• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Comfrey herbal tea is poisonous?

Matty1973

Critical Thinker
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
253
Can't really be sure from the article if the comfrey tea was the cause but it highlights the need for some regulation in the herbal industry.

Times newspaper article

Most herbalists, represented by organisations such as the European Herbal and Traditional Medicine Practitioners Association, want to be regulated, in accordance with a tough EU directive that comes into force next year; only with regulation, they say, can we buy teas with confidence.

But the pharmaceutical lobby has delayed regulation of herbalists for a decade, arguing that this would confer unmerited respectibility: its friend in Parliament, Lord Taverne, has said this would be like regulating astrologers. What those lobbyists don’t shout so loudly is that, without regulation of herbalists, Big Pharma will from next year enjoy sole control of remedies that historically have been freely available.

Does anyone know about this new EU directive?
 
so is water if you drink enough of it :rolleyes:

Did you not read the nicely cited Wikipedia article or did you just decide to run your mouth off trying to come off as insightful when the exact opposite happened?


My guess would be the both—he did not read the Wikipedia article, AND he decided to run his mouth off trying to come off as insightful when the exact opposite happened.
 
Having a hard time reading the thread title are you? :rolleyes:

Comfrey herbal tea is poisonous?

or perhaps you didn't bother to read the article at all and just made two non-contributory remarks.

But the average adult human would need to ingest 20,000 comfrey leaves to produce a comparative dose, and trials on long-term comfrey users, including one at University College London, have apparently found no harmful effects.
:garfield:
 
Last edited:
Having a hard time reading the thread title are you? :rolleyes:
No. I just know what the definition of poison is.
or perhaps you didn't bother to read the article at all and just made two non-contributory remarks.
Isn't the biggest knock against herbal medicine is that you would have to be a moron to try and make that claim.
EDIT:
I was right. You were being a know nothing snark.
 
Last edited:
You do realize the article was tongue in cheek..just as my comment was, or didn't you read it? :rolleyes:
I read the article. I couldn't tell if an idiot wrote it or if it was written tongue in cheek. The article makes a claim that its hard to poison yourself with the root despite the fact that a few cases of poisoning actually caused the FDA to step in (Not the claims of cancer).
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom