Complexity
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2005
- Messages
- 9,242
Saying "whether Israel survives or not is no concern of mine because all states eventually are destroyed" is like saying "whether you live or die is of no concern of mine because all men are mortal".
Not only should the logical mistake be obvious, but, quite apart from that, anybody who couldn't care less about whether Israel survives or not is hardly in a position to give it moral lessons, whatever the worth of the moral lesson itself -- much like Al Gore is more or less the worst possible crusader to stop conspicuous consumption so as to slow down global warming, with his private jet and multiple mansions, whatever the truth of his views.
I don't give a damn whether any of the current governments survives for 10 or 100 years. I don't think any will survive for 1000 years.
Having no liking for or respect for a government says nothing about how one feels towards the people in that country, except to the extent to which individuals have supported an unjust government.
I neither agree with your conclusions nor with process by which you apparently arrived at them.
Don't shoot the messenger. Israel is behaving badly.
