Homeopathy - I am ready for open challenge

[MRC_Hans]

Thanks, but I dont have desire to take dollars..... my intension is to ask Randi to remove homeopathy from MDC.

There will be a strong reason to include homeopathy in MDC that might be pressure from the side of allopathic pharmacies.

Unfortunately, you have a long way to go. You and I have discussed your experiment earlier, elsewhere, and from analysing your data, I'm quite certain that whatever patterns you see are artefacts deriving from your sampling frequency.

Hans

 

[muntadev2in]

I will be back with my blind studies. I am not getting time to conduct experiments I told you, I am working as Researc asst My equipement at my home town. I hope I will get tranfer soon. I will surely claim for MDC.

Aslo I have to plan how to escape from your mazical statistics.

Hope we all will meet at a desk soon.

Thanks,

Dr.Devendra Kumar munta.

 

[Acleron]

Aslo I have to plan how to escape from your mazical statistics.

I hope that word is not 'magical'.

 

[Akhenaten]

I will be back with my blind studies.

We'll see.

I am not getting time to conduct experiments

Try saving some time in a bottle and then use it to prepare a batch of homeopathic time. You'll have heaps more than you need.

I told you, I am working as Researc asst My equipement at my home town.

Perhaps you should stop telling us things like this. But since you have, then I might as well ask why you don't move Your Researc equipement and dictionary closer to where you are, and get started on the MDC.

I hope I will get tranfer soon. I will surely claim for MDC.

It's truly amazing to see the barriers that are thrown up by Kismet and the Cosmos to prevent potential MDC claimants from realizing their ambitions.

Aslo I have to plan how to escape from your mazical statistics.

Why don't you just ask Aslo to keep the cages locked?

Hope we all will meet at a desk soon.

That would be a big desk. Who's bringing the cake?

Thanks,

Dr.Devendra Kumar munta.

Dr. doesn't mean the same thing in all places, does it?



Akhenaten,

Now even more diluted and potent than before.

 

[Pixel42]

I hope that word is not 'magical'.

I think he means mazical as pertaining to a maze, in the way magical pertains to magic. A word which doesn't exist in the English language, but ought to. In fact as far as I'm concerned it now does

Though the fact that he appears to believe the word is applicable to a straightforward request that he demonstrate that his hit rate is significantly better than chance is a little concerning.

 

[JWideman]

There's nothing "mazical" about statistics. In fact, they seem very good at repelling "mazic".

 

[MRC_Hans]

I will be back with my blind studies. I am not getting time to conduct experiments I told you, I am working as Researc asst My equipement at my home town. I hope I will get tranfer soon. I will surely claim for MDC.

Aslo I have to plan how to escape from your mazical statistics.

Hope we all will meet at a desk soon.

Thanks,

Dr.Devendra Kumar munta.

Before you make any blind studies, you need to answer a question I have put to you elsewhere (and wich you have carefully ignored): In the data you have already collected and published (I have attached it below), you claim that there is a difference between the placebo and the medicine signals.

Please state exactly what this difference is.

If you can't do that, there is no need to proceed further.

Hans

 

[ruckenheim]

I think we "Randi Forum fornicators" may have seen the last of him:

http://www.hpathy.com/homeopathyforums/forum_posts.asp?TID=8526&PID=80283

 

[GzuzKryzt]

I think we "Randi Forum fornicators" may have seen the last of him:

http://www.hpathy.com/homeopathyforums/forum_posts.asp?TID=8526&PID=80283

"I am the visionary, you come up with the nuts and bolts."

Bart Simpson



Muntadev2in, will you come up with nuts and bolts for your MDC protocol? MRC_Hans' inquiry seems a good place to start.

 

[Pixel42]

I think we "Randi Forum fornicators" may have seen the last of him:

http://www.hpathy.com/homeopathyforums/forum_posts.asp?TID=8526&PID=80283

Oh dear, that's a pity. I really thought we might get to a workable test protocol with this one.

I hope he's smart enough to respond to comments like "We all know that homeopathy works" with "Well it should be simple to prove it under laboratory conditions then, shouldn't it?" and persevere with his double-blind self-testing at least. But I'm not optimistic

 

[Mojo]

I hope he's smart enough to respond to comments like "We all know that homeopathy works" with "Well it should be simple to prove it under laboratory conditions then, shouldn't it?"

I fear that the response is more likely to be "yes, we all know it works, but the skeptics deny this because they're in the pay of Big Pharma".

 

[Cuddles]

Stay on topic to the challenge. Any other subjects should be discussed in the appropriate section.

Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles

 

[Adavidson]

Sorry. Moved to Norway at 7, been living here ever since. After my father died I havn`t been speaking english much so I`m a bit rusty.

 

[catbasket]

Sorry. Moved to Norway at 7, been living here ever since. After my father died I havn`t been speaking english much so I`m a bit rusty.

I suspect arthwollipot was complementing you on your English in a joking kind of way ... the rest of your post was top quality

Back on topic - I take it there's still no sign of any communication from the good doctor. I wonder if he got unexpected results from blinded self-testing

 

[GzuzKryzt]

The thread title should read: I am ready to spout unsubstantiated crap, point to my degree in baloney, bitch about critical attitude towards the former and hence am in no way ready for an open challenge which includes two controlled tests.



Ah, perhaps he simply got paid off by Big Allopathy.

 

[JWideman]

I suspect arthwollipot was complementing you on your English in a joking kind of way ... the rest of your post was top quality

Back on topic - I take it there's still no sign of any communication from the good doctor. I wonder if he got unexpected results from blinded self-testing

I think that's why he was talking about "escaping [our] mazical statistics".

 

[MattC]

I do not understand what you hope to accomplish by passively insulting potential applicants.

~ Matt

 

[arthwollipot]

I suspect arthwollipot was complementing you on your English in a joking kind of way ... the rest of your post was top quality

Yes - my apologies if I was misinterpretable. I wasn't aware of whether English was your first language or not, but "physiological" is a tricky word and a lot of native speakers in my experience tend to spell the tricky words phonetically. Otherwise your English was impeccable.

 

[Adavidson]

Its fine, as I said I have not been able too use the language that much sicne we moved to Norway. Over here they don`t use PH as F. It was just a glip. I`ll pay better attention next time

 

[RossFW]

Dr Mutadev2in,

I wonder if you could answer a question for me regarding homeopathy.

You talk here about a 200c solution, or 10^201. This represents a solution something of the magnitude of a drop of water in a body of water the size of the sun.

Your fellow Homeopaths admit that at this dilution, not a single molecule of the active ingredient is in the remedy, but claim there is a "Memory" effect in the water used, at some sub-atomic level.

My question is this- If water has this property and "Remembers" the ingredient you add, wouldn't it also remember any other impurity that had ever been in it or any body of water it had been a part of? And as we are talking about such a tiny dilution, wouldn't all the water on earth have been exposed to just about every molecule that exists on the planet, and retain the "Memory" of that molecule?

Would not, in fact, every glass of water you use to prepare you remedies have a much higher concentration of every molecule of every remedy known to homeopathy than that of the solution you are preparing? And as higher doses reduce the effects of your remedies, would not that make ANY homeopathic solution using water ineffective?