 |
Right, that's it. Gnome is almost as good as dead to me.
I just installed Ubuntu 11.10 yesterday, to see how good it was, in order to find out whether I would make the jump to 12.04 when it comes out.
I installed Gnome 3 immediately, because Unity (which will not be mentioned hereafter) doesn't do it for me. Maybe I'll try it later on, but I wanted to try the new and improved Gnome first. I'd been dying to get it out for a test drive, and this was my moment.
After a fairly shaky start (I accidentally didn't take the .gnote folder with me, losing all my notes in the process (I copied the .gnome2 folder in stead, stupid me)), I found my footing in Gnome shell.
Things went okay, until I wanted to start my usual array of background programs, which resided in the notification area in gnome 2.x. Imagine my surprise when they didn't do that. In stead, I had to go search for the notification area, finding out that it's hidden from sight in the lower right hand corner. Are they crazy? It's a notification area, not a nothing to see here area.
Add to that the annoying fact that when you hover over an icon it folds out to show the name of the program. I am not an idiot. If I hover over anything, a tag with the name of it shows up, and since that functionality is not gone, having the name show up twice merely furthers my annoyance. Sure it means that in emsene you have a history function when you click the text, but I really don't care about that. When I use a notification area, I just want to hover over, click the icon and show the window. I don't want to hover over the icon, wait until the text rolls out, and THEN move to the icon again (because it moves to the left to accommodate the text) and THEN click to show the window.
Another thing is the absence of a window list. Sure, they have the slick dash, but you can's access the dash from the window in which you're working. Oh, no. They make you go to the upper left hand corner to do that.
I want to change to a new window with the click of the mouse, and not via a mouse movement. No, Alt-Tab is not a good alternative, because it means that, before I can select the program I want to use, I first have to use a keyboard command, royally ruining any work-flow I still had.
That brings me nicely to the hierarchical drop-down menu for selecting programs.
What's that you say? There is no hierarchical drop-down menu for selecting programs? Well, that's just it. I want such a menu.
As if that's not enough, I can't add any applets to the panel by myself. I can't change the place of the panel, and I can't add any other panels. I can't even change the colour or background image.
I guess user customisation isn't as needed as I thought it was.
Extensions are available, sure. But when I enabled the "Bottom Pane" extension, it hid the notification area, which doesn't move above the panel.
And when I enabled the "application menu", it had categories you had to open by clicking, and not by hovering, adding to the annoyance on another level.
In short, extensions aren't real fixes of all problems, they are merely ways to feel like you're not completely powerless.
Gnome wanted to make things more integrated, but they decided to de-emphasise the user in the process.
And if that makes me sound like a cry-baby who doesn't get what he's used to, then so be it. I mean, I have a lot of programs that are Gnome dependent, and moving to KDE or XFCE (or even Lxde) wouldn't solve the problem. Trust me, I've looked at all three.
Before Gnome Shell, I just went on with things. Now, I habitually walk into walls with things I want to do.
If anyone knows of a good Gnome alternative (as in, fork) that is usable already, don't hesitate to let me know. |