Understanding the Liberal Mindset

I will correct you. This is what he said...

"All billionaires are, in smartcooky's view, working persons"

He referred to MY view, and then directly a deliberately mischaracterized. That is a strawman any way you ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ slice it!

So, you don't think ALL billionaires are working persons?

I still want to read Steve's explanation and not just assume you're right.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.


ETA: BTW, how many billionaires aren't major or just minor stockholders (meaning they're part owners) in one corporation or another?
 
Last edited:
I think a lot of the issue here comes down to terminology - specifically what defines a "worker".

On the one hand we have those who say that anyone who does any kind of work at all is a worker. On the other hand, we have those who say that there is a distinction between those who do the work and those who hire people to do the work.

I propose that instead of using the ambiguous term "worker" we switch to "employer" and "employee".

There are different legal and social frameworks around those who work as an employer and those who work as an employee.
 
I think a lot of the issue here comes down to terminology - specifically what defines a "worker".

On the one hand we have those who say that anyone who does any kind of work at all is a worker. On the other hand, we have those who say that there is a distinction between those who do the work and those who hire people to do the work.

I propose that instead of using the ambiguous term "worker" we switch to "employer" and "employee".

There are different legal and social frameworks around those who work as an employer and those who work as an employee.

I don't know, sometimes an employee is employed to hire other employees, but that doesn't mean they're owners, unless they have stock in the company.


ETA: For example, I've worked for temp agencies that hired me to work for companies, and they were the ones who paid me, not the company I worked for as an employee. Now in that case, who's the employer?
 
Last edited:
I think a lot of the issue here comes down to terminology - specifically what defines a "worker".

On the one hand we have those who say that anyone who does any kind of work at all is a worker. On the other hand, we have those who say that there is a distinction between those who do the work and those who hire people to do the work.

I propose that instead of using the ambiguous term "worker" we switch to "employer" and "employee".

There are different legal and social frameworks around those who work as an employer and those who work as an employee.

the context of the video clip the basis of raising taxes on rentals and interest yields on the grounds that taxing them more was breaking a promise on taxing the income of workers because landlords and savers are workers. she basically said people receiving an income from someone else's company are how she was defining the term and those types of taxes aren't taxes on worker income
 
So, you don't think ALL billionaires are working persons?

I still want to read Steve's explanation and not just assume you're right.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.


ETA: BTW, how many billionaires aren't major or just minor stockholders (meaning they're part owners) in one corporation or another?
All billionaires, perhaps with the exception of purely hereditary billionaires, work to some degree to oversee the companies that keep the bucks rolling in, and/or consult with their financial advisers re investments. Hence they meet smartcooky's overly broad definition of worker.
 
All billionaires, perhaps with the exception of purely hereditary billionaires, work to some degree to oversee the companies that keep the bucks rolling in, and/or consult with their financial advisers re investments. Hence they meet smartcooky's overly broad definition of worker.
BTW, did you mean ALL billionaires (like smartcooky implied) or just most or many?


ETA: I still think most (if not all billionaires) are part owners in corporations they own stock in even if they're heredity billionaires, and I wouldn't be surprised if many of them don't do a lick of work.
 
Last edited:
BTW, did you mean ALL billionaires (like smartcooky implied) or just most or many?
I think a billionaire that does absolutely no work at all would be extremely rare. At the very least they take steps to look after their own money. I cannot say categorically as I have zero personal experience with billionaires.
 
I think a billionaire that does absolutely no work at all would be extremely rare. At the very least they take steps to look after their own money. I cannot say categorically as I have zero personal experience with billionaires.

I wouldn't doubt that they hire people to do that for them.

I mean, I'm sure there are some billionaires who actually do real work, but why do any if you can pay people to do it for you?

I guess the real problem is what the definition of "work" is. For example, some people would consider being a Party DJ (like I mentioned earlier) was work, but I thought it was just plain fun.


ETA: I still think most (if not all billionaires) are part owners in corporations that they own stock in even if they're heredity billionaires, and I wouldn't be surprised if many of them didn't do a lick of work (depending on your definition of work) for those corporations.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't doubt that they hire people to do that for them.

I mean, I'm sure there are some billionaires who actually do real work, but why do any if you can pay people to do it for you?


ETA: I still think most (if not all billionaires) are part owners in corporations that they own stock in even if they're heredity billionaires, and I wouldn't be surprised if many of them didn't do a lick of work for those corporations.

I guess the real problem is what is the definition of "work".
Of course they hire people. And any one who hires people then takes absolutely no interest in what those employees do with their money and never consults with them will not be a billionaire for very long.

We are discussing smartcooky's rather singular definition of worker, you may recall.
 
Of course they hire people. And any one who hires people then takes absolutely no interest in what those employees do with their money and never consults with them will not be a billionaire for very long.

We are discussing smartcooky's rather singular definition of worker, you may recall.

Being interested in something isn't the same as working at it, depending on your definition of work of course.

Actually, I'm replying to you, smartcooky, and Art's post about employer and employee all together. I can actually multitask.
 
Last edited:
So the actual question was been Wages and Rents?
Yes, obviously, they should be taxed very differently
 
Last edited:
I think billionaires are a red herring here. They're in a class all of their own.

Don't they own businesses (at least as stockholders) and that's not a red herring, but if you want to believe that it is, go for it, but that doesn't mean I have to agree with your opinion.
 
Last edited:
This whole discussion started with some British minister being criticised for using the term "worker" by those who find that "worker" is anyone who works. It was obvious that the Labour minister was using the term "worker" in the old socialist meaning that is more or less synonymous with "employee". In traditional socialist parlance it has always been a difficult term, because there is a huge grey area of the middle tiers of management that are representing the employers, but are also themselves employees.

The term is unfortunate, and should never have been used. From what I have seen here, the minister in question has been forced retract, and accept that workers are anyone who works.
 
Last edited:
Reminder:
That said... if you want an enemy of the people to focus your choler on, I would suggest private equity, venture capital firms, and derivative traders. Those are people who largely (always some exceptions) don't do any actual productive work. They largely gamble with other people's money and enrich themselves at no risk. And they frequently end up destroying productive businesses.
If you drop the artifice of marxist terminology, there is a category of financial undertakings that merit scrutiny. Don't let your zeal to be revolutionaries blind you to the real risks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom