• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Iraq's National Library Destroyed

Clancie

Illuminator
Joined
May 19, 2002
Messages
3,021
Maybe some of you who didn't care about the National Museum's destruction will feel something tragic about this:

Looters Ransack Iraq's National Library

By CHARLES J. HANLEY, AP Special Correspondent

BAGHDAD, Iraq - Looters and arsonists ransacked and gutted Iraq National Library, leaving a smoldering shell Tuesday of precious books turned to ash and a nation's intellectual legacy gone up in smoke.

They also looted and burned Iraq's principal Islamic library nearby, home to priceless old Qurans; last week, thieves swept through the National Museum and stole or smashed treasures that chronicled this region's role as the "cradle of civilization."

"Our national heritage is lost," an angry high school teacher, Haithem Aziz, said as he stood outside the National Library's blackened hulk. "The modern Mongols, the new Mongols did that. The Americans did that. Their agents did that," he said as an explosion boomed in the distance as the war winds down.

The Mongols, led by Genghis Khan's grandson Hulegu, sacked Baghdad in the 13th century. Today, the rumors on the lips of almost all Baghdadis is that the looting that has torn this city apart is led by U.S.-inspired Kuwaitis or other non-Iraqis bent on stripping the city of everything of value.

But outside the gutted Islamic library on the grounds of the Religious Affairs Ministry, the lone looter scampering away was undeniably Iraqi, a grizzled man named Mohamed Salman.

"It was left there, so why leave it?" he asked a reporter as he clung to a thick, red-covered book, a catalog of the library's religious collection. The scene inside was total devastation. Not a recognizable book or manuscript could be seen among the dark ash.

The destruction has drawn condemnation worldwide, with many criticizing U.S.-led coalition forces for failing to prevent or stop the looting, sometimes carried out by whole Iraqi families.

The United Nation's cultural agency and the British Museum announced Tuesday they will send in teams to help restore ransacked museums and artifacts.

Koichiro Matsuura, director-general of the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, called on customs officials, police, art dealers and neighboring countries to block the trading of stolen antiquities.

Among the National Museum's treasures were the tablets with Hammurabi's Code — one of mankind's earliest codes of law. It could not be immediately determined whether the tablets were at the museum when war broke out.

Thieves smashed or pried open row upon row of glass cases at the museum and pilfered or destroyed their contents. Missing were the four millennia-old copper head of an Akkadian king, golden bowls and colossal statues, ancient manuscripts and bejeweled lyres.

The looting and burning — the museum in the northern city of Mosul also was pillaged — has dealt a terrible blow to a society that prides itself on its universities, literature and educated elite.

"I can't express the sorrow I feel. This is not real liberation," said an artist in a wing of the National Library that had been looted but not burned.

The thin, bearded, 41-year-old man, who would not give his name, was going through old bound newspapers and tearing out pages whose artistic drawings appealed to him. "I came yesterday to see the chaos, and when I saw it, I decided to take what I could," he said.

The three-story, tan brick National Library building, dating to 1977, housed all books published in Iraq, including copies of all doctoral theses. It preserved rare old books on Baghdad and the region, historically important books on Arabic linguistics, and antique manuscripts in Arabic that teacher Aziz said were gradually being transformed into printed versions.

"They had manuscripts from the Ottoman and Abbasid periods," Aziz said, referring to dynasties dating back a millennium. "All of them were precious, famous. I feel such grief."

No library officials could be located to detail the loss. Haroun Mohammed, an Iraqi writer based in London, told The Associated Press some old manuscripts had been transferred from the library to a Manuscript House across the Tigris River.


Except for wooden card catalog drawers and a carved-wood service counter which somehow escaped the flames, nothing was left in the National Library's main wing but its charred walls and ceilings, and mounds of ash. The floor on the ground level was still warm from the flames. Long rolls of microfilm littered the courtyard.

"This was the best library in Iraq," said music student Raad Muzahim, 27, standing among piles of paper in the periodical room. "I remember coming as a student. They were hospitable, letting students do their research, write their papers.

Armored vehicles were positioned on the nearby street, manned by U.S. Marines. They did nothing to stop Tuesday's continuing trickle of looters.
 
So sad. Its almost as if the looters and arsonists are purging all of Iraq of itself. Tearing down every remnant of the establishment.
 
library

I find this most disturbing. I have often looked back at incidents such as the shelling of the Parthenon and wondered why people let that happen and now here it is in present day.

I think this point is worth making. For the first time in 2-3 thousand years (with the exception of the Gulf War), Iraq was conqered by a nation who did not pillage, rape and steal the country so Iraqi's are doing to themselves. Maybe they just can't handle it.

If we were to colonize Iraq, they would be better off for it and they are essentially expecting that.

Bentspoon
 
corplinx said:
So sad. Its almost as if the looters and arsonists are purging all of Iraq of itself. Tearing down every remnant of the establishment.

...taking it down to the lowest common denomenator, erasing any remnant of the last regime. You know what message the looting sends too--it lets all the wealthy aristocrats in other arab countries know that if the US invades, our troops won't stop the looting of the monarchy.

Whoever designed this invasion is a genius and deserves a medal for the sheer brilliance of it.

That said, I get mad when people burn books. Burning books is very bad. :mad:

JK
 
JK, I am glad you said that .......

about burning books being very bad

It is something that I have always found appalling - even if I don't like the books.

I certaily don't blame the American forces for not doing anything about it but I abhor it and wish they would protect these kinds of establishments. Let the looters have the palaces.

All in all, if I were an Iraqi and had half a brain I would be begging for the US to take over the country and willingly become a territory.

I don't believe these people have what it takes to make a civilization in the 21st century.

step 1 is to abandon tribalism and from what I hear about Kurds and Shiites, that isn't going to happen for another thousand years.

Bentspoon
 
There are thieves and opportunists in every society, every country in the world, including this one.

If an opportunity presented itself, when the word got out that there was no one in Washington, D.C. (or Los Angeles or Las Vegas or...) to stop a crowd from looting, does anyone here really believe the Smithsonian would not be looted? That the White House, if abandoned, would not be stripped?

When a new police/military force occupies a country, they assume the authority--and the responsibility--for attempting to protect its most precious cultural heritage. It was up to us to prevent this...and we didn't.

So a few days ago there were admissions of broken promises, and mea culpas for the National Museum of Baghdad...and then still the U.S. allows the National Library to go unprotected ("nearby troops did nothing to stop it")? It's unforgiveable. It's a disgrace.

While some Americans go on cheering for this administration and it's "victory" over "terrorism" (or whatever the reason we are there), we are displaying ourselves to the rest of the world as crude, barbaric hypocrites.

History will not treat Bush as kindly as the U.S. press does.
 
...taking it down to the lowest common denomenator, erasing any remnant of the last regime. You know what message the looting sends too--it lets all the wealthy aristocrats in other arab countries know that if the US invades, our troops won't stop the looting of the monarchy.

Message trying to be sent is NOT equal to message being heard.
I do agree that the looting of the palaces sends a "good" (in your terms) message to the elites elsewhere in the region. But the looting and burning of a national library, when US force don't do a damn about it, sends a very NEGATIVE message. Of course the US didn't want it to happen, and it might be true that they didn't expect it. But it still sends the message.

Btw, no one planned the looting, the US said so themselves. No one is going to get a medal for that.

Gem
 
Re: library

Bentspoon said:
I find this most disturbing. I have often looked back at incidents such as the shelling of the Parthenon and wondered why people let that happen and now here it is in present day.

I think this point is worth making. For the first time in 2-3 thousand years (with the exception of the Gulf War), Iraq was conqered by a nation who did not pillage, rape and steal the country so Iraqi's are doing to themselves. Maybe they just can't handle it.

If we were to colonize Iraq, they would be better off for it and they are essentially expecting that.

Bentspoon
Nice rationalisation. I'm not sure it there's a shred of evidence to support your assertion, but certainly a good blame-shifting effort.
 
Robert Fisk: Library books, letters and priceless documents are set ablaze in final chapter of the sacking of Baghdad

So yesterday was the burning of books. First came the looters, then the arsonists. It was the final chapter in the sacking of Baghdad. The National Library and Archives _ a priceless treasure of Ottoman historical documents, including the old royal archives of Iraq _ were turned to ashes in 3,000 degrees of heat. Then the library of Korans at the Ministry of Religious Endowment was set ablaze.

I saw the looters. One of them cursed me when I tried to reclaim a book of Islamic law from a boy of no more than 10. Amid the ashes of Iraqi history, I found a file blowing in the wind outside: pages of handwritten letters between the court of Sharif Hussein of Mecca, who started the Arab revolt against the Turks for Lawrence of Arabia, and the Ottoman rulers of Baghdad.

And the Americans did nothing. All over the filthy yard they blew, letters of recommendation to the courts of Arabia, demands for ammunition for troops, reports on the theft of camels and attacks on pilgrims, all in delicate hand-written Arabic script. I was holding in my hands the last Baghdad vestiges of Iraq's written history. But for Iraq, this is Year Zero; with the destruction of the antiquities in the Museum of Archaeology on Saturday and the burning of the National Archives and then the Koranic library, the cultural identity of Iraq is being erased. Why? Who set these fires? For what insane purpose is this heritage being destroyed?

When I caught sight of the Koranic library burning _ flames 100 feet high were bursting from the windows _ I raced to the offices of the occupying power, the US Marines' Civil Affairs Bureau. An officer shouted to a colleague that "this guy says some biblical [sic] library is on fire". I gave the map location, the precise name _ in Arabic and English. I said the smoke could be seen from three miles away and it would take only five minutes to drive there. Half an hour later, there wasn't an American at the scene _ and the flames were shooting 200 feet into the air.
 
Clancy said:
If an opportunity presented itself, when the word got out that there was no one in Washington, D.C. (or Los Angeles or Las Vegas or...) to stop a crowd from looting, does anyone here really believe the Smithsonian would not be looted? That the White House, if abandoned, would not be stripped?

Shoot, there were americans who tried to sell pieces of the space shuttle after it exploded! Imagine what would have happened had their not been authorities chasing after them ASAP.

How would have we responded to an accusation that Americans don't care about our astronauts?
 
Jedi Knight said:


That said, I get mad when people burn books. Burning books is very bad. :mad:

JK

Even Mein Kampf and the Communist Manifesto? :D

But for once I think we at least mostly agree. Burning books, especially irreplacable historical archives, is hideous.
 
From a NY Times article on the looting:
While war and looting are synonymous, few scholars could remember such a spectacular loss in recent times. When Vietnam invaded Cambodia and overthrew Pol Pot in January 1979, there was virtually no looting of ancient Khmer art or manuscripts. During World War II, the Allies changed their military strategy to avoid fighting inside Florence, Italy.

Langdon Warner, a Harvard archaeologist, is a hero in Japan for persuading the Air Force to spare the ancient cities of Nara and Kyoto from firebomb raids that laid waste to other major Japanese cities in 1945. No such solicitude was shown for Berlin or Dresden.
 
Ozymandius
by Percy Bysshe Shelley
First Published in 1817
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


I met a traveller from an antique land,
Who said--"Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desart . . . . Near them, on the sand,
Half sunk a shattered visage lies, whose frown,
And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command,
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
The hand that mocked them, the heart that fed;
And on the pedestal, these words appear:
My name is Ozymandius, King of Kings,
Look on my Works, ye Mighty, and despair!
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal Wreck, boundless and bare
The lone and level sands stretch far away."
 

Back
Top Bottom