Ok, some of you will be glad to hear I'm rounding this up now. I'll be honest, I expected more intellectual challenge over and above the usual shouts of "Warren Buffet! ..Taleb!" from supposedly one of the most intelligent forums on the net.
I have put up pages of accusations, theories and surmising, along with reams of screenshots of just daily goings on, and a few ongoing predictions which haven't worked out that badly either. There is reams of stuff here to be challenged, pulled apart, examined etc, I cannot help but wonder why it doesn't attract the same interest as any other subject you guys feel you need to intervene to tell the truth in.
Because that is what I WANT you to do, and on the subject matter, not my individual ability to trade it preferably, because that IS actually irrelevant. By comparison to the guys who have been doing this years I am a numpty noob.
And this is actually borne out in my trading, until maybe 3 months ago I was still taking
loads of stupid entries and losing silly shots that I should never have taken, and
yet.. the wins remained big enough, to still go upwards? I can tell you as a fact,
nobody was as surprised as me to stumble onto something on the net, that seemed to work.
so please, somebody tell me how this is possible, an 18month-in numpty noob taking loads of terrible entries first, dragging his figures right down, but still profitable? then numpty starts trying to be a bit more selective, takes fewer trades, monthly figures accelerate dramatically.
I also understand that the vast majority of you don't know what you're looking at really, and so have tried to keep it very simple and playful, but show all the nuts and bolts at the same time.
so apologies if my muppetry language has offended, but if the daily observable phenomena that I (an 18 month in numpty noob) can see and profitably trade IS for the reasons that we surmise (and it fits trading price movement pretty well, as I think I have at least demonstrated) then we are ALL muppets. only some of us want to be pigs instead.
the logical alternatives are that there is nothing untoward at all going on and:
1. I have worked out how the mystical market actually works in 18 months.
2. I'm psychic.
neither of these seem very realistic to me, whereas the numbers and daily chuckles are as real as can be.
Lastly, a word about the other standard skeptic tactic "They're trying to make money by having you over"
well, there are several similar educators teaching marketmaker based trading tactics, I was lucky enough to see (free) a 4 day internet seminar by a guy who charges $5500 per person for it, with 270 people in attendance. He claims he was trained by an ex
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salomon_Brothers marketmaker. No idea if that's true, but the basis of the system is identical to what my lot teach.
so that claim could be leveled against him, whereas our lot want a couple of hundred dollars for lifetime membership, daily sessions and open-ended email support,
until you get it
that sounds like an
awful lot of work trying to teach people something forever, for almost no money for a lifetime membership,
if it was false, does it not? besides the fact they put the analysis out every day for free anyway, you just dont get the live sessions or forums.
So, once again, debunk everything I have shown you here please.
and re my educators, there isn't any point anybody who has commented here signing up, I can tell you that much.
I can tell you that they can turn round (5yr) losing traders, and teach brand newbies from scratch.
however I can also tell you, many still never get there at all either and fade away, because ultimately it's always going to be down to
you to see it and press the buttons, and only a very few people seem to have the capability to DO.
in this thread, you are the mark