• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Orcas attacking boats - several incidents

carlosy

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jun 3, 2011
Messages
1,022
Scientists baffled by orcas ramming sailing boats near Spain and Portugal


In the last two months, from southern to northern Spain, sailors have sent distress calls after worrying encounters. Two boats lost part of their rudders, at least one crew member suffered bruising from the impact of the ramming, and several boats sustained serious damage.

...

On 29 July, off Cape Trafalgar, Victoria Morris was crewing a 46ft delivery boat that was surrounded by nine orcas. The cetaceans rammed the hull for over an hour, spinning the boat 180 degrees, disabling the engine and breaking the rudder, as they communicated with loud whistling.

It felt, she said, “totally orchestrated”. Earlier that week, another boat in the area reported a 50-minute encounter; the skipper said the force of the ramming “nearly dislocated the helmsman’s shoulder”.

At 11.30 the previous night, British couple Beverly Harris and Kevin Large’s 40ft yacht was brought to a sudden halt, then spun several times; Harris felt the boat “raise a little”.

Earlier that evening, Nick Giles was motorsailing alone when he heard a horrific bang “like a sledgehammer”, saw his wheel “turning with incredible force”, disabling the steering as his 34ft Moody yacht spun 180 degrees. He felt the boat lift and said he was pushed around without steering for 15 minutes.

...
https://www.theguardian.com/environ...-launch-orchestrated-attacks-on-sailing-boats

So, this is it. That's how the end times start. Good luck everyone.

:boxedin:



Ok, seriously. Must be pretty scary being on a boat and getting attacked by a group of Orcas, for almost an hour.
 
I wonder if these orcas perceive the boats as creatures. Do they think the boat is alive? But then no part of the boat is edible.
 
I wonder if these orcas perceive the boats as creatures. Do they think the boat is alive? But then no part of the boat is edible.

I wonder if it even has to go that far. Maybe they perceive movement + wallowing and that just triggers an instinct? Or maybe there's some higher-level mental process beyond instinct that's kicking in? I don't know. All I know is that a rubber toy snake, or a small toy or plush bee doesn't have to actually have venom to give me a heebie-jeebie shudder. It just has to either surprise me, or look super realistic, even if I understand it's not genuinely alive.

I wish I knew myself.
 
Maybe it's just very rough play against a defenseless thing. Do whatever you want or can with the boat and it never fights back or hurts you.
 
Scientists baffled by orcas ramming sailing boats near Spain and Portugal


They’re probably being trained by the UK Home Office prior to being deployed in the English Channel.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/environ...-launch-orchestrated-attacks-on-sailing-boats

So, this is it. That's how the end times start. Good luck everyone.

:boxedin:



Ok, seriously. Must be pretty scary being on a boat and getting attacked by a group of Orcas, for almost an hour.
I’m not sure who these expert scientists are who have never heard of this activity.
Two stories from 2017.

One where fishing fleets were targeted, perhaps to drive them away from Orca food sources?
Linked in that article is a 2014 study on Orca depredation on the fish caught on long lines.

Back in whaling times off the Australian SE coast, Orcas would cooperate with whaling fleets to herd, capture and kill the targeted baleen whales. The whalers would feed them the scrap meat, such as tongues, that the whaling industry would normally waste.

I don’t know how territorial Orcas are, but if they have a favourite fishing ground, that some pods certainly do, then it doesn’t surprise me that they’d be sufficiently organised to defend it, either from other Orcas or any perceived threat.
 
I wonder if these orcas perceive the boats as creatures. Do they think the boat is alive? But then no part of the boat is edible.


The people in it are.
But it doesn't seem to happen:
In the wild, there have been no fatal attacks on humans.
Orca attacks (Wiki)
Competition with fishermen also led to killer whales being regarded as pests. In the waters of the Pacific Northwest and Iceland, the shooting of killer whales was accepted and even encouraged by governments. As an indication of the intensity of shooting that occurred until fairly recently, about 25% of the killer whales captured in Puget Sound for aquarium through 1970 bore bullet scars. The U.S. Navy claimed to have deliberately killed hundreds of killer whales in Icelandic waters in 1956 with machine guns, rockets, and depth charges.
Orcas: "Killer" stereotype (Wiki)
Orca intelligence (Wiki)
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom