It's hard to say, because I already hated Trump so it's somewhat difficult to put myself in a position of a Trump lover, or even a lukewarm Trump voter.
To me, when the "grab them by the pussy" tape came out, my biggest thought was actually. "Hillary. Stop talking about this! No one cares!" It was the Saturday before the election when I spent a lot of time in my car, and heard that on a Hillary commercial played over and over again that I first started getting nervous.
In other words, at that time, a lot of Democrats were saying, "We've got him!", but I, and apparently somewhere close to half the voters were saying, "I don't care." I thought that was the most overplayed moment of the campaign.
I have a different feeling this time. It was so staged. So obviously phony. Will it actually matter? Time will tell. I just think the "I'm going to use a church and a Bible as a prop" motif doesn't play well. I wish I could read the minds of Trump voters, or people who would consider voting for him, to see how this played.