9/11-investigator explains the Holocaust

[drkitten]

Sigh, do I have to explain everything to you!?

No, you just have to be correct, which is apparently much harder.

I might even settle for "consistent."

According to Jewish law, if a person’s mother is Jewish, then that person is automatically Jewish, regardless of the father’s ethnicity or religion. The facts indicate that both of Lyndon Johnson’s great-grandparents, on the maternal side, were Jewish. These were the grandparents of Lyndon’s mother, Rebecca Baines.11 Their names were John S. Huffman and Mary Elizabeth Perrin.12 John Huffman’s mother was Suzanne Ament, a common Jewish name. Perrin is also a common Jewish name.

So, aside from the fact that "a common Jewish name" is not proof of being Jewish, and the fact that neither Ament or Perrin is a common Jewish name.... surnames are inherited from the father, which is by your own admission irrelevant to the question of being Jewish.

o Maternal great-great grandparents (parents of Mary Perrin): Dicea Kerby and William Perrin

You need to prove that Dicea Kerby was Jewish, because it doesn't matter if William Perrin was Jewish. If Dicea was not Jewish, then your argument is a whole line of fail.

Similarly, the fact that a distant male ancestor of Roosevelt may have been Jewish is a whole line of fail. Who was FDR's mother? Was she Jewish?

Doesn't it tire you to never be right about ANYTHING?

 

[Jungle Jim]

Not to mention, that even if Ament and Perrin are common Jewish names, it would not mean that everybody with those surnames was Jewish. Edit: drkitten beat me to it.

Here is some basic information on Jewish surnames: http://www.jewfaq.org/jnames.htm

 

[dudalb]

I love the way that 9/11 Investigator claims his dislike of Jews is not based on race or ethnic reasons, but then makes a big deal if he finds out somebody has a Jewish Ancestor.

 

[Thunder]

My last name is one of the most common Germanic last names there is. Watch the Winter Olympics and you will see folks with my last name form Germany, Switzerland, and Austria...left and right.

And yet, I am not German and my grandfather came from a little lumber town in western Ukraine.

 

[Cleon]

I love the way that 9/11 Investigator claims his dislike of Jews is not based on race or ethnic reasons, but then makes a big deal if he finds out somebody has a Jewish Ancestor.

Not even a Jewish ancestor, but an ancestor with a Jewish-sounding name.

I wonder what Alfred Rosenberg's opinion on the subject would be?

 

[Thunder]

Not even a Jewish ancestor, but an ancestor with a Jewish-sounding name.

I wonder what Alfred Rosenberg's opinion on the subject would be?

didn't the SS wanna do a severe background check into this guy?

i mean, he has an incredibly stereotypical Jewish name, for a Latvian.

 

[9/11-investigator]

I love it when girls offer resistance

From my LBJ link:
Lyndon Johnson began his career in 1931 as the legislative assistant of Congressman Richard M. Kleberg, a wealthy Jewish politician representing the 14th District of Texas.


Perrin not a Jewish name? Think again:
http://thinkexist.com/quotes/rabbi_yaacov_perrin/

And then Johnson's behavior during the Liberty incident (Israeli's bombing to US Liberty to make it look like an Arab act; have seen that somewhere else before, cannot remember when and where)
http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/ussliberty.html
A former Navy attorney who helped lead the military investigation of the 1967 Israeli attack on the USS Liberty that killed 34 American servicemen says former President Lyndon Johnson and his defense secretary, Robert McNamara, ordered that the inquiry conclude the incident was an accident.

 

[9/11-investigator]

My last name is one of the most common Germanic last names there is.

Goldstein.

Just kidding, Parky.

And yet, I am not German and my grandfather came from a little lumber town in western Ukraine.

Ah, it must be Fiddler (Fiedler) then, from Anatevka!

 

[Cleon]

I love it when girls offer resistance

Wow, a rape joke. You're just all class.

From my LBJ link:
Lyndon Johnson began his career in 1931 as the legislative assistant of Congressman Richard M. Kleberg, a wealthy Jewish politician representing the 14th District of Texas.

So?

Perrin not a Jewish name? Think again:
http://thinkexist.com/quotes/rabbi_yaacov_perrin/

Congrats, you found a Jew named Perrin. That doesn't make it a "common Jewish name." Because, well, it isn't.

And then Johnson's behavior during the Liberty incident

...doesn't, of course, have any bearing on whether or not he was Jewish. Which he wasn't.

 

[Simon39759]

Perrin is a common French last name.
There have been significant Jewish population in France since the first century CE so, some Jews might have ended up with a French last name, nonetheless, Perrin hints at a French, probably Roman Catholic, origin first.

Also, so now, not only is having Jewish ancestry shameful, but it also is contagious?

Finally, maybe it's PC of me but rape jokes = not funny, you are a scumbag through and through and you?

 

[Ignorantbystander]

ever checked your own ancestry for Jewish names 9/11-investigator? Might explain why you're 'jewing' your way out of difficult questions or mistakes.

 

[Thunder]

you guys really should ignore 9-11 Invest. after that rape joke. that was sooo very uncalled for.

 

[Cleon]

He wants us to see his ilk teaming up with the worst criminals in history as something Godly.

...Says the guy defending Nazis.

 

[9/11-investigator]

...Says the guy defending Nazis.

I am not defending the Nazi's, just denying you the right to write history as you please.

 

[Cleon]

I am not defending the Nazi's

Yes, yes, you are.

just denying you the right to write history as you please.

That would be "the way things actually happened."

 

[Nick Terry]

I am not defending the Nazi's, just denying you the right to write history as you please.

Thing is, you're in no position to deny anything in a meaningful way. Neither you nor the vaunted revisionists are actually writing history, so you fail.

 

[9/11-investigator]

Thing is, you're in no position to deny anything in a meaningful way. Neither you nor the vaunted revisionists are actually writing history, so you fail.

What's your opinion about teaming up of the Anglo's with the worst criminals in history?

Was it a good cause?

 

[Thunder]

Writing history as we please? then tell us, Mr. Investigator, where are the missing 3 million Polish Jews and 1 million Ukrainian Jews?

 

[Moss]

And bring you to the moon.

More like transport Der Führer's hissy fits across the Channel when the drugaddled Generalfeldmarschall failed to do it.

 

[Nick Terry]

What's your opinion about teaming up of the Anglo's with the worst criminals in history?

Was it a good cause?

Irrelevant gish-gallop distraction attempt. Stop trying to change the subject when confronted by points you dislike.

Face it, revisionism doesn't revise anything, and therefore doesn't work, because it doesn't say what did happen, in a conventional narrative format. The same, incidentally, can be said for the 9/11 Twoof Movement, and pretty much all conspiraloons.

Example: Saggy dodging what happened to 3 million Polish Jews on the other thread.