• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

ACLU: Decries bathroom Sting

ponderingturtle said:
You are mixing desire and intent. Wanting to have sex in a public bathroom fine, wanting someone to kill your wife, fine, asking someone to do either is very different though.
Click to expand...
Why is asking someone to have sex in a public place not ok?

I posted a legal opinion that having sex in a public bathroom isn't per se lewd in many jurisdictions.
 
RandFan said:
....I posted a legal opinion that having sex in a public bathroom isn't per se lewd in many jurisdictions.
Click to expand...
So you either think children have no right to use a public park bathroom, you think it's fine if they walk in on two (or more) guys butt(rule8)ing, or you don't believe the activity would be noticed by those kids despite the fact the police only get involved when people who do notice call and complain.

I also posted a legal opinion that in England, despite arguing paying to use the loo made it a private place, it was judged not to be. So where is it legal to have sex in a public place?
 
ponderingturtle said:
Why is asking someone to do something illegal not OK? Are you serious?

If you want to legalize bathroom sex then that would change things.
Click to expand...

I think it would be useful to clarify what is being discussed here, to avoid any possible misunderstandings.

Are we talking about asking, in a public place, someone to have sex, or asking someone to have sex in a public place?
 
skeptigirl said:
So you either think children have no right to use a public park bathroom, you think it's fine if they walk in on two (or more) guys butt(rule8)ing, or you don't believe the activity would be noticed by those kids despite the fact the police only get involved when people who do notice call and complain.

I also posted a legal opinion that in England, despite arguing paying to use the loo made it a private place, it was judged not to be. So where is it legal to have sex in a public place?
Click to expand...
I've told you time and again I don't think it is ok. You are not engaging in logically valid argument but are instead focusing on me and doing so when you know what you are saying is untrue.

A child might notice that something unusual is going on but how would the child know what was going on? The activity is in a single stall behind closed doors or is between stalls. A child would have to bend down to peer under the stall to see anything.
 
ponderingturtle said:
Why is asking someone to do something illegal not OK? Are you serious?
Click to expand...
Damn straight I am and I told you why.

If you want to legalize bathroom sex then that would change things.
Click to expand...
Such behavior is illegal, in many if not most places, only if it is being witnessed. There IS a basis for my question.
 
ponderingturtle said:
So when do you think proposing illegal activities should be illegal?
Click to expand...
First off it is only potentially illegal (in many jurisdictions)

As to your question, most of the time. In this instance and perhaps others there are better ways to deal with the situation rather than outlawing speech.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom