• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Proof of Life After Death!!

meg said:
No. That means nothing to me. It is a fantasy. A fairy tale.

My proof of what? You are the one with the alleged proof of life after death.
Click to expand...
You think it is a fairy tale.

I don't.

Agree to disagree..and be as kind as we can while we are here.
 
Robin1 said:
Read the thread. Again. Carefully.
Click to expand...

Shall we count the myriad times you've said this, or something similar, as if to imply there's some subtly hidden truth we've all apparently missed?

We've read it. And there isn't.
 
Robin, looking at the wayback machine, there were 3 dates listed in early 2010 in your area:

Jan 26, 2010 at the New World Stages on W 50th St

March 17, 2010 at Oheka Castle in Huntington, NY

March 31, 2010 in East Rutherford, NJ

Could you please say when and where you saw John Edward?
 
Robin1 said:
If it weren't for John Edward I would still be shopping.
Click to expand...

That only means he said what you wanted to hear, not that he contacted the dead.

I believe you think I can't truly be skeptical , or a critical thinker, if I ever believe anything woo.
Click to expand...

No, I think you can. You just choose not to.

For example, The many psychics I went to at first and I thought were frauds (even famous ones) ...first you might say...kudos, Robin your skeptical thinking and critical thinking skills are great!
Click to expand...

Well, yes...if they were truly frauds, and you were able to see that, then that would be true critical thinking.

They only became flawed, I believe, in your opinion was when I went to a medium (JE) who I believed PROVED there was life after death.
Click to expand...

No. And there we have it: you want to believe, so you believe, regardless of logic.

And since then all my grand critical and skeptical thinking skills MUST have gone down the toilet.
Click to expand...

Yes. They won't do you any good when you refuse to use them.

Cause no way, no how there is life after death...and of that, you are 100% confident.
Click to expand...

No, I'd love it if there was life after death. I'd truly embrace it. I'm not 100% confident there isn't. Most of us aren't. We've said that over and over, but you refuse to read anything but your own posts.
 
Last edited:
Let me try that again . . .
Robin1 said:
Explain to me:
Click to expand...
Robin1 said:
1) JE's hits in the Michael Prescott article.
Click to expand...
I have no evidence that what’s claimed to be hits are actually hits
Robin1 said:
2) JE's hits with me and my brother.
Click to expand...
I have no evidence that what’s claimed to be hits are actually hits
Robin1 said:
3) JE's hits with my old work friend.
Click to expand...
I have no evidence that what’s claimed to be hits are actually hits
Robin1 said:
Then, I'll comment.
Click to expand...
Unless you’re a liar it’s now your turn . . .
 
Last edited:
Robin1 said:
So, just 1knowing 2your Dad survived bodily death, and 3can see what is happening in your life, and 4one day your love will reunite you, means nothing to you?

And your proof just doesn't cut it either. Read the thread. Again. Carefully.
Click to expand...

(Numbering and highlighting added)

Robin:

These opinions, asserted with no evidence, in the face of physics and neurology, among other disciplines, are part of the reason other posters call you dishonest.

You have done nothing to demonstrate that the tricks with which JE fools you, and others, demonstrate that the "soul" is "alive" "after death". Making an assertion in the title of the thread is not the same as actually providing proof for the things you choose to believe.
 
Last edited:
Foolmewunz said:
I'd say this sums up your confirmation bias, Robin. You cannot believe that very many of us do not believe in this nonsense and thus have no interest in whether or not mom noticed that I just talked to a neighbor about her dog or that I kept something of hers close by,... "something personal".

I'd think that if JE could locate my mom among the F names in his galaxy of talking dead, the first thing out of his mouth would be "I have someone's mom here who says, "Joe, you made me a grandma again - I'm watching over Marcello and he's wonderful."

And please.... do keep repeating "Read the thread... read the thread... read the thread." Remember, that's how you converted all of us when you started... "Read the blog and all the comments.... Read the blog and all the comments... Read the blog and all the comments." That's where most of us began to see the patterns of a True Believer. You don't even realize how you kept tailoring the narrative to re-make it into something that it wasn't, originally.

So any newbies or lurkers out there: Read the thread... Read the thread... Read the thread. Please. It will do more to debunk Robin's wussy claims than anything in any one single post could do for you.
Click to expand...
Yes, read the thread.
 
Just for the sake of curiosity and thoroughness I’ve listed how much information people gave JE in this short clip - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qx0Jt2jnLOQ

There is a Robert
Robert is dead
Robert was a ladies father
Robert was a fireman
Robert didn’t die of cancer
A dead grandfather and a mother had bone issues
The mother died from bone cancer
Robert died September 11th
A lady is only girl and oldest child in family
Robert died on the first day of work after surgery
Robert was working at a different fire station the day he died
A lady had three sons but one died
Son died after father Robert died
Son wasn’t killed by anyone else.
Son didn’t die from an illness

That’s a hell of a lot more information than JE provided (if he actually provided any).
 
ynot said:
Just for the sake of curiosity and thoroughness I’ve listed how much information people gave JE in this short clip - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qx0Jt2jnLOQ

There is a Robert
Robert is dead
Robert was a ladies father
Robert was a fireman
Robert didn’t die of cancer
A dead grandfather and a mother had bone issues
The mother died from bone cancer
Robert died September 11th
A lady is only girl and oldest child in family
Robert died on the first day of work after surgery
Robert was working at a different fire station the day he died
A lady had three sons but one died
Son died after father Robert died
Son wasn’t killed by anyone else.
Son didn’t die from an illness

That’s a hell of a lot more information than JE provided (if he actually provided any).
Click to expand...


Like I said earlier, JE is just doing parlor tricks. Basic mentalism/cold reading techniques.
 
ynot said:
Yes, we all know that except Robin1
Click to expand...


Seeing how patently transparent his technique is (and I say this as someone who's studied and performed magic and mentalism as an amateur for 20+ years), while manipulating his audience's emotions as he's doing, makes me sick.

What a piece of **** this guy is.
 
AdMan said:
Seeing how patently transparent his technique is (and I say this as someone who's studied and performed magic and mentalism as an amateur for 20+ years), while manipulating his audience's emotions as he's doing, makes me sick.

What a piece of **** this guy is.
Click to expand...
Definitely no better a person than SB or JVP regardless of what Robin1 believes.
 
You mentioned at some point in the thread (I've skimmed through it, but not read entirely, I admit) that you investigated many false psychics before him. Is he the only one you're aware of that you believe is real? How many other people in the world would you estimate have the same ability? Are you aware of any examples of practical/useful information that JE has communicated?

On a separate note, during the communication (apologies if this has been asked and I didn't see it)... How do you know it was your father? Isn't it just as possible that JE can read minds, or was communicating with something/someone merely claiming to be your father?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom