• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Continuation Part 3 - Discussion of the Amanda Knox case

Status
Not open for further replies.
bri1 said:
Does anyone have a link to the lies told by Prosecution and Police and leaked to the press?
Click to expand...

I can list a few.

1. The police reported they had a clear video image of Amanda going to the cottage on the night of the murder.

2. The claim that Amanda called Rudy around the time the body was discovered.

3. The release of the bloody bathroom photo.

4. A false claim that receipts were found proving that bleach was purchased on Nov. 2.

5. Reports that the cottage had been cleaned with bleach and the washing machine was spinning when the police arrived.
 
The story that Amanda brought a lot of strange men back to the cottage seems to be a lie as well.

Amanda, smoked a bit of dope, drank a bit, and took a nerdy virgin as a boyfriend.
Meredith, smoked a bit of dope, drank a bit, and took a rather creepy guy who was dealing pot as a boyfriend.

If matters had played out rather differently and it had been Amanda who had surprised Rudy and been murdered, and Meredith who had come home to find things a bit "not right" in the cottage, we could just as easily be hearing all about how Meredith was the witch of deception who murdered her room-mate, and Amanda was the saintly, pure and virtuous girl whose promising life had been cut short.

Rolfe.
 
Kestrel said:
I can list a few.

1. The police reported they had a clear video image of Amanda going to the cottage on the night of the murder.

2. The claim that Amanda called Rudy around the time the body was discovered.

3. The release of the bloody bathroom photo.

4. A false claim that receipts were found proving that bleach was purchased on Nov. 2.

5. Reports that the cottage had been cleaned with bleach and the washing machine was spinning when the police arrived.
Click to expand...

6. They reported that Amanda's sweatshirt was missing ("she burned it"), this was evidence in pretrial used to uphold the detention ( it's in the supreme court's ruling). Yet in police photos it's in clear view on Amanda's bed.

7. Harry Potter that Amanda read at Raffaele's. They said the book was at the cottage instead and she lied, but the police video from Raffaele's flat clearly shows the book.
 
Kestrel said:
I can list a few.

1. The police reported they had a clear video image of Amanda going to the cottage on the night of the murder.

2. The claim that Amanda called Rudy around the time the body was discovered.

3. The release of the bloody bathroom photo.

4. A false claim that receipts were found proving that bleach was purchased on Nov. 2.

5. Reports that the cottage had been cleaned with bleach and the washing machine was spinning when the police arrived.
Click to expand...


Thanks, Kestrel.
I wrote a post over at the Mail Online (having anything to do with the Daily Mail makes me feel dirty, though, ugh) and linked to the IIP list.
 
Harry Potter and the list of lies

Kestrel said:
I can list a few.

1. The police reported they had a clear video image of Amanda going to the cottage on the night of the murder.

2. The claim that Amanda called Rudy around the time the body was discovered.

3. The release of the bloody bathroom photo.

4. A false claim that receipts were found proving that bleach was purchased on Nov. 2.

5. Reports that the cottage had been cleaned with bleach and the washing machine was spinning when the police arrived.
Click to expand...

The claim that Knox's clothes were missing (they were right on her bed), and the claim that the Harry Potter book was only at the girls' flat (there was a second copy at Raffaele's flat) are two more that come to mind. The claim that the police arrived before the call to the Carabinieri is another.
 
bri1 said:
Thanks, Kestrel.
I wrote a post over at the Mail Online (having anything to do with the Daily Mail makes me feel dirty, though, ugh) and linked to the IIP list.
Click to expand...

Hey go person go.
Do not forget that the rovers won on saturday.
Yes, and it was away from home.
That is good I feel good
 
Last edited:
The really big lie:

They didn't coerce the Patrick story out of her and the all the false reasons it supposedly wasn't recorded.

Basically everything they said about the interrogation.


ETA: The postal cop saying he didn't enter room.

They were surprised by the police while standing with a mop and bucket.
 
Last edited:
the alleged shutting off of the cell phones

Grinder said:
The really big lie:

They didn't coerce the Patrick story out of her and the all the false reasons it supposedly wasn't recorded.

Basically everything they said about the interrogation.


ETA: The postal cop saying he didn't enter room.

They were surprised by the police while standing with a mop and bucket.
Click to expand...
I am not sure that the police are responsible for it, but there was a claim that they both turned off their cell phones at the same time, and then turned them back on together the next morning. It is mentioned in Darkness Descending, not the most reliable of sources.
 
I guess I'll say that that pretty much burned up my last shred of sympathy for Lumumba. It's time to man up and get over it.
 
It is tedious to keep hearing from the PGP that this is a battle between the Knox/Mellas and the Kerchers. It is a battle to find the best verdict the system allows.

Perhaps, very early on there was a sliver of a moment when Edda could have said something to the Kerchers directly about how sad it was that their daughter had been murdered, but being that Amanda was already in jail it would have been really delicate.

Edda has not demonstrated the ability to communicate in such a manner.

At this time in a trial it is about the people being tried for the crime. It is disingenuous to say the defendants are causing the world to forget Meredith. The ongoing trial keeps Meredith's memory alive. This is more about the fact that Amanda and Raffaele are famous and talked about all the time, not that Meredith isn't.

It is the way of the world that preceded this case and will be true in the future. Anybody know who Harris and Klebold killed?

When the Kerchers ask what happened to all the other evidence, I wonder if they meant the pathology reports of the death of Meredith or the footprints, phone records etc.?

No matter how Meredith was killed it was horrible. It is probably worse if it was a roommate rather than someone introduced to you by your boyfriend, but really just horrible either way.
 
Last edited:
RoseMontague said:
Daily Caller dude is saying Lifetime Movie trial taking place same time across the street and lunch has gone from 30 to 80 minutes now (wonder whats up).

http://twitter.com/#!/morsels
Click to expand...

Barbie said 2:30 local time, so 80 minutes? Maresca already in Courtroom limbering up apparently:
BLNadeau Barbie Latza Nadeau
#meredithkercher lawyer Maresca heads to courtroom early to get ready for his closing arguments in #amandaknox appeal.
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Share this page

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom