So I listened
Episode 5 with Mel Gibson and boy, that dude is seriously detached from reality. I mean his religion, sure, which is weird enough as it is, but when Rogan pushes back on some of Gibson's claims, Gibson basically goes "whatever, I don't care".
Like when Gibson said that he believes that humans were created by God about 8,000 years ago (yes, he's a YEC), Rogan comes back with evidence from radiocarbon dating. Gibson doesn't believe in radiocarbon dating. Rogan says that the science is extremely solid on it. Gibson says it doesn't matter because how does it affect him anyway?
Dude. It's important to know what's real and what's not!
The Skeptical Toolbox in this episode is the Argument from Anecdote, which Gibson uses constantly. He claims efficacy for
Neil Riordan's stem cell therapy, which Joe then happily ties into the Big Medicine conspiracy claiming that "they" suppress treatments that work so that they can keep you hooked on the drugs that they sell you.
Finally, Marsh and Cecil agreed that they liked how Rogan pushed back against Gibson's anti-evolutionary beliefs, but they also pointed out that he only pushes back when it's something he believes, and never when someone else is confirming his own narrative, and he isn't even consistent with it.
Next episode is Rogan's interview with none other than the Zuck himself, so that'll be interesting.