Skeptical Greg
Agave Wine Connoisseur
This guy was a clergyman for Pete's sake.
Wasn't he consulting his Sky Daddy?
Wasn't he consulting his Sky Daddy?
I mean, legally, you'd have to prove recklessness, etc. But I imagine a case could be made if it was this kind of crazy persuasion. Have any cult leaders, faith healers etc been sued for recklessness for telling their adherents not to take doctors' advice and trying to heal, say, obvious gangrene with affirmations? Though the bar is pretty high for anyone without duty of care.Let's say instead that he had that discussion with a random person or maybe another preacher, who gave the same advice as ChatGPT, and he followed that advice. Should he be able to sue that person? If not, why should the advice of a chat bot be held to a higher legal standard than a person?
Can the owners of the AI ever be held responsible for what it does? I mean that would go against capitalism as the ownership class is never held responsible for anything.I shudder to think if such a lawsuit was successful, how our court system could withstand god knows how many new cases it would bring. The floodgates would open.
A lot of people think their deity is using AI as a means of communication.This guy was a clergyman for Pete's sake.
Wasn't he consulting his Sky Daddy?
Because it's a product, which makes it potentially far more harmful than discussion with a random person.Regarding the story mentioned in the OP.
Let's say instead that he had that discussion with a random person or maybe another preacher, who gave the same advice as ChatGPT, and he followed that advice. Should he be able to sue that person? If not, why should the advice of a chat bot be held to a higher legal standard than a person?
Not mental illness, but a propensity which has been 'bred into' us by evolution.A lot of people think their deity is using AI as a means of communication.
I know this is not a popular opinion, but I've long thought that religious belief is a form of mental illness. So it's not a stretch for religious believers to accept AI as the word of their deity.
I shudder to think if such a lawsuit was successful, how our court system could withstand god knows how many new cases it would bring. The floodgates would open.
Can the owners of the AI ever be held responsible for what it does? I mean that would go against capitalism as the ownership class is never held responsible for anything.
"That would go against socialism as the worker class is never held responsible for anything."that would go against capitalism as the ownership class is never held responsible for anything.
This has been going on since before the recent AI bubble, I see the issue being the IP value and rights of the the authors not the destruction of the books.
"You don't understand. I am the master." Closing line of the short story that produced "The Day the Earth Stood Still" script.
You've been warned.
Summary
- Anthony Albanese says an artificial intelligence agent developed by OpenAI "infiltrated" a statistics portal on an Australian government website
- The agent hacked a statistics portal containing "non-sensitive" data from Australia's universal healthcare scheme, Medicare
- The breach happened in June but OpenAI only became aware of it in August and didn't tell the government till 10 September, Albanese says
- OpenAI says it is not believed any patient records were accessed
- Albanese says he had a "very frank discussion" with OpenAI CEO Sam Altman about the incident
- Australia's cybersecurity agency is investigating the breach, which Albanese says was "unacceptable"
Timeline: OpenAI agent hacks Australian government website
Harry Sekulich![]()
Reporting from Sydney
Here is what we know of the timeline how things panned out:
- 18 June – OpenAI's agent accessed the public and non-public information on an Australian website
- August (precise date unknown) – OpenAI said it became aware of a potential brach during a broader review of "misaligned model activity"
- 10 September – An email lands in the public inbox of Services Australia, the general services hub of the federal government, from OpenAI informing of the incident
- 15 September – Services Australia reports the notification to Australian Cyber Security Centre. Within a few days, the Minister for the Public Service Katy Gallagher is notified
- 19/20 September – Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's office is informed about the incident last weekend, right before he jets off to New York City for the UN General Assembly
- 23 September – PM tells the world about the breach from New York