• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

The character assassination of Richard Goldstone

Status
Not open for further replies.

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
http://www.forward.com/articles/134322/#ixzz19yeMNxm6

Obviously, it wasn’t easy to destroy Richard Goldstone. But for his report to be permanently deep-sixed, the man himself had to be thor-oughly discredited, recast not just as a naïve dupe of the human rights community but as an enemy of Israel, a Nazi in Zionist clothing, a perpetrator of “blood libel,” a self-hating Jew.​

“There are three primary threats facing us today,” said Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, “the nuclear threat, the missile threat, and what I call the Goldstone threat.” President Shimon Peres called Goldstone “a small man, devoid of any sense of justice.” Others in the government and media piled on, as did the so-called leaders of the “organized” American Jewish community. Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz said Goldstone was “an evil, evil man,” “a traitor to the Jewish people,” the U.N.’s “token court Jew” and a “despicable human being.”​


His foes mounted a fresh offensive last spring based on a front-page story in Yediot Aharonot, Israel’s mass circulation daily, that charged that during his years as a South African judge, Goldstone “sided through and through with the racist policies of the Apartheid regime” and should “do some soul-searching before he rushes to criticize others.”​



Goldstone responded that though it was “the most difficult” decision of his career, he had accepted the judicial appointment in the belief that he could accomplish more by defending the rule of law from within the judicial system. His critics fell over each other exploiting the story and ratcheting up the rhetoric. Danny Ayalon, Israel’s deputy foreign minister, said, “I don’t want to exaggerate but these are the same explanations we heard in Nazi Germany after World War II.” Alan Dershowitz sank to a new low. “That’s what Mengele said, too,” he told an Israeli TV program. Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman reportedly ordered Yediot’s story distributed to his diplomatic missions abroad.​





Horrible, despicable, and pathetic....what the right-wingers have done to this man. It shows how desperate they are and how low they will go, to attack those who dare to criticize them...or even examine them. Perhaps this is why soo many American Congressmen are scared **** less to condemn Israeli brutality, settlements, immigration & other racist policies.​

My God, if this is how they treat a fellow Jew, how would they treat a Gentile?​
 
Last edited:
If that's how Jews treat Jews, how will they treat non-Jews?

Well, there is this Jewish guy, Richard Goldstone. His treatment of Jews is to demand Jews be denied the right to defend themselves against murderous terrorists. How does he treat non-Jews? Well, he was a hanging judge in Apartheid South Africa. But he was only following orders the law.

Of course, anybody else with a record of sending Blacks to the gallows in Apartheid South Africa would be considered by the human rights brigade as beyond the pale; but Goldstone has the all-important "got out of jail free" quality -- he hates Israel, so all is forgiven.
 
Unfortunately much of this stems from the fact that he was part of a commission to investigate war crimes committed during the Gaza War, the United Nations Human Rights Council made the report, which unfortunately made it an elaborate joke as the UNHRC has thug dictatorships that violate human rights all the time as it's main membership. Thereby meaning that the UNHRC is little more then an anti-Israel propaganda organisation.

To be fair though he did insist that the investigation be extended to cover Palestinian war crimes (though when it came to endorsing the report the UNHRC merely endorsed the accusations against Israel)
 
To be fair though he did insist that the investigation be extended to cover Palestinian war crimes (though when it came to endorsing the report the UNHRC merely endorsed the accusations against Israel)
That is only partially true. The commission looked at instances of rockets fired into Israel, which is only one of several types of the war crimes that Hamas was accused of. The other ones were all related to tactics who aim was to increase the level of civilian causalities on their own side, or blur the distinction between civilians and fighters: fighting without uniform, putting fighting units near civilians, using hospitals as headquarters. These were not seriously looked into, and the commission never interviewed Hamas fighters about their tactics, even though Hamas was supposedly cooperating with the commission.

Of course knowledge of these tactics is REQUIRED in order to judge whether many of the dead were civilians or not, and whether Israeli actions are justified or not. By not looking into that aspect the commission has made itself into a show trail. This is expanded upon it an excellent article, here. Goldestone as the head of this commission richly deserve criticism, though I would not support actions such as preventing him from attending a family event, etc.
 
he hates Israel,

evidence please.

or is this just another typical "criticism of Israel= hatred of Israel" absurdity?

figures.


the ACLU spends very minute of every day, criticizing the USA. do you believe the ACLU hates the United States?
 
I hear Goldstone's character is going to Dubai soon...
 
That is only partially true. The commission looked at instances of rockets fired into Israel, which is only one of several types of the war crimes that Hamas was accused of. The other ones were all related to tactics who aim was to increase the level of civilian causalities on their own side, or blur the distinction between civilians and fighters: fighting without uniform, putting fighting units near civilians, using hospitals as headquarters. These were not seriously looked into, and the commission never interviewed Hamas fighters about their tactics, even though Hamas was supposedly cooperating with the commission.

Of course knowledge of these tactics is REQUIRED in order to judge whether many of the dead were civilians or not, and whether Israeli actions are justified or not. By not looking into that aspect the commission has made itself into a show trail. This is expanded upon it an excellent article, here. Goldestone as the head of this commission richly deserve criticism, though I would not support actions such as preventing him from attending a family event, etc.
A very informative article there, thanks
 
If that's how Jews treat Jews, how will they treat non-Jews?

Well, there is this Jewish guy, Richard Goldstone. His treatment of Jews is to demand Jews be denied the right to defend themselves against murderous terrorists. How does he treat non-Jews? Well, he was a hanging judge in Apartheid South Africa. But he was only following orders the law.

Of course, anybody else with a record of sending Blacks to the gallows in Apartheid South Africa would be considered by the human rights brigade as beyond the pale; but Goldstone has the all-important "got out of jail free" quality -- he hates Israel, so all is forgiven.
we have already had a thread about people who habitually substitute the term "Jews" for "Israel". Goldstones report is not about the actions of "Jews". Thats just your spin....

your slander of Goldstone is quite grubby....but thats the plan isn't it.
 
we have already had a thread about people who habitually substitute the term "Jews" for "Israel".

yes, and we can see how the thread was right on the money. :)

Jews, Zionists, Israelis.....the term depends on the agenda of the hour.
 
Is anyone really surprised? Character assassination is the bread and butter, the attack of first resort, of Israel's jackbooted defenders.
 
The criticisms I've seen on the Goldstone report revolve around the methodology and inaccuracy of the report itself. What criticisms I've seen leveled against it's authors revolve around questioning the wisdom of hiring people who are already predisposed to be critical of Israel to write a supposedly neutral report.

I disagree with Letty Cottin Pogrebin that there has been any campaign to assassinate the character of Goldstone.
 
Israel's jackbooted defenders.

This is what REALLY annoys me :mad:

Israel is in NO WAY comparable to Nazi :rule10 Germany!

When has Israel ever skinned Palestininans to make lampshades?

When have palestinians ever been worked to death as slave labour in Israel's factories?

When have entire Palestinian villages been forced to march across landmines?

How Many Palestinians have died due to being subject to grotesque and pseudoscientific surgical experiments?

When have Israelis ever taken Palestinian teeth which contained gold fillings?
 
This is what REALLY annoys me :mad:

Israel is in NO WAY comparable to Nazi :rule10 Germany!

comparing one's enemies to the Nazi regime, is the great cliche' of our time.

whether its Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda, Serbia, Sudan, Israel, the USA, Britain, etc etc......our less-than brightest around the world always resort to the Nazi comparison.

It requires little thought or analysis. That's why its soo popular.

Why do you think they are called "Islamo-fascists" and not "Islamo-authoritarians"? It requires less brain power.

Hell, when TeaBaggers liken Obama to the USSR, at least they are trying to think.
 
Last edited:
Because the term fits.

naa....but here's a hint:

"Islamo-fascist" has only 5 syllables.

"Islamo-authoritarian", while being much more of a correct description, has an annoying 7 syllables. For some folks, the path of least resistance is the one that ALWAYS must he chosen.

;)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom