• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Bad ideas in war

I am reminded of 'McNamara's Morons'.
Just looked that up.

My understanding is that it was the US army that was key in adopting IQ tests, and whatever they test, poor results in them translated to poor performance in war.
 
Perum tries to justify a load of bad ideas


The first bad idea was from Ian of Forgotten Weapons
Ian at Forgotten Weapons has quite a few what weapon would the Elbonian military buy videos.
His latest regular Q&A video has an Elbonian question in it.
I think Drachinifel has addressed it in passing in his weekly Q&A video. The Chieftain has at least one as well.
 
Germany was 100% to blame for the war.

Nothing to do with Russia?


Screenshot 2026-09-19 03.21.21.png

"Historians studying the causes of World War I have often highlighted the roles of Germany and Austria-Hungary, while downplaying Russia's contribution to the outbreak of this global conflict. The prevailing scholarly view has focused on Russia's defense of Orthodox Serbia, its pan-Slavic aspirations, its treaty commitments with France, and its efforts to maintain its status as a major world power. However, historian Sean McMeekin emphasizes Russia's ambitions to expand its empire southward and to capture Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul) as a gateway to the Mediterranean Sea."

"Russia's warnings to Germany led to military action by German forces, which carried out their mobilization and declared war on August 1, 1914. At the start of the conflict, Russian forces launched offensives against Germany and Austria-Hungary"
 
Last edited:
Important role because the Nazi party made it a scapegoat, along with the stab in the back myth.

Please read thru the following article:


And I even kinda don't think that article goes far enough. With the "Germany was at fault" section. Germany was at fault for WW1. They goaded the Austrian Empire into declaring war despite Serbia agreeing to almost all their demands. And it was for their own expansionist goals. Germany was 100% to blame for the war.

and watch
and realize that Foch's quote "This is not a peace treaty, this is an armistice for 20 years". Is often misinterpreted. He didn't think it was too harsh, he wanted an occupation.
Tell me you're a Stalinist without telling me you're a Stalinist.

I don't think Russia has ever been in a war that Russia didn't have a part in instigating.
 
Nothing to do with Russia?


View attachment 75916

"Historians studying the causes of World War I have often highlighted the roles of Germany and Austria-Hungary, while downplaying Russia's contribution to the outbreak of this global conflict. The prevailing scholarly view has focused on Russia's defense of Orthodox Serbia, its pan-Slavic aspirations, its treaty commitments with France, and its efforts to maintain its status as a major world power. However, historian Sean McMeekin emphasizes Russia's ambitions to expand its empire southward and to capture Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul) as a gateway to the Mediterranean Sea."

"Russia's warnings to Germany led to military action by German forces, which carried out their mobilization and declared war on August 1, 1914. At the start of the conflict, Russian forces launched offensives against Germany and Austria-Hungary"
I suppose we need this again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom