• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Holy Quran Corrects the False Bible (Part 2)

Emre_1974tr

Graduate Poster
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
1,441
Location
Turkey
Another excellent example of these corrections is the stipulation that clergy or other individuals do not have the authority to declare things forbidden (haram) or permissible (halal), or to issue religious rulings in the name of God:

Throughout history, humanity has produced a "clerical class" that acts as an intermediary between people and God, claiming special authority and, over time, establishing itself as an authority. The Qur'an fundamentally rejects this clerical system and the deification of religious figures, defining it as shirk (associating partners with Allah). The religion in the Qur'an is a system of direct and unmediated submission; in this system, every individual communicates directly with God, judgment belongs to Allah alone, and titles such as "imam" do not constitute a sacred class.

The Role of Rabbis in the Falsified Torah: The falsified Torah defines a special status for priests (Kohanim) from the lineage of the Levites. Over time, this structure evolved into the class of rabbis, who held the authority to interpret the Torah and, more importantly, the Talmud, which is the "oral tradition."

The interpretations (ijtihad) of the rabbis became as binding as revelation itself, introducing countless non-existent rules and details into the religion. The populace was made dependent on the interpretations of rabbis rather than the Torah to understand their faith.

The Role of Priests in Post-Gospel Christianity: Although the falsified Gospels show that Jesus himself harshly criticized the religious figures of his time (Pharisees and scribes) (Matthew 23), the institutionalized church rebuilt the very structure that was criticized, with figures like priests, bishops, and the Pope.

This class was granted divine powers, such as forgiving sins in the name of God (confession), interpreting sacred texts on behalf of the people (infallibility), and determining what is permissible and forbidden (council decisions). An ordinary believer could neither be cleansed of their sins nor be sure of understanding their religion correctly without the mediation of a priest.

In both of these models, the clergy ceased to be "teachers" who delivered Allah's message to the people and instead transformed into authorities who owned the message and held a monopoly on its interpretation, elevating themselves to the position of indispensable intermediaries between Allah and the people.

Error and Deviation: Associating Partners with Allah in Judgment

The clerical classes in other religions (e.g., rabbis, priests) have assumed the authority to impose prohibitions not found in God's book or to change the rulings He has established. The Qur'an describes this act as taking these religious figures as lords (rabb) besides Allah.

The Holy Qur'an's Identification and Rejection of Clergy:

The Qur'an clearly identifies this deviation among the People of the Book:

"They have taken their scholars and their monks as lords besides Allah..." (Surah At-Tawbah, 31)

The Holy Qur'an itself explains what this act of "taking them as lords" means: it is to usurp from Allah the authority to determine what is lawful and what is unlawful. The Qur'an declares that this authority belongs solely to Allah and that people cannot arbitrarily invent prohibitions:

"And do not say about what your tongues assert of untruth, 'This is lawful, and this is unlawful,' to invent falsehood about Allah..." (Surah An-Nahl, 116)

"Say, 'Who has forbidden the adornment of Allah which He has produced for His servants and the good things of provision?'" (Surah Al-A'raf, 32)

These verses reveal how clergy have claimed "lordship" by imposing prohibitions not found in God's book (such as clerical celibacy, arbitrarily forbidding certain foods, etc.) or by altering Allah's rulings. According to the Qur'an, judgment belongs solely and exclusively to Allah.

"The judgment (al-hukm) is for none but Allah." (Surah Yusuf, 40)

The Qur'an's Solution: Unmediated Religion and the True Meaning of the Word "Imam"

The Qur'an dismantles this clerical system and establishes in its place a concept of religion where every individual is directly responsible. In this understanding, there is no professional, salaried "imam" class with special privileges as we understand it today.

What does "Imam" mean in the Qur'an?

The Qur'an uses the word "imam," but never to describe a sacred clerical class. Its meanings in the Qur'an are as follows:

A leader, guide, or role model: Abraham was made an "imam" (leader) for humanity (Al-Baqarah, 124). Righteous people pray, "and make us an imam (leader) for the righteous" (Al-Furqan, 74). This refers to moral and spiritual leadership, not a professional office.

A book or a guide: The Qur'an describes the book of Moses as an "imam" (a guide) (Hud, 17). It also states that on the Day of Resurrection, every community will be called forth with its "imam" (its book/record of deeds) (Al-Isra, 71).

Why is there no clerical class/clergy in the religion of the Qur'an?

The Qur'an invites every individual to personally read, understand, and reflect upon the book. A person is not condemned to rely on an intermediary or an "official interpretation" to understand it.

"Then do they not reflect upon the Qur'an, or are there locks upon [their] hearts?" (Surah Muhammad, 24)

Unmediated Repentance and Prayer: There is no concept of confessing to a clergyman for the forgiveness of sins or seeking his intercession; indeed, this is shirk. The door of repentance is open directly to Allah for every individual.

"Say, 'O My servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning], do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins...'" (Surah Az-Zumar, 53)

The Qur'an values knowledge and scholars, stating that "those who know and those who do not know are not equal" (Az-Zumar, 9). However, this does not establish a clerical system that monopolizes knowledge within a specific class distinguished by special attire and titles. Knowledge is a virtue accessible to every sincere servant who seeks it.

The Importance of This Correction:

This correction liberates religion from the monopoly of interpretation by a specific group, from being a tool of exploitation, and from being a means of establishing authority.

Preserving Tawhid (the Oneness of Allah): It preserves the purest form of monotheism by preventing the usurpation of divine powers such as making rulings, determining halal and haram, and forgiving. Associating partners with Allah is the greatest sin, and this path is blocked from the very beginning.

Liberating Reason and Individual Conscience: The model of the Qur'an encourages every individual to move beyond being a passive member of a "community" and to become an active and responsible "believer" who learns their religion directly from Allah's book, using their own reason and conscience.

In conclusion, the Holy Qur'an demolishes all systems that deify clergy and place religion under the monopoly of a clerical class, returning religion to its rightful owner, Allah, and to the reason and conscience of each individual. There is no place in religion for clergymen known by titles such as rabbis, priests, imams, or sheikhs. Indeed, such priestly classes are of pagan origin.

And let us remember again, for today, the sole source of the religion of Islam is the Qur'an.

 
Last edited:
My individual reason and conscience tell me to disregard the Qur'an. But thanks, it's good to know the Qur'an agrees.
 
This correction liberates religion from the monopoly of interpretation by a specific group, from being a tool of exploitation, and from being a means of establishing authority.
Indeed I’ve always been highly skeptical of people who propose to interpret religion for everyone else and demand that we all pay attention to them. You know, like telling us to go read their blogs etc.
 
My church had pastors, but the drive was for each and every person to have an individual direct relationship with God and Jesus. There was no "clerical class". We spoke directly to God and/or Jesus and/or the Holy Spirit, and they spoke back, directly into our minds.
 
Another excellent example of these corrections is the stipulation that clergy or other individuals do not have the authority to declare things forbidden (haram) or permissible (halal), or to issue religious rulings in the name of God:

Throughout history, humanity has produced a "clerical class" that acts as an intermediary between people and God, claiming special authority and, over time, establishing itself as an authority. The Qur'an fundamentally rejects this clerical system and the deification of religious figures, defining it as shirk (associating partners with Allah). The religion in the Qur'an is a system of direct and unmediated submission; in this system, every individual communicates directly with God, judgment belongs to Allah alone, and titles such as "imam" do not constitute a sacred class.

The Role of Rabbis in the Falsified Torah: The falsified Torah defines a special status for priests (Kohanim) from the lineage of the Levites. Over time, this structure evolved into the class of rabbis, who held the authority to interpret the Torah and, more importantly, the Talmud, which is the "oral tradition."

The interpretations (ijtihad) of the rabbis became as binding as revelation itself, introducing countless non-existent rules and details into the religion. The populace was made dependent on the interpretations of rabbis rather than the Torah to understand their faith.

The Role of Priests in Post-Gospel Christianity: Although the falsified Gospels show that Jesus himself harshly criticized the religious figures of his time (Pharisees and scribes) (Matthew 23), the institutionalized church rebuilt the very structure that was criticized, with figures like priests, bishops, and the Pope.

This class was granted divine powers, such as forgiving sins in the name of God (confession), interpreting sacred texts on behalf of the people (infallibility), and determining what is permissible and forbidden (council decisions). An ordinary believer could neither be cleansed of their sins nor be sure of understanding their religion correctly without the mediation of a priest.

In both of these models, the clergy ceased to be "teachers" who delivered Allah's message to the people and instead transformed into authorities who owned the message and held a monopoly on its interpretation, elevating themselves to the position of indispensable intermediaries between Allah and the people.

Error and Deviation: Associating Partners with Allah in Judgment

The clerical classes in other religions (e.g., rabbis, priests) have assumed the authority to impose prohibitions not found in God's book or to change the rulings He has established. The Qur'an describes this act as taking these religious figures as lords (rabb) besides Allah.

The Holy Qur'an's Identification and Rejection of Clergy:

The Qur'an clearly identifies this deviation among the People of the Book:

"They have taken their scholars and their monks as lords besides Allah..." (Surah At-Tawbah, 31)

The Holy Qur'an itself explains what this act of "taking them as lords" means: it is to usurp from Allah the authority to determine what is lawful and what is unlawful. The Qur'an declares that this authority belongs solely to Allah and that people cannot arbitrarily invent prohibitions:

"And do not say about what your tongues assert of untruth, 'This is lawful, and this is unlawful,' to invent falsehood about Allah..." (Surah An-Nahl, 116)

"Say, 'Who has forbidden the adornment of Allah which He has produced for His servants and the good things of provision?'" (Surah Al-A'raf, 32)

These verses reveal how clergy have claimed "lordship" by imposing prohibitions not found in God's book (such as clerical celibacy, arbitrarily forbidding certain foods, etc.) or by altering Allah's rulings. According to the Qur'an, judgment belongs solely and exclusively to Allah.

"The judgment (al-hukm) is for none but Allah." (Surah Yusuf, 40)

The Qur'an's Solution: Unmediated Religion and the True Meaning of the Word "Imam"

The Qur'an dismantles this clerical system and establishes in its place a concept of religion where every individual is directly responsible. In this understanding, there is no professional, salaried "imam" class with special privileges as we understand it today.

What does "Imam" mean in the Qur'an?

The Qur'an uses the word "imam," but never to describe a sacred clerical class. Its meanings in the Qur'an are as follows:

A leader, guide, or role model: Abraham was made an "imam" (leader) for humanity (Al-Baqarah, 124). Righteous people pray, "and make us an imam (leader) for the righteous" (Al-Furqan, 74). This refers to moral and spiritual leadership, not a professional office.

A book or a guide: The Qur'an describes the book of Moses as an "imam" (a guide) (Hud, 17). It also states that on the Day of Resurrection, every community will be called forth with its "imam" (its book/record of deeds) (Al-Isra, 71).

Why is there no clerical class/clergy in the religion of the Qur'an?

The Qur'an invites every individual to personally read, understand, and reflect upon the book. A person is not condemned to rely on an intermediary or an "official interpretation" to understand it.

"Then do they not reflect upon the Qur'an, or are there locks upon [their] hearts?" (Surah Muhammad, 24)

Unmediated Repentance and Prayer: There is no concept of confessing to a clergyman for the forgiveness of sins or seeking his intercession; indeed, this is shirk. The door of repentance is open directly to Allah for every individual.

"Say, 'O My servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning], do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins...'" (Surah Az-Zumar, 53)

The Qur'an values knowledge and scholars, stating that "those who know and those who do not know are not equal" (Az-Zumar, 9). However, this does not establish a clerical system that monopolizes knowledge within a specific class distinguished by special attire and titles. Knowledge is a virtue accessible to every sincere servant who seeks it.

The Importance of This Correction:

This correction liberates religion from the monopoly of interpretation by a specific group, from being a tool of exploitation, and from being a means of establishing authority.

Preserving Tawhid (the Oneness of Allah): It preserves the purest form of monotheism by preventing the usurpation of divine powers such as making rulings, determining halal and haram, and forgiving. Associating partners with Allah is the greatest sin, and this path is blocked from the very beginning.

Liberating Reason and Individual Conscience: The model of the Qur'an encourages every individual to move beyond being a passive member of a "community" and to become an active and responsible "believer" who learns their religion directly from Allah's book, using their own reason and conscience.

In conclusion, the Holy Qur'an demolishes all systems that deify clergy and place religion under the monopoly of a clerical class, returning religion to its rightful owner, Allah, and to the reason and conscience of each individual. There is no place in religion for clergymen known by titles such as rabbis, priests, imams, or sheikhs. Indeed, such priestly classes are of pagan origin.

And let us remember again, for today, the sole source of the religion of Islam is the Qur'an.

You do know the qu'ran is just muslim clerics declaring what is halal and haram on behalf of a 9th centurt caliph, right?
 
The Pagan Sources Of Islam
"As Muhammad developed Islam he borrowed from the other regional religions present in the Mideast. These religions include Judaism, Christianity, Sabeanism, Zoroastrianism, and forms of paganism. Judaism is the largest contributor to Islam, followed by Christianity, then followed by the various pagan religions, and Muhammad’s mind."

In conclusion, the Holy Qur'an demolishes all systems that deify clergy and place religion under the monopoly of a clerical class, returning religion to its rightful owner, Allah, and to the reason and conscience of each individual. There is no place in religion for clergymen known by titles such as rabbis, priests, imams, or sheikhs. Indeed, such priestly classes are of pagan origin.
 
Last edited:
Scriptures (noun)
"The sacred books of our holy religion, as distinguished from the false and profane writings on which all other faiths are based."
~ Ambrose Bierce, The Unabridged Devil's Dictionary

And let us remember again, for today, the sole source of the religion of Islam is the Qur'an.
 
You've successfully come to the conclusion that your entire religion is founded on a single book. The next step is to realize that it's just an arbitrary random book, no more special than any other book, and become an atheist.
 
You've successfully come to the conclusion that your entire religion is founded on a single book.
But in order to understand that book correctly, you have to read his posts here and his blog where he spends a lot of effort telling us the proper way to read the book and the proper way to understand what it's trying to teach us. You know, what clergy do. It's not so much that Emre is anti-clergy as it is that he wants to be the clergy. That's the problem with so many religious "reformers." They don't want to change the system and make it less about personal power and authority. They just want to get some of that for themselves.

If Emre would just say that Allah appeared to him and told him where to find some golden tablets, he could publish the Book of Emre and peel off enough Muslims to make his own tidy little sect. He's really doing it that hard way here.
 
Replacing a lie with another lie doesn't work.

Feces is still feces.

It matters little if it comes out of bull's ass or a human's. It is still not suitable for human consumption.
 
Another excellent example of these corrections is the stipulation that clergy or other individuals do not have the authority to declare things forbidden (haram) or permissible (halal), or to issue religious rulings in the name of God:

Throughout history, humanity has produced a "clerical class" that acts as an intermediary between people and God, claiming special authority and, over time, establishing itself as an authority. The Qur'an fundamentally rejects this clerical system and the deification of religious figures, defining it as shirk (associating partners with Allah). The religion in the Qur'an is a system of direct and unmediated submission; in this system, every individual communicates directly with God, judgment belongs to Allah alone, and titles such as "imam" do not constitute a sacred class.
Allow me to introduce you to the biblical and especially Christian concept of "the priesthood of all believers.” The following is from Bible Hub, "What is believers' priesthood?"

Definition and Overview

The phrase “priesthood of all believers” refers to the privilege and responsibility granted to everyone who trusts in the Messiah, enabling direct access to the Divine without the need for a human intermediary. It highlights an extraordinary spiritual standing: all the faithful are called to function as God’s representatives, offering spiritual sacrifices and interceding on behalf of others. This concept underscores the unity, equality, and shared ministry of all who belong to the community of faith.

Biblical Foundations

From the earliest pages of Scripture, the idea of a divinely chosen people with priestly duties appears prominently. In Exodus, the Creator addresses the people as a “kingdom of priests and a holy nation” (Exodus 19:6). This roles up into the New Testament, where believers are named a “royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9). The continuity from Old Testament to New Testament reveals a consistent purpose: to gather a people who serve and honor the Almighty, reflecting His character to the world.

 

Back
Top Bottom