• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

9/11-investigator explains the Holocaust

Status
Not open for further replies.
Any essential books on the Holocaust I should read (Preferably well written too)?

On a related topic, I watched Mr Death for about the tenth time yesterday. Got round to it yet 9/11Inves?
 
I'd still like to see some evidence of how, who, why, and when, the evil Jews were able to fake world-wide Jewish census data from 1900 through 1945.

thats one insane conspiracy theory.

governments changed dramatically in Europe between 1900 and 1945...yet Neo-Nazis contend that the Jews were somehow able to still control and manipulate ALL of the Jewish census data coming out of Europe.

fascinating.
 
I'd still like to see some evidence of how, who, why, and when, the evil Jews were able to fake world-wide Jewish census data from 1900 through 1945.

thats one insane conspiracy theory.

governments changed dramatically in Europe between 1900 and 1945...yet Neo-Nazis contend that the Jews were somehow able to still control and manipulate ALL of the Jewish census data coming out of Europe.

fascinating.

The Dutch government anno 2009 knows exactly how many Dutch there are in the Netherlands (although a lot have a color these days). All the Dutch have a burger-service-nummer (sort of a national id) registered somewhere in a computer. The government just has to run a query and than knows precisely how many Dutch there are.

No comparable circumstance exists for the context of the Jews, the quintessential dispersed cosmopolitan people. They did and do not live in a single state so there is no way that any organization could have reliably known how many Jews there were in 1948, 1940, let alone 1920 or 1880. Nobody knew, not even the Jews themselves.

Besides, Parky hasn't shown any original sources for Jewish population data from 1940 or before. He only has presented numbers from a single modern source: jewishvirtuallibrary, a website, a body that will never be unbiased about providing numbers which could undermine the sheer existence of Israel itself. No way. Israel is founded on the holocaust (myth).

But again, nobody could have known or can even know today how many Jews there are and were worldwide since there is no single institution which has the power to collect these data. The only reliable figures are to be expected from modern day Israel for Israel only, since modern Israel is a state with a functioning administration and tax collection aparatus. The rest is guessing, estimations. There maybe 15 million Jews in this world, there maybe 30 million. Nobody can ever know how many for sure. And btw what is a Jew? Do we count 'half Jews', 'quarter Jews' (as the Nazis did) or don't these 'partial Jews' exist at all as some Jews claim (in their view a Jew is a Jew if his mother is Jewish otherwise he is not Jewish at all; partial Jews don't exist in their view). What about Jews who don't want to be Jews at all and became Christians or atheist (like Vainunu, Friedman). Are they counted?

Using these population figures is non-conclusive for answering the question whether the holocaust happened or not.

Counting the number of self-styled 'holocaust-survivors' is a better indicator. If all these people are sincere (about having escaped Nazi occupied territory), then the holocaust could not have happened because there are way too many survivors even now. Simple arithmetic (shown in the link I provided) makes this clear. Of course it is possible that large numbers of Jews swindled themselves into faked victimhood in order to touch money from the German government. But if large numbers of Jews are swindlers, what does that say about the credibility of the holocaust story as pushed by these same people.
 
Last edited:
To top it off, while Europe was dominated by the barbarians of Europe, China and the Indus were thriving civilisations that were far ahead of anything else at the time. Babylon and Egypt were also great powers as well as the Assyrians, Hittites, the Israelites and the Persians.

While Europe was in the dark ages, who formed the largest empire in the world? The Mongol Empire.

The Maya in Central America as well as the Toltecs and the Olmecs were very advanced as well.

So, Europe is not the greatest civilisation.

In order to prevent you to derail this thread you can expand on your fascinating view that the Mongol civilization was somehow 'greater' than European civilization here.

Psst NWO-S, don't suppress your feelings, feel free to admit that Israel is the best there is. Mazzeltov!
 
Funny how you omitted the fact that his expertise was electrical engineering.

It gets even funnier, virtually all the big shots in hololand, either orthodox or revisionist, are non-historians by education. Take holo pope Raul Hilberg: studied political science.
 
Last edited:
It gets even funnier, virtually all the big shots in hololand, either orthodox or revisionist, are non-historians by education. Take holo pope Raul Hilberg: studied political science.

Um...politcal science majors study history. But nice try trying to divert attention away from the fact that you picked an author who has no background in the area whatsoever. Do you care to justify that, or more diversionary tactics?
 
Um...politcal science majors study history.

Political science doesn't qualify one anymore to carry out research regarding the holocaust, that involves history and chemistry and archive research for starters, than engineering does. Mind you, I am not holding Hilberg's qualifications against him, as I neither do for Butz. It is you who tries to defame Butz, a professor, meaning a skilled intellectual.
 
Political science doesn't qualify one anymore to carry out research regarding the holocaust, that involves history and chemistry and archive research for starters, than engineering does. Mind you, I am not holding Hilberg's qualifications against him, as I neither do for Butz. It is you who tries to defame Butz, a professor, meaning a skilled intellectual.

I'm not defaming Butz, I'm sure he may qualified in the areas of engineering. And I'm sure there are engineers with excellent researching skills, but you must convince me and others why an engineer would have better research skills than a historian, who's much more adept in this area. I'm sure there are also engineers who make great heart surgeons, personally, I'll take a pass.
 
No comparable circumstance exists for the context of the Jews, the quintessential dispersed cosmopolitan people. They did and do not live in a single state so there is no way that any organization could have reliably known how many Jews there were in 1948, 1940, let alone 1920 or 1880. Nobody knew, not even the Jews themselves.

Besides, Parky hasn't shown any original sources for Jewish population data from 1940 or before. He only has presented numbers from a single modern source: jewishvirtuallibrary, a website, a body that will never be unbiased about providing numbers which could undermine the sheer existence of Israel itself. No way. Israel is founded on the holocaust (myth). .

the statistics on the website I showed you has sources.

until you can prove that those sources are WRONG....you have no argument to make.

all reliable census data, which has yet to be proven false, suggests between 4.5 and 7 million missing European Jews after WW2.

you have the sources...so why don't you now prove them incorrect.

come on 9-11 Investigator, we know you're a smart guy. you can do it.

http://www.adherents.com/Na/Na_408.html

prove them wrong.
 
Last edited:
Calling Butz's work "history" is a bit like calling moon-landing-never-happened books "astronomy".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top Bottom