• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

How many penises are there on the Bayeux Tapestry?

catsmate

No longer the 1
Joined
Apr 9, 2007
Messages
34,767
Or, The Mystery of the 94th Penis.¹

A burning question....
  • Though obviously not as important as the correct plural of 'penis' I'll going with the usual 'penises' rather than the arguably more correct 'penes'.
First, for those of you who haven't heard of the Bayeux Tapestry it's a thirty five square metre embroidered art piece showing an overview of the Norman invasion of Britain.

Now, on to the exposed genitalia (all male naturally). The dispute was started some six years ago when Oxford professor George Garnett published an article noting that he had counted up 93 penises stitched into the tapestry.²
  • It should be noted that the piece is not, technically, a tapestry. But, hey.....
According to Garnett's count 88 of the.....appendages are attached to horses and the remainder to human.
The world was awed at the accuracy of the count. Magnifiers were held over representations of the cloth to check.

But now a dispute has erupted in the narrow area where art, history, and obsessive counting of male genitalia on works of art intersect³.
Is there a 94th penis?

Historian and Bayeux tapestry scholar Dr Christopher Monk⁴ believes he has found a 94th penis.
On the tapestry border a running man is embroidered. The man⁵ has something dangling beneath his tunic. This is the dispute.
Garnett says it is the scabbard of a sword or dagger. Monk insists it is a member.
Monk states:
I am in no doubt that the appendage is a depiction of male genitalia – the missed penis, shall we say. The detail is surprisingly anatomically fulsome.
Garnett remains unconvinced.

The pair debate the discovery/dispute on the History Extra podcast, hodted by Dr David Musgrove

As an aside, the Tapestry was very much a political/propaganda work, hence the largest penis on show was attached to William the Bastard's horse...
Size matters.



1. Which would be an excellent title for a book. I'm thinking a time travel medieval queer romance featuring a time-traveller and a woman posing as a man pretending to be a monk, both attempting to access something hidden within the monastery. Shades of Once Corpse Too Many.

2. The question why Pr. Garnett did so is not answered. Really if you ask that you obviously don't have the proper mindset for historical research.

3. Something of a narrow area I'll admit. But you're reading this......

4. Who is known in some circles as 'The Medieval Monk'. Nominative determinism at work

5. Well it's assumed to be male, given the dangly bit. But who knows, it might be a strap on dildo?⁶
That might fit into my novel idea.

6. For those of you doubting such things existed in the eleventh century, or just interested in the history of the strap-on, they do precede the Norman Invasion of Britain. By perhaps nine thousand years.....
But that is for another post.
 
In Reading Museum there is a (nearly) faithful reproduction, full size, of the Bayeux Tapestry, created by a team of Victorian lady needleworkers. I'd offer to pop along in the name of research, but for this particular enquiry it's not useful, since, as I said, it was created by a team of Victorian ladies, and the particular objects in question have been obscured by anachronistic embroidered underpants.

 
Catsmate is now officially my favourite person of the day (closely followed by Dr Monk), and will continue to be so until someone posts an even better thread. So maybe forever! This is a perfect example of history (the tale of the battle), literature (the op's clear and well-structured outline of the issue) and art (the very tapestry itself) can come together to inform and enlighten us, and make us better humans. Or at the very least make some of us a little conmforted by the thought that even in dark times, dedicated researchers cannot not be stopped from carrying out their important, nay groundbreaking, research! You will keep us updated, I hope, if a definitive conclusion on the possible 94th phallus is reached?
 
Catsmate is now officially my favourite person of the day (closely followed by Dr Monk), and will continue to be so until someone posts an even better thread. So maybe forever! This is a perfect example of history (the tale of the battle), literature (the op's clear and well-structured outline of the issue) and art (the very tapestry itself) can come together to inform and enlighten us, and make us better humans. Or at the very least make some of us a little conmforted by the thought that even in dark times, dedicated researchers cannot not be stopped from carrying out their important, nay groundbreaking, research! You will keep us updated, I hope, if a definitive conclusion on the possible 94th phallus is reached?
Awww, thank you. If there is more news I will post it.
 
No doubt PhDs have been handed out for less, and as the identifier of the so-called 94th penis returned to his seat with his rolled up diploma a new theory suddenly dawned… ye gads! The depicted exhibitionist was merely holding a scroll the whole time!!!
 
I've been done with counting penises a long time ago. Got up to 1066, but then it got boring.
 

Back
Top Bottom