Garvarn
Thinker
- Joined
- Nov 4, 2003
- Messages
- 204
www.hugo-online.org takes a closer look at John Chambers' Conversations With Eternity in the June-July feature article. An excerpt:
"I began to check the verifiable information provided by John Chambers and discovered that not only did he present incorrect basic facts, such as dates, places and historic detail, he also neglected to present vital information that contradicts his version of the events that took place in Marine-Terrace. In addition, he has invented a state of mind of the Hugos, during their early exile, that simply have no connection with reality. Chambers' aim is to invoke a view of reincarnation and cosmos on the reader and to support this effort he uses rhetorical dodges with extraordinary coarseness -- he is in every aspect an intellectual conjurer."
Read the full review at http://www.hugo-online.org
Best regards,
Peter
"I began to check the verifiable information provided by John Chambers and discovered that not only did he present incorrect basic facts, such as dates, places and historic detail, he also neglected to present vital information that contradicts his version of the events that took place in Marine-Terrace. In addition, he has invented a state of mind of the Hugos, during their early exile, that simply have no connection with reality. Chambers' aim is to invoke a view of reincarnation and cosmos on the reader and to support this effort he uses rhetorical dodges with extraordinary coarseness -- he is in every aspect an intellectual conjurer."
Read the full review at http://www.hugo-online.org
Best regards,
Peter