• Due to ongoing issues caused by Search, it has been temporarily disabled
  • Please excuse the mess, we're moving the furniture and restructuring the forum categories
  • You may need to edit your signatures.

    When we moved to Xenfora some of the signature options didn't come over. In the old software signatures were limited by a character limit, on Xenfora there are more options and there is a character number and number of lines limit. I've set maximum number of lines to 4 and unlimited characters.

Merged Neom / The Line - genius, crazy, delusion, dystopia?

carlosy

Muse
Joined
Jun 3, 2011
Messages
822
I... don't know.

Saudi Arabia want's to build a city: 170km long, 200m wide, 500m tall:
The Line, Neom City

 
I... don't know.

Saudi Arabia want's to build a city: 170km long, 200m wide, 500m tall:
The Line, Neom City



The style of the video visualizations reminds me of The Blue Estate (artificial floating island) from early 2021, which disappeared from the Internet and the media by the following August (leaving behind some YouTube videos that were still available last time I checked).

Actually, the purpose of The Blue Estate as a media project was never clear. On the surface it appears to have been a real estate scam, but no one has reported ever having actually paid them anything. Maybe the people (or person) behind The Blue Estate were merely advertising their services as designers of futuristic Utopian pipe dreams, and The Line is their latest delivery.

One of the top YouTube comments, by one Jon Hanson, reads, "This feels like the video you see in the first act of a sci fi movie before everything goes to hell in the second." I said almost exactly the same thing about The Blue Estate.

ETA: The comments I was talking about are on a different YouTube posting of the same video, by NEOM, here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0kz5vEqdaSc. The Telegraph's copy linked to in the OP has comments turned off.
 
Last edited:
It's an obvious scam to raise money and use it on feasibility studies in the Caribbean.

Just like the Japanese rotating moon base.

It will never get build.
 
Just the resources for materials alone is insane. I guess it could be somewhat equivalent to building 850 skyscrapers (500m tall, 200m wide).
 
I guess it would be functionally equivalent to building an urban corridor along a rail line. One advantage might be needing only a single easement for all your major transportation and supply infrastructure, One highway, one waterway, one railway, one power line, etc.
 
I didn't watch the whole thing but a little. Perfect if you like the idea of living in a wall, with the density of Kowloon and the aesthetics of a science fiction underground city. Fast travel and excursions into nature are promised. What is not promised, but I suspect will be delivered, is the opportunity for surveillance, vulnerability, privilege, containment and contagion.

Where will all the material for this immense project be sourced and manufactured? Not within it, I surmise.

In the library, you will need special permission to access the copies of Brave New World, The Machine Stops, and 1984.
 
If the goal is to reduce the impact on the environment, then isn't a straight line one of the worst shapes? Is 500m tall enough to affect local weather patterns?
 
If the goal is to reduce the impact on the environment, then isn't a straight line one of the worst shapes?

It depends what environmental impact problem they're trying to solve. If it turns out that an extremely long, narrow urban core is a much more energy-efficient way to house, supply, and employ hundreds of thousands of people, that might mean a lot less contribution to global climate change from energy production, even if if it leaves the local ecosystem somewhat less "pristine" than other city footprints.
 
It depends what environmental impact problem they're trying to solve. If it turns out that an extremely long, narrow urban core is a much more energy-efficient way to house, supply, and employ hundreds of thousands of people, that might mean a lot less contribution to global climate change from energy production, even if if it leaves the local ecosystem somewhat less "pristine" than other city footprints.

I suppose it would depend on where it is. I note that the idealized illustration in the movie, as far as I bothered with it, was in a desert. If it occurred in just about any other place, and probably in many deserts as well, it would be a disaster for wildlife.
 
Eh, the problem I have with that solution is that when they start breaking through the wall they're breaking into my living room.


The apartments should be in about the top 100 stories, leaving about 50 for infrastructure and industrial and commercial space. So only the dragon would crash directly into your living room. The infantry hordes would have to work their way up the stairs.

That living area (100 stories * 170km * ~20m per side) appears to work out to about 75 square meters per resident. That's reasonable, neither cramped nor decadently lavish.
 
Yes we must remember how freaking tall and huge this thing is. Plenty of room for infrastructure, machinery the folks upstairs need never see, sewage, garbage, slums.


When they run out of funds, they can use the partially completed bits as a set for the lavish remake of Metropolis.
 
The building would be just a bit shorter than the world's biggest buildings. I suggest its height would make it very expensive to build. I wonder how they would deal with the wind that would exist at that height? Plus all the other problems faced by other tall buildings, plus other ones that will only exist in such a long building.
 
I guess it would be functionally equivalent to building an urban corridor along a rail line. One advantage might be needing only a single easement for all your major transportation and supply infrastructure, One highway, one waterway, one railway, one power line, etc.



This was my thought. One of the fundamental problems with promoting mass transit over cars is that mass transit works best in a straight line. Providing adequate coverage for a traditional 2-D city almost always requires transfers between at least two bus or train lines, and the scheduling of such transfers are always a pain in the ass.

So this would let you have one main train line running back and forth the length of the city. You'd be able to access a station almost anywhere with just an elevator ride and a short walk. The biggest complexity might be short-distance vs. long distance trains. Have a local train with stops every 200m or so, and an express train with stops maybe 2 to 5km apart. You'd only have to do a transfer if you were planning on going a long way, or wanted to get there quickly.
 
