Dave Rogers
Bandaged ice that stampedes inexpensively through
The fundamental "error" both make is that they get wrong what is actually plotted in the video - which renders all their calculations moot. Their "misunderstanding" is derived from a not very precisely formulated bullet point in the video, one that can only be "misunderstood" if one stops to watch the video there.
I'm a little intrigued by this, but not enough to watch an hour and ten of incredible tedium. Boiled down into a brief summary, the claim seems to me to be:
If we take X as the number of votes for the full Republican ticket and Y as the number of off-ticket Trump votes, then:
Y is negatively correlated with X.
Is that correct?
If so, isn't that totally bloody obvious from the fact that the number of off-ticket votes is a subset of the remaining votes after the full ticket votes have been deducted, so simple probability demands that they correlate negatively?
Dave