110 times.[/spoiler]

 

[Foster Zygote]

Her argument is incredibly stupid. She seems to be unaware that with each successive floor, the mass is increased by the sum of the last floor.

Does she really think that the last floor to collapse, with the mass of the entire building above it, would take just as long to fail as the first floor to collapse? Do you?

 

[gabeygoat]

Does she really think that the last floor to collapse, with the mass of the entire building above it, would take just as long to fail as the first floor to collapse? Do you?

I imagine he does

 

[Cosmic Yak]

"People want me to be absolutely precise....Let's just say "clunkity". You can't say that in 10 seconds."
That's precise?

 

[Oystein]

In the spoiler below Sophia delineates her Clunkity-Clunk evidence
delivered on the Truth Jihad interview ...

It wasn't necessary, as everybody who's active around here already gets how painfully stupid her argument was, but lurkers might be thankful you repeated it for the lulz.
(You DID quote Shafquat in order to expose and ridicule her obvious silliness, right? Right?!)

 

[TheGoldcountry]

Whatabout if - just thinking out loud and theorizing heavily - the pancakes at the falling top TILTED before cascading down - would we still get 110 distinct clunkety-clunk noises?

Let me get out my Jenga set and test it out.

 

[Brainster]

Oh! I had falsely ascribed "clunkety-clunk" in my head to Judy Wood

She did the Keebler elves comparison:

And recently I gave a talk at an engineering conference where I showed some diagrams of the buildings being built and I showed, “If this were a tree and the Keebler elves cut out this big chunk out of the side here, for their little house, where their dwelling is. Would that affect the towers?” And everyone in the room could see, that no, the way the structure is designed, it can’t bring it down.

 

[Oystein]

She did the Keebler elves comparison:

I have never heard of that one!
(Nor have I ever heard of "Keebler elves", for that matter.)
She also did that billiard balls model, didn't she, wherein she forgot at each step that the falling billiard balls are already fallling and don't reset to v= 0 110 times?

(I have my own theory to explain the collapse of the WTC towers, which centers around "platoons of midgets with hacksaws", which is undeniably true because a) platoons exist, b) midgets exist, c) hacksaws exist, d) midgets can work hacksaws, e) hacksaws can cut iron. I never entertained much doubt that when my midgets "cut out this big chunk out of the side here", that very much would affect the towers and very much would bring the structure down.)

 

[cjnewson88]

She did the Keebler elves comparison:

Thanks, I had completely forgotten about that one

 

[Brainster]

(I have my own theory to explain the collapse of the WTC towers, which centers around "platoons of midgets with hacksaws", which is undeniably true because a) platoons exist, b) midgets exist, c) hacksaws exist, d) midgets can work hacksaws, e) hacksaws can cut iron. I never entertained much doubt that when my midgets "cut out this big chunk out of the side here", that very much would affect the towers and very much would bring the structure down.)

Ridiculous theory. Now platoons of midgets with magico/super/nano/thermite/thermate hacksaws... that's completely credible.

 

[Axxman300]

She did the Keebler elves comparison:

Okay, now I want pancakes AND cookies...