So this would let you have one main train line running back and forth the length of the city. You'd be able to access a station almost anywhere with just an elevator ride and a short walk. The biggest complexity might be short-distance vs. long distance trains. Have a local train with stops every 200m or so, and an express train with stops maybe 2 to 5km apart. You'd only have to do a transfer if you were planning on going a long way, or wanted to get there quickly.


Or, try out that high-speed moving sidewalks thing, at long last! The roads must roll!
 
I'm going to do a quick post-and-run, in case the hyenas that bullied me off this forum pick up my scent: don't expect any further input from me.
I live in Saudi Arabia, as some of you may know. I was told by a Saudi co-worker that The Line has been quietly shelved: too expensive and too impractical. Not official, of course, but that's how things often work in the Magic Kingdom.
 
Portland has a pair of circular routes that ring the downtown, running in opposite directions. In a 2-D cityscape, that seems to be the best solution. A "linear" ring line, with transfers to spoke lines (bus or light rail) into the outskirts.
 
Continuing on the "what could go wrong" level here, I'm reminded of the disappointingly bad movie "Snowpiercer," which did have at least one point, which is that in a linear society it's pretty easy to isolate the underclass. Of course that's possible anyway, and every city seems to have its slums and favelas, but it seems likely to be especially easy to do by initial design, if the city is enormously high and enormously long. Put all the low ranking housing at the bottom of the far end, or perhaps at the bottom of the middle, with the mass-transit equivalent of servants' staircases to get them to their destinations. In an enterprise this huge, and this complex, I suspect it would be very easy to engineer in durable system of social stratification, with transit, social services, etc. separate.
 
Portland has a pair of circular routes that ring the downtown, running in opposite directions. In a 2-D cityscape, that seems to be the best solution. A "linear" ring line, with transfers to spoke lines (bus or light rail) into the outskirts.

That works well up to a certain scale. At some point, the city becomes large enough that getting to the ring routes become a problem.
 
The style of the video visualizations reminds me of The Blue Estate (artificial floating island) from early 2021, which disappeared from the Internet and the media by the following August (leaving behind some YouTube videos that were still available last time I checked).

Actually, the purpose of The Blue Estate as a media project was never clear. On the surface it appears to have been a real estate scam, but no one has reported ever having actually paid them anything. Maybe the people (or person) behind The Blue Estate were merely advertising their services as designers of futuristic Utopian pipe dreams, and The Line is their latest delivery.

One of the top YouTube comments, by one Jon Hanson, reads, "This feels like the video you see in the first act of a sci fi movie before everything goes to hell in the second." I said almost exactly the same thing about The Blue Estate.

ETA: The comments I was talking about are on a different YouTube posting of the same video, by NEOM, here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0kz5vEqdaSc. The Telegraph's copy linked to in the OP has comments turned off.

My favourite comment is:

Jeremy Buxman
3 days ago
It's like a late 2000's young adult dystopia novel brought to life! "In the Line, we could have anything we wanted...if you were a Highliner. Us Lowliners had to struggle to get by, and outside the GlassWall, the Lineless dwelled and scribbled not-straight lines..."​
 
Last edited:
They are building it there because it is still cheaper than a Mars Utopia.
 
One advantage might be needing only a single easement for all your major transportation and supply infrastructure, One highway, one waterway, one railway, one power line, etc.

... and one drawback might be being a Single Point Of Failure textbook example
 
Neom: Saudi forces 'told to kill’ to clear land for eco-city

Neom: Saudi forces 'told to kill’ to clear land for eco-city

Saudi authorities have permitted the use of lethal force to clear land for a futuristic desert city being built by dozens of Western companies, an ex-intelligence officer has told the BBC.

Col Rabih Alenezi says he was ordered to evict villagers from a tribe in the Gulf state to make way for The Line, part of the Neom eco-project.

One of them was subsequently shot and killed for protesting against eviction.

The Saudi government and Neom management refused to comment.

Neom, Saudi Arabia's $500bn (£399bn) eco-region, is part of its Saudi Vision 2030 strategy which aims to diversify the kingdom's economy away from oil.

Its flagship project, The Line, has been pitched as a car-free city, just 200m (656ft) wide and 170km (106 miles) long - though only 2.4km of the project is reportedly expected to be completed by 2030.

Dozens of global companies, several of them British, are involved in Neom's construction.

The area where Neom is being built has been described as the perfect "blank canvas" by Saudi leader Crown Prince Mohamed bin Salman. But more than 6,000 people have been moved for the project according to his government - and UK-based human rights group ALQST estimates the figure to be higher.

The BBC has analysed satellite images of three of the villages demolished - al-Khuraybah, Sharma and Gayal. Homes, schools, and hospitals have been wiped off the map.

Abdul Rahim al-Huwaiti refused to allow a land registry committee to value his property, and was shot dead by Saudi authorities a day later, during the clearance mission. He had previously posted multiple videos on social media protesting against the evictions.

At least 47 other villagers were detained after resisting evictions, many of whom were prosecuted on terror-related charges, according to the UN and ALQST. Of those, 40 remain in detention, five of whom are on death row, ALQST says.

Several were arrested for simply publicly mourning al-Huwaiti's death on social media, the group said.
 
Utopia comes at a cost

The BBC has analysed satellite images of three of the villages demolished - al-Khuraybah, Sharma and Gayal. Homes, schools, and hospitals have been wiped off the map.
 
Its a brilliant cocnept if you just think of it as a money laundering scheme. Or a series of money laundering schemes.

Has a "made to order" city ever actually worked?
 
Back
Top Bottom