As much as I'd like to see Kavanaugh spend the rest of his days slipping on banana peels or something, these kooks can't have it both ways. If the witch is claiming some kind of power and she is applying that power to do harm to another person then that's assault, right?
I'm struggling for an analogy, but something like shooting at someone with an unloaded gun might work. Whether she knows the gun is empty or she doesn't, she still gets in trouble.
The kinds of workings discussed in this thread don't generally rise to that level. Though the news writer described Melissa Madara's spell as a "hexing" it was probably not a curse of the "may your gall bladder fall out..." variety. "May you suffer the rightful repercussions of your misdeeds..." is more in vogue.
Here's an example of a different rite, from before the confirmation, which was part of the public political magic that was being promoted to prevent it. The main purposes of it appear to be:
1. Assure that Kavanaugh is punished for his crimes against women.
You are powerless over any woman you have abused
Your foul deeds have bound you
To their consequences
And as the elements expose
What lies hidden beneath the soil
So you wicked behavior
Shall be exposed to all
2. Prevent Kavanaugh from harming women in the future.
Say:
I bind you, Brett Michael Kavanaugh
I bind your groping, grasping hands
I bind your leering eyes
I bind your lying mouth
When the paper doll is completely wrapped, tie a knot, binding it to the candle.
Say:
I bind your genitals, that they may fail to bring you pleasure at another’s expense
With the pin or nail, pierce the paper doll’s genital area, embedding the pin or nail in the candle.
3. Prevent Kavanaugh from being confirmed as a Supreme Court Justice.
Say, with increasing intensity:
...
In the name of all women harmed by men
In the name of truth
In the name of Justice
You are bound!
You shall never sit on the highest court!
Blow out the black candle, visualizing Kavanaugh fading away into the dust of history. Feel the joy you will experience when he fails to become appointed to the Supreme Court.
4. Support the claimed victims by sending "love and healing energy" to them.
Now hold your hands out to the white candle. Imagine your heart glowing in your chest, then send that love and healing energy through your arms and out of your palms to the candle. Send that love to Christine Blasey Ford, Deborah Ramirez, Julie Swetnick, and all women harmed by men, saying:
May you be healed
May you be protected
May your truth prevail
Overall it's not very assault-like, except for part 2 if you pay attention to the obvious symbolism of the ritual action rather than just the words of the incantation.
However, that very inconsistency is one of many ways the ritual is very poorly designed. It's all over the map; there are at least those four distinct "intentions" when focusing of intention is supposed to be the key to the whole thing. And there's that inconsistent symbolism I mentioned earlier.
For instance, the start of the ritual invokes Venus by inscribing her symbol on the white candle. This was most likely chosen because the ancient symbol of Venus is used as a symbol of feminism by modern Americans. But Venus isn't the goddess of feminism, she's the goddess of Getting It On, and in mythology has never been one to let issues of prudence, propriety, or even consent get in the way.
In other words, not the best choice of deity to invoke, for the binding (or stabbing!) of a supposed horn dog's genitals. (Possible Venusian backlash: the caster becomes irresistibly attracted to an obviously unsuitable prospect, or to a succession of them.)
Speaking of backlash, consider the ritual's final words: "By the swift sword of Justice, so mote it be". Invoking the supernatural powers of Justice, in case Venus doesn't get the job done.
Now, imagine if a supernatural power of Justice actually existed, what it might look like. You might, for example, visualize it as a grim-faced angel carrying a flaming sword. (The people doing the casting will have visualized it in that or a similar way.) Not, in this case, a blindfolded person carrying a set of scales, so as to make a wise and unbiased judgment. A swift sword was asked for instead.
Now suppose that supernatural power goes off to put that metaphorical weapon to use, only to find that not all the charges against the accused are quite true, so the accused doesn't actually deserve the full measure of retribution called for. Do you imagine it saying, "oh well, false alarm," and going away? Probably not. So, there's another risk of backlash.