Not Enough JE Threads: What Do Believers Say He Can Do?

[Garrette]

In this thread, "process" is irrelevant.


I'm starting this thread because in at least one other, neo (and possibly others) insist that understanding the process of JE and mediumship is essential to discussing JE at all.

I disagree.

The purported process may be interesting, but is irrelevant to whether anything actually occurs.

So I am asking believers to define for me what does occur.

Here are the questions:

1. What, as precisely as you can state it, does John Edward do?

2. What are the definable results of what he does?

Believers need not agree on their answers, though I think it would be telling if they don't.

Takers?

 

[renata]

Garrette, today I was just contemplating a thread asking questions of people who attended JE seminars, so we could compare their impressions. I asked some of Lurker and Instig8r on different threads, and that is what gave me that idea. I guess I have to wait. Not enough JE threads indeed....

 

[Ed]

In this thread, "process" is irrelevant.


I'm starting this thread because in at least one other, neo (and possibly others) insist that understanding the process of JE and mediumship is essential to discussing JE at all.

I disagree.

The purported process may be interesting, but is irrelevant to whether anything actually occurs.

So I am asking believers to define for me what does occur.

Here are the questions:

1. What, as precisely as you can state it, does John Edward do?

2. What are the definable results of what he does?

Believers need not agree on their answers, though I think it would be telling if they don't.

Takers?

3. What are the parameters ounder which he operates? Do non-believers have a chilling effect? What is the range of critters that he can talk to? Can he make money on this (I mean thru gambling and such or is this precluded by a "rule"?) And so on. Basically the rules are his outs when he FU.