That's funny. Of course, the GOP doesn't want to give the middle class anything, that would take money away from corporations.
The Dems can start filming their "Where's my $4000?" ads for the mid-term elections now.
I'm thinking of this now, how you could nail them to the wall on it.
Q:Why not just do what Bush did and send the tax cut afterward and send everyone a check for $4000?
A: Well, that $4000 is actually over 4 years.
Q: Oh, so it's a $1000 a year?
A: Yes, that is correct.
Q: OK, so send everyone a check for $1000.
A: The $1000 is an average, so obviously not everyone will get that much.
Q: So you are saying that some will get more and some will get less?
A: That is correct.
Q: How many do you estimate will be getting $1000 or more?
A: What?
Q: You have said that some will be getting more than $1000 a year, and some less. I am just wondering, how many do you estimate will be getting $1000 or more?
A: I don't have those numbers with me.....
Q: Well I do. According to [this source], 10% of Americans will get a tax cut of $1000 or more.
A: I don't know if that source is correct.
Q: So you have an alternative estimate?
[edit bickering over the quality of that estimate]
A: I would say, yeah, I think the number who would get a tax cut of $1000 or more is less than 20%, based on my recollection of what I've seen. But everyone is getting a tax cut.
Q: Fine. One last question: you keep asking what we would do with $4000, but you know that less than 20% of Americans would get that much. So how can you talk about the average tax cut when you know it does not apply to 80% of Americans?