• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

The Professor's writers claim the MDC is a sham

GzuzKryzt

Philosopher
G
Joined
Aug 18, 2005
Messages
6,363
The stage is yours, The Professor's writers.

Please provide evidence for the statement that the MDC is a sham.
 
I propose The Professor's claim is a sham.

Couldn't The Professor also list evidence,as he claims it too.
 
Last edited:
I can't believe I need to post a reminder this early.
Please keep this thread on topic. It is not for discussing The Professor's claim, nor any other claim specifically. It is to discuss whether the claim itself is a sham or not.

Anything further in this thread not on topic is in danger of being removed, and the thread may be put on moderated status.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
The original post seems to limit the responders to The Professor's writers. Which, if correct, should mean this thread is over.
 
Apologies for rule breaking,I dont know what thread is for what anymore ;)
 
I know a couple Paid Professional Florists who think that "The MDC" is a punk rock band... would their opinions change reality?
 
Thabiguy said:
You mean the MDC itself, right?
Click to expand...

Yes.
As per the OP, the claim has been made that the MDC is a sham. There's some context on page 18 of this thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=121157

GzuzKryzt said:
The Professor's writers claim the MDC is a shamhttp://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4064187#post4064187

The stage is yours, The Professor's writers.

Please provide evidence for the statement that the MDC is a sham.
Click to expand...
 
Since the MDC is not a sham, how can we post to this thread? If we're limited to producing evidence that it IS a sham, well, since it's not, that evidence is going to be a long time coming ...
 
Czarcasm said:
They are as real as his protocol, so there!
Click to expand...

Exactly! That's the beauty of imagination -- one can conjure up swathes of "professional writers," "TV deals," and a partridge in a pear tree, all without one shred of evidence.

Oh, I wish it were so!


M.
 
I think that the Professor has been watching The Amazing Race far too often, and decided that since he is doing a TV show as well, creating his own roadblocks is a great literary "show stopping" device which adds to the theatre of it all.

What have we had so far:

The Wedding and Honeymoon
Bad Moderation on "THA THREAD"
Biased negotiator
Writers needed
Change in Negotiator
2nd Biased Negotiator
Writers turn into judges and refuse to co-operate
Randi won't turn up and it's JREF's fault!!!

Is this a record?

Norm
 
Last edited:
fromdownunder said:
I think that the Professor has been watching The Amazing Race far too often, and decided that since he is doing a TV show as well, creating his own roadblocks is a great literary "show stopping" device which adds to the theatre of it all.

What have we had so far:

The Wedding and Honeymoon
Bad Moderation on "THA THREAD"
Biased negotiator
Writers needed
Change in Negotiator
2nd Biased Negotiator
Writers turn into judges and refuse to co-operate
Randi won't turn up and it's JREF's fault!!!

Is this a record?

Norm
Click to expand...

We'll need to wait for His Eminence to respond...


M.
 
I find it odd that a professional writer being payed to write something would decide not to. Even if they thought the MDC was a sham wouldn't they still want work. Or was it more they couldn't work with Mr. Koenig as he wouldn't let them write something that would actually get approved as he would no longer be able to do a performance and have to actually have a paranormal event occur. If it was the last case they might have said " This is a sham", and Mr. Koenig went "exactly the MDC is a sham" although they were talking about Mr. Koenigs claim.

Or my last idea about these writers. Who is a writer we have heard about who as a mutual acquaintance with Mr. Koenig? That would be Raymond Hill. So to prove he has a writer may indeed be a MDC winning attempt.
 
Seanrmr said:
I find it odd that a professional writer being payed to write something would decide not to. Even if they thought the MDC was a sham wouldn't they still want work. Or was it more they couldn't work with Mr. Koenig as he wouldn't let them write something that would actually get approved as he would no longer be able to do a performance and have to actually have a paranormal event occur. If it was the last case they might have said " This is a sham", and Mr. Koenig went "exactly the MDC is a sham" although they were talking about Mr. Koenigs claim.

Or my last idea about these writers. Who is a writer we have heard about who as a mutual acquaintance with Mr. Koenig? That would be Raymond Hill. So to prove he has a writer may indeed be a MDC winning attempt.
Click to expand...


One other possibility (and the one I'd bet on if I was betting)- there are no 'professional writers' and never were.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom