• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Texas Board of Education Chairman Don McLeroy in trouble?

Questioninggeller

Illuminator
Joined
May 11, 2002
Messages
3,048
This is an interesting turn of events for Don McLeroy, who is awaiting confirmation for another term on the Texas Board of Education:

McLeroy nomination in jeopardy
By Kate Alexander
Austin American-Statesman
Wednesday, April 22, 2009, 07:39 PM

State Board of Education Chairman Don McLeroy, R-Bryan, faced searing questioning during his uncommonly long confirmation hearing Wednesday at the Senate Nominations Committee.

And Chairman Mike Jackson, R-La Porte, said McLeroy’s nomination is on shaky ground because he might not be able to get the required two-thirds vote from the Senate.

Democratic senators Kirk Watson of Austin and Eliot Shapleigh of El Paso challenged McLeroy over his leadership during a number of controversial Board of Education decisions, including the recent adoption of new science curriculum standards that critics say undermine the teaching of evolution.

Shapleigh said he plans to have McLeroy separated from the others when his nomination comes up on the Senate floor so that it could be debated and voted on individually.

“You’ve created a hornet’s nest like I’ve never seen,” Shapleigh said, noting that 15 bills - “the most I’ve ever seen” - have been filed during this legislative session to strip various powers from the State Board of Education.
...
Shapleigh said there is a perception that McLeroy is using the chairmanship of the State Board of Education as a bully pulpit for promoting his religious point-of-view and pushing it into the public arena.
...
Watson, however, said that McLeroy has created controversy time and again by not listening to expert advice and replacing it with his own perspective.
...

Full article: Austin America-Statesman

More on Don McLeroy:


Education board leader set to challenge evolution
McLeroy is point man in fight over Texas' science curriculum.
By Laura Heinauer
AMERICAN-STATESMAN
Sunday, March 08, 2009

Some go to church to find answers. Bryan dentist Don McLeroy, chairman of the State Board of Education and point man in the fight over Texas' science curriculum, goes to teach.
...
At the time, McLeroy was a 29-year-old dental student in Houston. His response was to first write up a list of reasons that he could not accept Christ. Some things he read in the Bible didn't make sense with what he was learning in dental school, he said. And he wondered why God would allow innocent people to die.

One by one, he said, his questions were answered by pastors and in Bible studies. The conversion took four months. Over the next year, he began taking seminars on creationism and biblical principles. He is now a young earth creationist, meaning that he believes God created Earth between 6,000 and 10,000 years ago.
...
These days, he carries with him the books he has read on the topic, many of which are well-marked in the margins, and a large binder that is adorned on the front with a picture of Albert Einstein.
...

Full: AMERICAN-STATESMAN
 
The Texas Freedom Network has posted video of the hearings and has a write up. At one point Don McLeroy said:

Don McLeroy said:
I think what we’re doing is destroying America’s soul in science.

Here's a clip from the hearing (Part 1):


Here's an editorial:

End poor guidance of Texas education
Texas Senate should put brakes on Don McLeroy's nomination as chairman of the State Board of Education.
Austin American-Statesman
Friday, April 24, 2009

It's time for Don McLeroy to step down as chairman of the State Board of Education. Since he won't go willingly (and Gov. Rick Perry apparently won't remove his appointee), it is up to the Texas Senate to remove him from the chair.

Perry appointed McLeroy chairman in 2007 after the Legislature left town, so this year was the first opportunity for the Senate to exercise the body's power to ratify the appointment. McLeroy's tenure as chairman of the education board has been marked by controversies that have been a magnet for ridicule and rebuke from acclaimed scientists and researchers.

That kind of embarrassment would be bad enough if it were limited to the 15 members elected to the board from districts across the state. But here's the thing: The board wields real power in devising policies and setting academic standards for Texas public schools. It oversees the $17.5 billion Permanent School Fund. And, unfortunately, it is that same board that selects textbooks that go to the state's 4.7 million schoolchildren.

Though McLeroy, R-College Station, didn't start the culture wars that have polarized the board, he certainly amped up their volume — to the detriment of Texas students.
...
With McLeroy at the helm, some board members have made international news by questioning the theory of evolution, arguing that the universe is less than 10,000 years old and writing that President Barack Obama is a terrorist sympathizer who intends to establish martial law.

The board needs a strong leader who will stop the bickering and shift the focus back to students' needs.
...
It's clear that the board's dysfunction under McLeroy has done real damage to Texas public education. It is time to put a stop to it.
 
Last edited:
He just needs to go. Let him make his crazed pronouncements on his website or to his patients while he's filling their cavities, but please, don't let this buffoon continue to besmirch the entire state.
 
This guy has to go! If he has his way with TX, the rest of the US might insist on secession. Perry has to go, too, BTW.
 
global warming denier

He's a global warming denier too.

Education board's ideas on warming raise tempers
By LISA FALKENBERG
Houston Chronicle
April 6, 2009, 10:19PM

All eyes were on the State Board of Education’s assault of evolution a couple of weeks ago when members quietly voted to cast doubt on another hot topic: global warming.
...
Jim Marston, Environmental Defense Fund’s Texas director, said in a widely circulated e-mail that the board’s decision was an “outrage” that exposed Texas schoolchildren to junk science.

“This is not fair to our kids, who will be forced to compete in a world where the study of real science is taken seriously,” Marston wrote. “It’s time for the SBOE to acknowledge that the Earth is round, Elvis is dead, and yes, global warming is real.”

Meanwhile, education board chairman and proud Darwin-denier Don McLeroy was quoted in the Austin American-Statesman as saying “conservatives like me think the evidence (for human contributions to global warming) is a bunch of hooey.” (It’s reminiscent of the time his fellow member David Bradley called critical thinking in reading curriculum “gobbledygook.”)
...
• A recent University of Illinois at Chicago survey of 3,146 Earth scientists found that 90 percent believe Earth’s temperature has risen since pre-1800s levels, and 82 percent think human activity is a factor.

Of the 79 most knowledgeable climate specialists, the results were 96 percent and 97 percent.
...

Full: Houston Chronicle
 
And this guy's in charge of education? Wow. I mean, wow.
 
Dems: Votes there to bust McLeroy
‎May 25, 2009‎
News-Journal.com

Senate Democrats are claiming this evening they have more than enough votes to block the nomination of Bryan dentist Don McLeroy as chairman of the State Board of Education.

If true, the development would pose another setback for Gov. Rick Perry, who already has had two nominees turned back by senators so far: parole board nominee Shanda Perkins was rejected earlier this month, and Youth Commission ombudsman Will Harrell never came up for a vote.
...
Senators said this evening that a vote by the full Senate could come as soon as Tuesday or Wednesday.

San Antonio Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, who chairs the Senate Democratic Caucus, said all 12 Democrats in the Senate plan to vote against the nomination. It takes 11 votes to block consideration of nominations.

Several other Democrats this evening confirmed the tally of ‘no’ votes.

“At this point, I think they’ve got the votes to block,” acknowledged one GOP senator, who asked not to be quoted for fear of retribution by colleagues who are trying to get McLeroy approved. “I’ll be a little surprised if (the Senate GOP leadership) push the vote.”
...

According to the Texas Freedom Network, the Senate Nominations Committee Chairman gave a 24-hour notice for McLeroy's confirmation so the vote could happen on Thursday afternoon. If the block happens, rumors are that Rick Perry will nominate Cynthia Dunbar, who is just as radical. Watch Dunbar question Eugenie Scott and basically admit her religious movitations:




PS. You can see James Randi's comments on McLeroy here.
 
Last edited:
If Gov. Perry nominates Dunbar in place of McLeroy, it could very well be a hollow victory. That is, unless the Texas legislature has the stones to block her as well.
 
McLeroy's nomination was voted on and failed to pass today. From that link:

3:58 – The vote: 19 votes for his confirmation, 11 against. McLeroy’s confirmation fails. We will get a list of how senators voted ASAP.

UPDATE: The final vote was entirely along party lines. All Senate Republicans voted for confirmation, while 11 Democrats voted against. Democratic Sen. Lucio was present but did not vote.
 
Last edited:

Win!!! :D

Now to encourage the Texas legislature to scrutinize McLeroy's potential replacement. You can count on Gov. Perry to try slipping another creationist nutter past them...

So ultimately, all this crap is Perry's fault.

Well, yes and no. Ultimately, it is the fault of the people who voted Perry into office. It's my hope that enough people in Texas are waking up to the fact that he's a first-rate loon that come next election cycle, he'll be sent packing.
 
Last edited:
Thomas Ratliff

More trouble for McLeroy:

Former SBOE chairman draws challenger in GOP primary
Dallas Morning News
June 3, 2009

The son of former Lt. Gov. Bill Ratliff announced Wednesday that he will challenge State Board of Education member Don McLeroy of College Station in the GOP primary next year. Thomas Ratliff, a lobbyist and legislative consultant for the Ratliff Co., has filed paperwork with the Texas Ethics Commission to seek the Republican nomination for the SBOE District 9 seat in East Texas. Ratliff listed his residence as Mount Pleasant.
...
Although he is out as chairman, McLeroy retains his seat on the state board. But Ratliff said the board under McLeroy's leadership has become a "distraction" to neighborhood schools and a "liability" to the Republican Party. "I strongly believe we need to take the politics out of kids' education," said Ratliff, whose two children are in the Chapel Hill ISD.

Full article at: Dallas Morning News
 
Cynthia Dunbar update

If Gov. Perry nominates Dunbar in place of McLeroy, it could very well be a hollow victory. That is, unless the Texas legislature has the stones to block her as well.

Yeah, that's what the paper said with recent news:

Talk of Dunbar's potential role draws cheers, jeers
Conservative Christian may be in running to lead state education board
By GARY SCHARRER
SAN ANTONIO EXPRESS-NEWS
July 5, 2009, 8:31PM

AUSTIN — Critics who engineered the recent ouster of State Board of Education Chairman Don McLeroy, in part because of his strong religious beliefs, could end up with someone even more outspoken in her faith.

Cynthia Dunbar, R-Richmond, who advocated more Christianity in the public square last year with the publication of her book, One Nation Under God, is among those that Gov. Rick Perry is considering to lead the State Board of Education, some of her colleagues say.
...
In a book published last year, Dunbar argued the country’s founding fathers created “an emphatically Christian government” and that government should be guided by a “biblical litmus test.” She endorses a belief system that requires “any person desiring to govern have a sincere knowledge and appreciation for the Word of God in order to rightly govern.”

Also in the book, she calls public education a “subtly deceptive tool of perversion.”
...
Hardy, of Fort Worth, wants Perry to elevate Bob Craig, R-Lubbock, to the chairman’s seat. But such an appointment would not sit well with hard-core conservatives.
...

Full: SAN ANTONIO EXPRESS-NEWS

I like what PZ Myers pointed out: "Crazy Dunbar is regarded as a likely choice because her selection would make far-right conservatives happy; they don't even want a moderate Republican to be considered for the job. And Dunbar claims that she is just the person to bring together the various factions on the current board!"
 
I like what PZ Myers pointed out: "Crazy Dunbar is regarded as a likely choice because her selection would make far-right conservatives happy; they don't even want a moderate Republican to be considered for the job. And Dunbar claims that she is just the person to bring together the various factions on the current board!"

Ooops. I just misread that as "bring together the vacuous factions on the current board".

Meh. More or less right.
 
McLeroy lost:

Two State Board of Education incumbents lose in GOP primary
Dallas News
7:31 AM Wed, Mar 03, 2010

Mount Pleasant Republican Thomas Ratliff narrowly beat State Board of Education member and prominent social conservative Don McLeroy in the GOP primary Tuesday, while long-time board member Geraldine Miller of Dallas was upset by Dallas high school educator George Clayton. Ratliff (right) and McLeroy were expected to have a close race, but Miller was favored in her contest because of a big edge in campaign funds and her long-time incumbency. She has served on the board since 1984 and never had a close election race before.

Ratliff waged a strong campaign and outspent McLeroy for the board seat, which represents Collin County and much of Northeast Texas, but McLeroy also ran a strong race as he tried to capitalize on recent victories by the social conservative bloc on the 15-member education board. Among the successes were changes in curriculum standards for science, history and English. Ratliff accused McLeroy and his allies of ignoring the advice of teachers and education groups in their decisions - and of politicizing the curriculum requirements such as on teaching of evolution in science classes. Ratliff, a legislative consultant and lobbyist, carried 50.5 percent of the vote
...
 
The National Center for Science Education issued a report:

McLeroy booted in Texas
National Center for Science Education
March 3rd, 2010

In the March 2, 2010, primary election, avowed young-earth creationist Don McLeroy narrowly lost his bid to be the Republican candidate for the District 9 seat on the Texas state board of education. ...
...
... But McLeroy was unabashed. "Our science standards are light years ahead of any other state when it comes to challenging evolution," he told the Washington Monthly (January/February 2010), adding, "Evolution is hooey."
 
I hope Mr. McLeroy takes the primary results for what he claimed them to be to the Dallas Morning News - This election is a referendum over what we've accomplished on the board these past two years. I am proud of these accomplishments: the rejection of the math book, the adoption of new English Standards, the adoption of new Science Standards and the work that is being done to adopt new History Standards

It certainly was Don. It certainly was.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom