newyorkguy
Penultimate Amazing
Based on my knowledge of American history -- and I've been reading a lot about presidential elections recently -- it must be remembered that in the first eight or nine elections presidents were elected by state legislatures (by selecting "electors"). Massachusetts was one of the first states to go to a popular vote and gradually other states followed. By 1828 only Delaware and South Carolina still had their state legislators decide on the president instead of the general public. South Carolina held out until 1868 (and in that election Florida chose electors through the state legislature). It was not until 1872, in the 22nd presidential election, that all the states (then 37) chose the president by popular vote.
One of the reasons early on for the legislature's selecting the electors was to preserve the power of the states in selecting a chief executive who was not seen as having the political power (or importance) that the office of American president has gained over time. In the late 1700s and early 1800s it was Congress that ran the country, not the president, and members of the House of Representatives (but not the Senate) were elected by popular vote.
One of the reasons early on for the legislature's selecting the electors was to preserve the power of the states in selecting a chief executive who was not seen as having the political power (or importance) that the office of American president has gained over time. In the late 1700s and early 1800s it was Congress that ran the country, not the president, and members of the House of Representatives (but not the Senate) were elected by popular vote.
Last edited: