• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Autistic genius novelist woos the literary world with novel composed using "Facilitated Communication"

When did you get access to his diagnosis?
If he is unable to write because of motor coordination difficulties then he is dyspraxic. Being dyspraxic does not equate to severe learning difficulty. If Woody did not have bodily motor coordination difficulties or poor attention deficit then of course he would sit in front of a computer, laptop or tablet and type out his own stuff.
 
Your bigotry (either that or you 19th century understanding of psychology) is showing.

The term is “autistic savant”. It is your own claim that he is intelligent, therefore, calling him an “idiot” is a disgusting slur on a handicapped person that shows your underlying sense of your own mental superior to anyone else in the room with you.
How is it bigotry to point out that Woody does not have severe learning difficulty? Stop lying. I have at no point described Woody as an idiot. The term 'idiot savant' is in quotation marks because that is the colloquial term. Your claim "calling him an “idiot” is a disgusting slur on a handicapped person that shows your underlying sense of your own mental superior to anyone else in the room with you" is a malicious lie on your part.
 
Trolls, feed, don't, etc. (or do, this thread has probably run its course anyway). They saw the thread slowing down so they're throwing out a new slew of inflammatory remarks. Like saying people with ADHD can't use computers, which they'll also probably endlessly quibble over if someone were to correct them.
Nobody has said people with ADHD can't use computers. We are talking about a specific person here: Woody Brown. People can't understand why he can't sit down at a PC, laptop or tablet like anyone else. He has severe autism which includes high anxiety and a compulsion to focus on video films and animations. He concentrates so intently it is hard to get his attention. When his mother and teachers realised Woody was not severely learning disabled but actually gifted, they made an effort to help him realise his intellectual capabilities.
 
Ah shoot! I was gonna watch this, but now the Telepathy Tapes guys got it copyright struck. So it's gone.

I tried searching the name and found some true believers saying not to listen to him because he's an ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊, just like that James Randi guy.
Claiming that Woody communicates by supposed telepathy has not been proven.
 
If he is unable to write because of motor coordination difficulties then he is dyspraxic. Being dyspraxic does not equate to severe learning difficulty. If Woody did not have bodily motor coordination difficulties or poor attention deficit then of course he would sit in front of a computer, laptop or tablet and type out his own stuff.
When did you get access to his diagnosis?
 
There is nothing personal there. You have read somewhere that FC is a fraud but you haven't done any background research as to what the issues are. That is a perfectly valid argument for me to point out.
At least your jokes take one's mind off the current world situation!
 
Last edited:
You have a few misconceptions here. The controversy in psychology over conditions such as severe autism was (a) claims it could be 'cured', and (b) the morality and ethics of claiming people with severe learning difficulties (SLD) are effectively communicating when they do not have that capacity, i.e., exploitation. Woody has severe autism but he does not have SLD, quite the reverse, unless his college, university tutors and publishers are conning the public. So if Woody has the intellectual ability to understand, learn and communicate, he is not SLD and all the hysteria about 'debunking' and 'pseudoscience' just because he is severely disabled yet able to communicate is coming from people who haven't actually done their homework and are just mindlessly jumping on a bandwagon. It is of course possible it is all one big gimmick but there is nothing to suggest that so far.

If he is unable to write because of motor coordination difficulties then he is dyspraxic. Being dyspraxic does not equate to severe learning difficulty. If Woody did not have bodily motor coordination difficulties or poor attention deficit then of course he would sit in front of a computer, laptop or tablet and type out his own stuff.

How is it bigotry to point out that Woody does not have severe learning difficulty? Stop lying. I have at no point described Woody as an idiot. The term 'idiot savant' is in quotation marks because that is the colloquial term. Your claim "calling him an “idiot” is a disgusting slur on a handicapped person that shows your underlying sense of your own mental superior to anyone else in the room with you" is a malicious lie on your part.

Nobody has said people with ADHD can't use computers. We are talking about a specific person here: Woody Brown. People can't understand why he can't sit down at a PC, laptop or tablet like anyone else. He has severe autism which includes high anxiety and a compulsion to focus on video films and animations. He concentrates so intently it is hard to get his attention. When his mother and teachers realised Woody was not severely learning disabled but actually gifted, they made an effort to help him realise his intellectual capabilities.

There is nothing personal there. You have read somewhere that FC is a fraud but you haven't done any background research as to what the issues are. That is a perfectly valid argument for me to point out.

Claiming that Woody communicates by supposed telepathy has not been proven.

This is an attempt at distraction with strawmen an irrelevances
 
When did you get access to his diagnosis?
By inference. There is a paucity of information on this so I expect there will be a biography along soon explaining his struggles. I feel confident that Woody will not have been accepted on his degree courses as a disabled student without a detailed assessment of his developmental needs and the disabilty support he needed. I understand why people are sceptical. However, I prefer to wait until we have ALL the details before condemning Woody's mother as a fraud - because of <fx deep intake of breath> FC - and claiming Woody's intellectual abilities are near to non-existent and therefore, it would be immoral to facilitate communication with him.
 
At least your jokes take one's mind off the current world situation!
The controversy around FC is to do with the idea that deeply disabled people with severe learning disabilities (SDL) are being exploited by use of communication methods other than by speech. I am not sure why you are assuming ipso facto that this unethical use extends to ALL severely disabled people but I accept that you are utterly convinced Woody's mother is perpetrating a con because Woody is severely disabled. And an angry person on YouTube says so.
 
The controversy around FC is to do with the idea that deeply disabled people with severe learning disabilities (SDL) are being exploited by use of communication methods other than by speech. I am not sure why you are assuming ipso facto that this unethical use extends to ALL severely disabled people but I accept that you are utterly convinced Woody's mother is perpetrating a con because Woody is severely disabled. And an angry person on YouTube says so.
There is no documented "Ouija board" method to help autistic people communicate. Your essentially saying that Woody and his mother have invented a completely original and revolutionary method, one that looks remarkably similar to a documented scam.

Do you see why people find this hard to believe?
 
By inference. There is a paucity of information on this so I expect there will be a biography along soon explaining his struggles. I feel confident that Woody will not have been accepted on his degree courses as a disabled student without a detailed assessment of his developmental needs and the disabilty support he needed. I understand why people are sceptical. However, I prefer to wait until we have ALL the details before condemning Woody's mother as a fraud - because of <fx deep intake of breath> FC - and claiming Woody's intellectual abilities are near to non-existent and therefore, it would be immoral to facilitate communication with him.
Also known as "pulled it from my arse"
 
So Vixen, you haven't done any further research about fc, apart from wiki, and yet you feel able to state that what Mary Brown is doing is not that?

And yes, you are indulging in personal attacks on people in this thread, over and over. Saying that you don't does not make it so.

Please see my comments re the difference between a severely disabled person with severe learning disabilty ~vs~ those who do not have SDL.
 
There is no documented "Ouija board" method to help autistic people communicate. Your essentially saying that Woody and his mother have invented a completely original and revolutionary method, one that looks remarkably similar to a documented scam.

Do you see why people find this hard to believe?

Yes, I fully understand the scepticism. But Woody is supposedly highly intelligent so anything designed to help him communicate and achieve his aims to be like any other young man is not unethical under those circumstances.
 
Yes, I fully understand the scepticism. But Woody is supposedly highly intelligent so anything designed to help him communicate and achieve his aims to be like any other young man is not unethical under those circumstances.
But it doesn't help him to be like any other young man, since he cannot communicate unless his mother is with him. Depriving him of the opportunity to communicate directly with others, if possible, is definitely unethical.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom