"Heavy metal gets socially conscious"

Questioninggeller

Illuminator
Joined
May 11, 2002
Messages
3,048
Below is an interesting article that discusses metal and social issues. I wonder how much the lyrical content actually affects teenagers.

Heavy metal gets socially conscious
By JUSTIN M. NORTON, Associated Press Writer
Thu Aug 10,

SAN FRANCISCO - Heavy metal singer Chris Barnes didn't know what people would think of "Amerika the Brutal," an anti-war song he wrote after his cousin deployed to Iraq in 2003.

He heard a number of complaints — but also received supportive e-mails from American troops in the war zone.

"It kind of sent a shiver up my spine because those are the guys I didn't want to offend by sounding anti-war," said Barnes, vocalist for the death metal band Six Feet Under.
...
Cattle Decapitation vocalist Travis Ryan said his San Diego band's mix of charging guitars and an animal rights message is drawing a diverse crowd that includes activists as well as traditional metal fans.

"We've always had a lot of crazy crossover going on," he said before a recent show. "It's a pretty diverse crowd we have. I've never known what to make of it."

Twenty artists recently displayed art inspired by the band's last album "Humanure," in an online exhibit. Proceeds from sales of the art will be donated to animal rights causes.

Metal bands are also branching out into literature and mythology. Mastodon, which is headlining a summer tour with metal stalwart Slayer, patterned the concept album "Leviathan" around the story of Moby Dick. Death metal band Nile bases its songs and image around Egyptian mythology and iconography.

"Metal is expanding and evolving and becoming more diverse," said Canadian anthropologist and filmmaker Sam Dunn, who directed "Metal: A Headbanger's Journey," released on DVD this summer. "It's at a much more vibrant state than it was even five or 10 years ago."
...
Metal music in the 1980s was often homophobic and "very white," she said, but current bands tend to be socially conscious and suspicious of political power. There's also more women in the audience — and fronting the bands.

"This is another generation rising," Gaines said.

Heavy metal has always touched on social and political issues. Metal grandfathers Black Sabbath criticized the Vietnam War in songs like "War Pigs" and "Children of the Grave." Iron Maiden's "Run to the Hills" was an angry denunciation of the displacement of Native Americans.
...
Napalm Death was a product of Britain's "Crass" movement, which fused anarchism and punk in the late 1980s. Vocalist Mark "Barney" Greenway, a vegetarian and peace advocate, is often pulled aside by fans who want to know more about his progressive views.

One recent song, "The Code is Red, Long Live the Code," takes aim at the spate of terror alerts in America with lyrics like: "Switched on to subdue when the masses switch off."

"It's really, really difficult sometimes to break through the cloud of apathy, so it's great when someone comes and asks why you are coming from your perspective," Greenway said during a recent tour stop in California.

"When you come into a country like America, when you challenge thinking, it's a great affront to some people," he said.

The lyrics on Lamb of God's two most recent albums have been expressly political, and the politics lean heavily to the left.

Napalm Death's Greenway is considering work as a political activist when his metal days are over, but he doesn't think metal will ever completely stray from hedonistic and supernatural themes.

"I appreciate that not everything has to be awareness raising or political," he said. "Music is also a form of entertainment and it should remain that way. Variety is the spice of life. Escapism is a good thing if it doesn't cloud your vision."

Full article at Yahoo News
 
At least its a genre of music that can get away from singing the same thing over and over again....
 
This thread reminds me of Stewie Griffin's memory of his failed performance at Woodstock.

Establishment, establishment you know what's best for me!"
 
what a stupid title. Ecept for the few bands that hit the radio, the majority of modern metal bands took up the political front when hardcore punk left off

And before that, in the 80's xover type metal was ALL political. Only a few of the underground bands did anything BUT politics, notebale exception like slayer who mixed politics with religion..

And I would argue that LONG before that, say 1970, the first band who legitamately and unarguably could be considered to be playing Heavy Metal, Black Sabbath, had a song War Pigs, which was about as political as any song could get then or now, barring bands like CRASS or Conflict, who just write political essays with music kinda thrown in as background noise
 
That's what I was thinking. Just in Metallica's albums you can find anti-war, anti-drug, anti-religion messages, along with teen apathy and anti-establishment. And all that happened before 'and Justice for All..." was put out.

Iron Maiden did Two Minutes Before Midnight and quite a few scathing commentaries on contemporary issues. Heavy Metal has always been an anti-establishment thing. Hell, if you want to go WAY back, Steppenwolf and Led Zep did a few political songs. IIRC, the term 'heavy metal' was coined by a critic reviewing a Steppenwolf concert, though it would not be thought so by today's standards. Quite the opposite.

This article sounds like it was written by someone who listens to Barry Manilo and just discovered that the "heavy, screaming music" actually has some meaning to it.

Just my take.
 
Not to derail, but ehh what the hay, the "Heavy Metal" "adult-ish comic" magazine once started reducing, month after month, the size of "eavy" and "etal" on its cover, intending to change the name to HM. This was quickly reversed after one month and a big outcry.

The reason they wanted to do it: Too many young teenagers were buying it, thinking it was about the badass music style heavy metal, getting it home, and seeing lots voilence? No, that wouldn't upset mothers. Ummm, gore and guts? Nah, that wouldn't be a problem. Oh yeah. Cartoon boobies!

Think the 1980 "Heavy Metal" movie, if you can't recall what I'm talking about.
 
what a stupid title. Ecept for the few bands that hit the radio, the majority of modern metal bands took up the political front when hardcore punk left off

When did Punk ever leave the political front? There have been numerous punk bands that have made great music in opposition to the war in Iraq as well as opposition to the Bush administration. Green Day won awards for their "American Idiot" CD, Bad Religion's "The Empire Strikes First" was pretty popular, and nearly every punk band on the Vans Tour made political statements against the fiasco caused by this administration.

It's about time that Heavy Metal woke up - they've been hiding behind their girly hairdos and predictable guitar riffs long enough. :)
 
Green Day won awards for their "American Idiot" CD, Bad Religion's "The Empire Strikes First" was pretty popular,...

How dare you name those two albums in the same sentence ;)

American Idiot is aptly named, whereas TESF is probably one of the most intelligent albums ever, as well as there being no contest musically :P

Anyhoo:

"Metal bands are also branching out into literature and mythology."

Like this is a new thing?
 
How dare you name those two albums in the same sentence ;)

American Idiot is aptly named, whereas TESF is probably one of the most intelligent albums ever, as well as there being no contest musically :P

:) I see I've run into someone who appreciate less "commercial" punk. ;)

I've often taken dookie (:)) for liking Green Day and usually by people who believe they're sell-outs. I happen to think they're great lyricists in spite of the fact that they've become more general appeal.

Bad Religion has always been a favorite to listen to on harrowing bike rides; it really gets the adreneline flowing. I will agree that TESF is probably one of the most intelligent albums ever, but I'd like to think that Green Day's general appeal is reaching people who would ordinarily write off any punk music. :)

For the record, I was only joking about the girly hair of metal bands. It was probably too long ago for most to remember, but there was a bit of rivalry between metal and punk (back when punk bands were trying to get away from the endless glam and wanted Rock & Roll to be dangerous and pertinent again). :)

Can anyone provide any info about whether this is happening in other music genres? I don't listen to Country or Rap (Hip Hop or whatever it's called these days), and Classical is pretty static so I don't know.
 
green days politics arent about anything but their desire to cater to their perceived market. To put them in the same sentence with bad religion....ugh

Then again bad religion has gone whacko as of late...

Yes hardcore punk never left politics, but it came to thin out SEVERELY as a genre...most "punk" you find nowdays is of the green day/blink 182 variety

typical pop40 crap, that would be brittney spears if it had more dancing
 
At least its a genre of music that can get away from singing the same thing over and over again....

Since you are generalizing, rock by definition uses the 32 pop song formula; AABA. They generally play in fours, and the lyrical content matches that (except certain types of metal and jazz). With the exception of "classical music," genre's are defined in general terms as vocal style and guitar style, not exactly in terms of how many times a chorus or pre-chorus is sung.
 
what a stupid title. Ecept for the few bands that hit the radio, the majority of modern metal bands took up the political front when hardcore punk left off

Well, some people might think of "glam metal," which wasn't "socially aware." I mean Motley Crue's ("Girls, Girls, Girls"), Van Halen's ("Hot For Teacher"), Poison, etc were the 1980s biggest acts and they didn't discuss social issues.
 
Well, some people might think of "glam metal," which wasn't "socially aware." I mean Motley Crue's ("Girls, Girls, Girls"), Van Halen's ("Hot For Teacher"), Poison, etc were the 1980s biggest acts and they didn't discuss social issues.

Yes this would explain the part of my sentence that said "Ecept for the few bands that hit the radio"

I forgot the x in except

From the very start of the genre (at least the first one of the bands to use 8 note scales instead of pentatonic blues) it was political. Never stopped. The rules for ANY band of ANY genre:

You want it on the radio, leave the politics out, politics divide.

Some bands were strong enough to bring politics in a VERY general way to the radio, when there was an extremely popular sentiment about an issue throughout nearly the entire intended audience. Songs about war and pot for instance in the late 60's

Perhaps some miss the irony of "one nation controlled by the media" as an alleged criticism, BY those in fact who ARE the media...I thought it was funny
 
:) I see I've run into someone who appreciate less "commercial" punk. ;)

I've often taken dookie (:)) for liking Green Day and usually by people who believe they're sell-outs. I happen to think they're great lyricists in spite of the fact that they've become more general appeal.

Bad Religion has always been a favorite to listen to on harrowing bike rides; it really gets the adreneline flowing. I will agree that TESF is probably one of the most intelligent albums ever, but I'd like to think that Green Day's general appeal is reaching people who would ordinarily write off any punk music. :)

For the record, I was only joking about the girly hair of metal bands. It was probably too long ago for most to remember, but there was a bit of rivalry between metal and punk (back when punk bands were trying to get away from the endless glam and wanted Rock & Roll to be dangerous and pertinent again). :)

Can anyone provide any info about whether this is happening in other music genres? I don't listen to Country or Rap (Hip Hop or whatever it's called these days), and Classical is pretty static so I don't know.

The only Country group with a political message that is mainstream is the Dixie Chicks, that I know of. Don't look for a lot of imitators.
 
"True" metal has always been more complex than most ever give it credit for. It's not all juvenille songs about getting high, girls, sex, or why daddy never loved me. There are lots of concept albums in metal which is something I don't see too much of outside the genre. When is the last time a pop band or Propagandhi released something like Crimson or Still Life? Acid Bath's "Scream of the Butterlfy" is one of the most moving songs I've ever heard. If you count religion, then the entire genre of black metal qualifies as well, even if most of it is silly and childish.
 
Yes this would explain the part of my sentence that said "Ecept for the few bands that hit the radio"

I forgot the x in except

From the very start of the genre (at least the first one of the bands to use 8 note scales instead of pentatonic blues) it was political. Never stopped. The rules for ANY band of ANY genre:

You want it on the radio, leave the politics out, politics divide.

Some bands were strong enough to bring politics in a VERY general way to the radio, when there was an extremely popular sentiment about an issue throughout nearly the entire intended audience. Songs about war and pot for instance in the late 60's

Perhaps some miss the irony of "one nation controlled by the media" as an alleged criticism, BY those in fact who ARE the media...I thought it was funny

I disagree. Metallica was able to get songs such as 'One', 'and Justice for All', and 'Master of Puppets' on the radio. Black Sabbath's 'War Pigs' was well played, as was Iron Maiden's 'Two Minutes to Midnight' and 'Run for the Hills'.

Political songs have, historically, done well on the radio, all the way back to 'Fortunate Son' from CCR, and further....

The quality of the band dictates what can be on the radio. The best bands can put out the political stuff and 'get away' with it.
 
Let me know when you see a CRASS song on the radio

and I thought I covered the caveat with "Some bands were strong enough to bring politics in a VERY general way to the radio, when there was an extremely popular sentiment about an issue throughout nearly the entire intended audience. Songs about war and pot for instance in the late 60's"
 
And all this time I thought they were shrugging the bonds of Barry Manilow's "Copacabana." ;)
 

Back
Top Bottom