• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Declining IQ of college grads

Well at least this generated some discussion.

Someone asked for evidence standards have been lowered, lol.

We award high school degrees for "special education" students now who cannot compete with average students. There's a lot of money in it. A whole slew of acts direct funding to making sure stupid people, most of all, are awarded degrees.

In 1893 the Massachusetts supreme court upheld the expulsion of a student solely due to poor academic ability. My God, have times changed.

Generally the education-industrial complex likes to conflate stupidity with "disabilities", as if a moron was the same thing as Stephen Hawking being in a wheelchair.

When you increase the proportion of people attending school by 250% the education-industrial complex is the primary beneficiary.

But this is the one place we are to never question economic motivations.

What on earth is a "high school degree"?
 
I have been known to complain about a school policy that should be called:

"No child shall be allowed to get ahead."

It was my experience of primary school and high school, that they did their utmost to try and prevent me from getting an education. (They even went so far as to confiscate my books at school).

Fortunately that went away when I started my first degree.
 
Americans seem to 'graduate' a lot.

Junior High School, Senior High School.

Perhaps they even 'graduate' from primary school?

Is there a primary school degree?

American here. No, no graduations from junior high (very casual term) and we don't even use the term "senior high". We do have a kinda sorta graduation from primary school, because many districts give you a choice of high schools to attend, some of which are not in your district and in the same system, so you formally are leaving one curriculum and entering another. So we have maybe one more "graduation" than just high school, but it's pretty low key and informal, mostly a pomp ad circumstance feel-good thing for mom.
 
Americans seem to 'graduate' a lot.

Junior High School, Senior High School.

Perhaps they even 'graduate' from primary school?

Is there a primary school degree?

I "graduated" from 8th grade but it was a Catholic school so the nuns made us feel bad about it.
 
Good barometer: did you meaningfully get what you wanted out of your life, and feel satisfied? Congratulations, you are a success! If not, it doesn't matter what you banked or degrees you bagged, you done ****** up.

Yep.

But I’m working on my forty time in retirement.
 
Yes but the selection heavily favoured the little Lord Fountelroys of the upper class. I would say that, now that academics is more open to all, standards will necessarily be much higher than when academics were the preserve of the elite, because nowadays degrees are far less likely to be in recognition of being your father's son.

That change definitely happened, but the transition happened IIRC* in the 40's and 50's, and while college admissions were increasing then, they were still no where near modern day levels.

I don't remember if we have actual research on this, but I think there's reason to believe that IQs of college grads went up during that early period when it was still a small elite who were attending college, but it had shifted away from the children of the upper class and toward the high achievers looking to climb the social/economic ladder. Of course it was (and remains) a mix of both.

Perhaps also worth noting is the the elite institutions today remain extremely selective, perhaps more so than in the past.

*I'd have to double check, it may have been slightly earlier.
 
Do you really not know what he means?

We ask questions like that, because terms don't necessarily map from USA to Australia.

For example, we have terms like:

Leaving certificate;
Year 12 certificate;
Matriculation certificate/High School Certificate/ATAR.

Notice the lack of the word 'degree' ?

A High School degree would be some kind of academic qualification for teachers, something like a Bachelor of Education (Secondary) or a Master of Education (Secondary) for someone with other tertiary qualifications.

You're welcome,

:)
 
Notice the lack of the word 'degree' ?

A High School degree would be some kind of academic qualification for teachers, something like a Bachelor of Education (Secondary) or a Master of Education (Secondary) for someone with other tertiary qualifications.

Well, I'm pretty sure that Darat wasn't actually confused enough to think that ABP was talking about academic qualifications for teachers. Personally I see language as a means of communicating ideas, and as long as I understand what someone means, it has done its job.

If you or Darat actually were confused, I apologize, but his posts seemed clear enough to me. Making a nitpick correction is completely fine, I just don't believe that Darat didn't actually understand. As I said, he can correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Americans have never in history referred to a high school degree. You get a diploma. ABP's post is the only known usage in American history, save a few functional illiterates here and there.
 
Typical USA is grade schools give a cert of completion, HS gets a diploma.
If you get a HS equivalence later after after dropping out of school, tech schools offer a GED program to show you have passed the typical HS program.

Colleges give degrees.
 
Americans have never in history referred to a high school degree. You get a diploma. ABP's post is the only known usage in American history, save a few functional illiterates here and there.

Yep. My point isn't that he's correct, it's that he's understandable.
 
Yep. My point isn't that he's correct, it's that he's understandable.

Agreed, if he was maybe an ESL guy. But I'm pretty sure he isn't, and is quite deliberately screwing up the terminology. So if see Darat's question as inviting clarification, more than actual confusion.
 
Agreed, if he was maybe an ESL guy. But I'm pretty sure he isn't, and is quite deliberately screwing up the terminology. So if see Darat's question as inviting clarification, more than actual confusion.

I agree that if he's doing it on purpose then the confrontational tone is probably justified, and remove my objection. I read it as just an honest mistake, but your reading makes sense too.
 
Yes but the selection heavily favoured the little Lord Fountelroys of the upper class. I would say that, now that academics is more open to all, standards will necessarily be much higher than when academics were the preserve of the elite, because nowadays degrees are far less likely to be in recognition of being your father's son.

Belated nitpick: in the original story, Fauntleroy is a fairly streetwise kid who lives in New York with his "Dearest" widowed mother. The privilege comes about later on.
 
Agreed, if he was maybe an ESL guy. But I'm pretty sure he isn't, and is quite deliberately screwing up the terminology. So if see Darat's question as inviting clarification, more than actual confusion.

I was confused and sought clarification, thanks to watching way too many USA trials I know that you have to meet a certain level of achievement to "graduate" high school, given the topic of this thread it had me wondering if some folk are saying High schools now offer degree courses!
 
I was confused and sought clarification, thanks to watching way too many USA trials I know that you have to meet a certain level of achievement to "graduate" high school, given the topic of this thread it had me wondering if some folk are saying High schools now offer degree courses!

In that case I apologize. It seemed obvious to me in context that he had just messed up, and I misread your reply. Sorry about that.
 

Back
Top Bottom