• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Tom Clancy criticizing War in Iraq...

Questioninggeller

Illuminator
Joined
May 11, 2002
Messages
3,048
I don't know if this is new, but I just stumbled on it:

NEW YORK (AP) -- A brand name author with many admirers in the military criticized the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, citing it as proof that "good men make mistakes."

That same writer said he almost "came to blows" with a leading war supporter, former Pentagon adviser Richard Perle.

The author is Tom Clancy.

The hawkish master of such million-selling thrillers as "Patriot Games" and "The Hunt for Red October" now finds himself adding to the criticism of the Iraq war, and not only through his own comments.

...

"It troubles me greatly to say that, because I've met President Bush," Clancy said. "He's a good guy. ... I think he's well-grounded, both morally and philosophically. But good men make mistakes."

.... [Later in the piece]...

In discussing the Iraq war, both Clancy and Zinni singled out the Department of Defense for criticism. Clancy recalled a prewar encounter in Washington during which he "almost came to blows" with Richard Perle, a Pentagon adviser at the time and a longtime advocate of the invasion.

"He was saying how (Secretary of State) Colin Powell was being a wuss because he was overly concerned with the lives of the troops," Clancy said. "And I said, 'Look ..., he's supposed to think that way!' And Perle didn't agree with me on that. People like that worry me."

Both Clancy and Zinni praised President Bush but would not commit to voting for him. Clancy said that voting for Sen. John Kerry, the Democrats' presumptive nominee, would be "a stretch for me," but wouldn't say that he was supporting Bush.

Full story: http://www.cnn.com/2004/SHOWBIZ/books/05/25/author.and.the.general.ap/index.html
 
Its not new, he co-wrote the Zinni book. He also co-wrote "Shadow Ops" in the same fashion. Shadow Ops of course is mostly about the evolution of US special forces. Along the way, he details the mistakes that were made since the military primarily learns from blunders. Now, this is always troublesome to some people since a military blunder means people might die. IN hindisight, it might even look like they died unnecessarily.

This is why I think the brouhaha over the Clancy/Zinni book is funny. This sort of book is what Clancy does in nonficition, analyzing the strategy and pointing out the successes and the failures. There is some undercurrent from Bush's opposition that is frankly obsessed with him making mistakes. I don't get it. Reminds me of the right wing being obsessed with what they saw as Clinton's lies.

To have this book come from Clancy/Zinni is the ultimate vindication for Bush's most rabid detractors. I can't wait to read the book and probably find that the brouhaha is vastly overstated like the debacle over the Woodward book.
 

Back
Top Bottom