Doped-up pilot escapes prosecution for FF incident

evil sutko

Scholar
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
84
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/cpress/20040624/ca_pr_on_wo/us_cda_friendly_fire
CP) - Family members of Canadian soldiers who were killed when an American fighter pilot mistakenly bombed them in Afghanistan (news - web sites) expressed disappointment at a U.S. air force decision Thursday to dismiss all criminal charges against him.

Maj. Harry Schmidt has accepted an offer to face administrative punishment in exchange for dismissal of four counts of dereliction of duty, the air force said. Agatha Dyer, mother of Cpl. Ainsworth Dyer, 25, who was killed in the 2002 bombing, said she was saddened by the news.

"He should get some penalty because he was at fault. He didn't obey orders. My heart is broken," Dyer said Thursday from her home in Montreal.

What the article doesn't mention is that Schmidt's defense was that the dextroamphetamine that the Air Force sometimes
requires pilots to ingest (in order to prevent fatigue) clouded his judgement and made him disregard proper procedures.

That put the Defense Dept. in the awkward position of actually defending drug use.
 
http://my.webmd.com/hw/drug_data/d00804a1?src=inktomi

WebMD info for Dexedrine
Use caution when driving, operating machinery, or performing other hazardous activities. Dextroamphetamine may cause dizziness, blurred vision, or restlessness, and it may hide the symptoms of extreme tiredness. If you experience these effects, avoid hazardous activities.

http://www.reason.com/hod/jm012703.shtml

Some more background:
Given such a vital need, how much drug use is going on? Col. Alvina Mitchell, chief of Air Force media operations, has told reporters she doesn't know the current rates, but if previous wars are anything to go by, the numbers are quite substantial. "A survey of pilots who took part in the 1991 Desert Storm operation suggests 60 percent of them took [dextroamphetamine]," according to Buncombe. "In units most heavily involved in combat missions, the rate was as high as 96 percent. During Desert Storm, the standard dosage of [dextroamphetamine] was 5mg. In Afghanistan it was 10mg." This is nothing big; usual doses for adults can range from 5 to 60mgs a day, depending on need.

Ironically, the drug, branded Dexedrine, carries the warning that it "may impair judgment or coordination. Do not drive or operate dangerous machinery [like F-16s, for instance] until you know how you react to the medication." Once a user knows how he reacts, however, the presumption is that the drug is relatively safe. After all, the Air Force trusts tired men to zip through the air with extremely lethal, million-dollar equipment.

The obvious follow-up: If it is good and safe enough for pilots, what about the rest of us? With "no known speed-related mishaps" why shouldn't taxicab drivers, swing-shifters at NEC, or bleary-eyed night-school students be able to take advantage? It's not as if only pilots must battle fatigue, and these folks are certainly not in the position to drop 500-pound bombs on innocent Canadians. A government that punishes people for using a substance it praises as vital seems worse than hypocritical.
edited to add: I don't necessarily believe that it should be legal (it would depend on further study, of course) but I do agree that it's hypocritical
 
evil sutko said:
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/cpress/20040624/ca_pr_on_wo/us_cda_friendly_fire

What the article doesn't mention is that Schmidt's defense was that the dextroamphetamine that the Air Force sometimes
requires pilots to ingest (in order to prevent fatigue) clouded his judgement and made him disregard proper procedures.

That put the Defense Dept. in the awkward position of actually defending drug use.
Pilots are given 5 or 10 mg. Some research:

Doses of 10-30 mg methamphetamine have shown to improve reaction time, relief fatigue, improve cognitive function testing, increase subjective feelings of alertness, increase time estimation, and increase euphoria. However, subjects were willing to make more high-risk choices.
http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/injury/research/job185drugs/methamphetamine.htm

Helicopter pilots who received placebos and then flew a simulator from 0100 to 1700 hours after a single night of sleep deprivation displayed significant, progressive deterioration of flight--control skills that would have threatened both safety and mission accomplishment. The problems encountered were especially severe in the morning hours (0300–1000). Even after a slight improvement in the afternoon (due to circadian rhythm), control accuracy did not recover to normal prefatigue levels. When these pilots received amphetamine on a different sleep--deprived night, decrements in performance did not occur. In fact, low--dose amphetamine eliminated the early morning deteriorations in flight skills and maintained performance at prefatigue level for the remainder of the day.
http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/apj/spr97/cornum.html

Of the Class A mishaps occurring during Desert Shield/Desert Storm, several were partially attributed to pilot fatigue, and no pilots were using amphetamine at the time of any mishap. Additionally, there have been no accidents, during training or actual deployment to a theater, in which amphetamine use by the aircrew was either reported or found to be a factor during the accident investigation.
http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/apj/spr97/cornum.html

I wonder how this could be used in the defense - it seems to me that I should worry more about pilots that didn't take their pill.

"The obvious follow-up: If it is good and safe enough for pilots, what about the rest of us?"

Maybe because we tend to take more? :p
 
His career's over anyways. Chances are, they'll probably break him in rank and discharge him ASAP.

--Toasty
 
I don't know the effect of 5-10mg of dex, having never taken it. Could we conclude that 'doped-up' is a bit of hyperbole, or accurate? I.e. is it closer to 4 cups of coffee, or to the coke snorting fiend at the party whose standing on top of the table screaming?
 
roger said:
I don't know the effect of 5-10mg of dex, having never taken it. Could we conclude that 'doped-up' is a bit of hyperbole, or accurate? I.e. is it closer to 4 cups of coffee, or to the coke snorting fiend at the party whose standing on top of the table screaming?
Last time we discussed it in this forum, some pilot explained how loads of coffee (which was the alternative) would make him pee, which could be a hassle and even difficult in certain situations.
 

Back
Top Bottom