• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Islam has an image problem

Humes fork

Banned
Joined
Jul 9, 2011
Messages
3,358
Recently a study was carried out in Sweden about the Swedes' views and attitudes toward different things in society. One of the issues was attitudes toward the five world religions as well as atheism (treated as the equivalent of a religion for the purposes of the study). About attitudes, not beliefs (though one's beliefs obviously impact on one's attitudes). The results can be seen below (the words are similar enough in Swedish and English that I don't think translation will be necessary):

SOM2012a.png


I can see Christianity being positively rated because many people associate it with various Swedish traditions. I'd suspect Judaism's negative rating has to do with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as well as just old-fashioned antisemitism (Sweden was historically much less tolerant of Jews and Catholics that say England or the Netherlands). No idea about why atheism. Hinduism and Buddhism get the ratings they do. I think negative views on Islam come from Islamic terrorism, cartoon riots, attempted murders of Lars Vilks, and associated events. I don't think old plain xenophobia is enough to explain it. From a European point of view, Buddhism and Hinduism are even more foreign than Islam, yet are rated better.
 
Islam doesn't allow images, right?

Cheap jokes aside, I think it might just be that Islam is seen as less tolerant, so as less liked.

Judaism; I can't make heads or tails of that one either.

Hinduism; again, no ideas.

Buddhism; seems obvious, since the public image of it is that it's tolerant of everyone.

Christianity; I agree. So mundane that people see it as a standard to compare everything against.
 
I'd be interested to know how many people in Sweden had enough interaction with Hinduism to be able to form an opinion
 
I'd be interested to know how many people in Sweden had enough interaction with Hinduism to be able to form an opinion

Really thiis is the whole point of the o/p - image vs. reality.

Hinduism? Ah, like that Gandhi guy and the elephant god and colourful clothes and festivals and all? Seems OK to me ...... ;)
 
Could it be the swedes are just negative about pretty much everything?


I'd say Islam has a general image problem plus the Swedes are a more homogeneous culture negative about the outside (to avoid the word xenophobia) than other societies. There's a similar study from 2010 done in (West- and East-) Germany, Denmark, France, Netherlands and Portugal. English language press release here. Numbers are not directly comparable because there was no "neutral" option, only "very negative","rather negative","rather positive" and "very positive". And the question was not about attitudes towards the religions but the members of the religions.

The results for both negative options are in this chart. I'd say the Swedes are somewhere between the Germans and the rest of the countries in their negativity against everything. ;)

Christianity and Atheism were also questioned - see raw data page 21ff of this pdf. As to be expected, Atheists get the most slack in former East Germany: 27,7% very positive, 46,2% rather positive, 10,1% rather negative and only 3,7% very negative attitude. Denmark about the same picture with even slightly more "very positive". Most unfavorable attitude towards Atheists among the polled countries: Again West Germany.

Haters.
 
Last edited:
Wait, are you saying that a country with a 1000 years of Christian traditions view Christianity more favourably than any other religion? Amazing! :rolleyes:

In other news, Taoism seen more favourably in China, Shinto more favourably in Japan, and Islam more favourably in Yemen.
 
I'm atheist and I have a negative view towards atheism.
 
yeah we beat Islam, Judaism and Budhism, ha up yours Buddhists.
 

Back
Top Bottom