• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Brian Dunning lawsuit

I do a lot of stuff with military history. . . . .Often I have to trudge to a library to check I do not own, buy an expensive out of print book, or ask somebody for help who has the books.

A lot of the in depth stuff is not on the web.
Have you listened to the show or ever tried to cross-ref the stuff he has researched? It's mostly very easy. He's done like 400 shows, I'm sure he's had the occasional difficult topic, but that is not the norm.

Military history is MUCH more in depth than "some guy claimed he saw mothman, where did that story come from?"
 
Have you tried Wikipedia?






(Married to a librarian, so this joke gets used a lot around our house. Sorry)

http://skepticblog.org/2010/12/09/skeptoids-massive-ddt-fail/
I often begin researching episodes with Wikipedia, as it's a great way to find out who are the major players in a subject, and you usually get a wealth of links to more authoritative sources, which is where I generally spend a lot of time, along with science journals and newspaper archives, to which I have many access accounts.

:)
 
Have you tried Wikipedia?

(Married to a librarian, so this joke gets used a lot around our house. Sorry)

As you might expect, I am a contributing author to a number of Wikipedia articles on naval history items, especially with battleships.
 
Last edited:
It is inaccurate to say "Users would see nothing" if they actually saw a link to eBay.

Which they did, according to this post: http://melaniecolburn.blogspot.com/2006/05/whats-this.html

ETA:
Did eBay ever allege, at any point, that users who received cookies saw no adverts from KFC? I read through the superseding information and saw no such allegation therein.

That's a red herring. Merely seeing an ad for ebay shouldn't leave a cookie; the allegation is that KFC was dropping cookies without the user clicking on an ad for ebay, or even being aware that they had left the page they were viewing.
 
That's a red herring. Merely seeing an ad for ebay shouldn't leave a cookie; the allegation is that KFC was dropping cookies without the user clicking on an ad for ebay, or even being aware that they had left the page they were viewing.



It may well be a red herring but it is not one of my making. Other posters here have alleged that Dunning outright lied about whether users saw eBay links or adverts at all prior to receiving cookies.
 
2014 Form 990 for Skeptoid Media

According to the 2014 Form 990 for Skeptoid Media, Brian Dunning received $65.6 k USD compensation for being president, while his wife received $16.65 k USD compensation along with $5.5 k for health benefits, contributions to employee benefit plans, and deferred compensation for being an executive director for the year 2014. It looks like most expenses went towards salaries for officers.
 
According to the 2014 Form 990 for Skeptoid Media, Brian Dunning received $65.6 k USD compensation for being president, while his wife received $16.65 k USD compensation along with $5.5 k for health benefits, contributions to employee benefit plans, and deferred compensation for being an executive director for the year 2014. It looks like most expenses went towards salaries for officers.

Meh. Even combining his salary with his wife's, that's not a huge amount of money for SoCal.
 
Well, at least he's being more honest on the podcast now. He out-and-out tells you that Skeptoid is a full-time job. How? I don't know. I could do the research and cut the 12 minutes about 6-8 hours, tops.

Looks like he's paying himself about $150.00 per hour or so, not counting his wife's income (because she may be doing a lot of work, heck I don't know.) I based that on each episode taking 8 hours, although those "listener emails" episodes that occur about every month shouldn't take nearly that long. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.
 
Well, at least he's being more honest on the podcast now. He out-and-out tells you that Skeptoid is a full-time job. How? I don't know. I could do the research and cut the 12 minutes about 6-8 hours, tops.
Doing research can be time-consuming, especially if you're trying to track down primary references. A lot of times finding that primary reference can be difficult because of circular referencing: article "A" makes a claim but doesn't give a source, and every other article you find simply parrots "A."

I delivered a five-minute reminiscence at my father's memorial service recently. I figure that took me at least 2 to 3 hours to write, and I didn't have to do very much research at all. (I had to look up the year in which he got married.) And that was for a smaller and much less critical audience than Skeptoid has. And I didn't have to deal with a bunch of stupid e-mails after I gave it.

Looks like he's paying himself about $150.00 per hour or so, not counting his wife's income (because she may be doing a lot of work, heck I don't know.) I based that on each episode taking 8 hours, although those "listener emails" episodes that occur about every month shouldn't take nearly that long. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt.
$150/hr is not unheard of for a consultant or other self-employed person. He's having to make all contributions to various government programs that sometimes are split 50/50 between the employer and employee. (I don't know about the US, but here in Canada those programs are Employment Insurance and Canada Pension Plan, and some places have a payroll tax as well.) On top of that he has to pay for his own and his wife's health insurance, which probably is not cheap for self-employed people. Then there are required activities that don't generate revenue: bookkeeping, auditing, filing forms, looking for sponsors, etc.

Having said all that, I wonder what happened to the $7 million the FBI claims he got from the cookie-stuffing caper?
 

Back
Top Bottom