• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Chimps ‘are people too’

rats

Muse
Joined
Mar 27, 2006
Messages
608
Did anyone watch the horizon programme Chimps are people too?

It seems to be available from the Horizon web site (I’m currently off line at home so can’t watch it): available until 17th October .

The BBC article linked to above introduces several experiments, hinting the focus of the programme was an experiment that tried to raise bonobos as people. Unfortunately the article doesn’t report on the results, except that a 26 year old bonobo was acting like a child. The article also seems concentrated on the approach of the presenter, who I’d never heard of.

A quick google for the Great Ape Trust Research Center indicates an attitude of having accepted that apes can learn language (discussed in this interesting thread). Their work may be very interesting, but I disagree that their research is “arguably the most critical and powerful new science emerging today!”
 
i watched it - but was a bit disapointed - Horizon seems to have dumbed down quite a bit......

from the BBC link
As a non-scientist, he's a useful man to investigate the extent to which our closest relatives, the chimpanzees, could indeed be people, too.

which seems a strange thing to say - as it suggest that the mere fact that he's not a scientist makes him more qualified.....surely a scientist who knows what they're talking about would have been a better man (or woman) to investigate?

it was mainly annecdote and silly experiments (eg. 3 people choosing their favourite smelling t-shirt and then comparing the results - oh look 2 out of 3 chose the same one!)

which was a shame.....
 
Last edited:
i watched it - but was a bit disapointed - Horizon seems to have dumbed down quite a bit........

Yes, the "Rough Science" ethos has leaked into their 'serious' science side.

I really liked the Rough Science series, but their aims were different from those of Horizon, or, at least, they should be.
 
it was mainly annecdote and silly experiments (eg. 3 people choosing their favourite smelling t-shirt and then comparing the results - oh look 2 out of 3 chose the same one!)

Are you sure that wasn't Brainiac?;)
 

Back
Top Bottom