Of Viruses and Men
The Atheist still needs some clarification, so I'll have to elaborate:
1) No, 'we' absolutely did no such thing. Herd immunity by infection didn't 'remove' measles at all. Measles was a childhood disease, which the vast majority of children were infected with and for the most part survived - with or without long-term complications. Unlike SARS-CoV-2, it usually leaves survivors with life-long immunity, which they pass on to their descendants.
2) However, as explained in post 1,069, which The Atheist doesn't seem to understand, the virus didn't mutate into a milder version of itself, which becomes clear when we look at people, who weren't exposed to the weeding-out process generation after generation: They still haven't got much natural immunity, but this is not because they are "only a small group of idiots." It's an evolutionary process, and even idiots can be protected by congenital immunity passed down by their parents.
3) As for unnatural immunity, i.e. the one induced by vaccines, it is true that "a small group" of antivaxxers help keep the virus alive. However, many of the people who don't vaccinate their children aren't idiots. They are just ignorant and sometimes disinformed by professional antivaxxers who ought to know better and often do.
4) In fact, fans of natural immunity come in all shapes and sizes. One of the proponents of natural immunity over vaccination in the case of COVID-19 is The Atheist.
This article explains it well. Notice again that the virus doesn't evolve to become benign. Instead, the virus weeds out people and lets only those with a level of natural immunity survive and procreate:
However, there is a reason why it won't happen with SARS-CoV-2 any time soon (soon, in this case, being "500 to 1000 years"): Unlike the measles virus, for the most part, it doesn't kill children. It kills mainly people beyond reproductive age, and thus it doesn't leave much of a "signal of "adaptive markers"."
For the same reason, the virus itself also doesn't gain much of an advantage by mutating into a benign version of itself. What we have seen so far is that it primarily becomes more contagious. I have lost count of how much more contagious it is nowadays than it was in early 2020, and I am not sure that anybody is still keeping track of it. Another change is that different variants appear to be better at infecting some organs rather than others. Omicron and its descendants seem to be better at infecting the gut and thus affect the gut microbiota, but it is not as if people still don't get scarred lungs, brains, hearts, kidneys etc.
Some of you may still imagine that SARS-CoV-2 is on the path to becoming benign because you have been fooled by people who ought to know better.
Beware of the people who preach the gospel even though they do know better. Some of them are well-paid for their efforts. Others are just part of a very large "group of idiots" who don't question what they are being told. Many of them are much like MAGA in this respect.
ETA: I think it is obvious that this never happened: "Nice of you to walk back on your attempted and idiotic conflation with HIV, though."
The Atheist sure enjoys his small pretend victories.
As well as English, you don't quite get irony, do you?
We absolutely removed measles as a disease by herd immunity plus vaccination, and only a small group of idiots means it's still around.
Nice of you to walk back on your attempted and idiotic conflation with HIV, though.
The Atheist still needs some clarification, so I'll have to elaborate:
1) No, 'we' absolutely did no such thing. Herd immunity by infection didn't 'remove' measles at all. Measles was a childhood disease, which the vast majority of children were infected with and for the most part survived - with or without long-term complications. Unlike SARS-CoV-2, it usually leaves survivors with life-long immunity, which they pass on to their descendants.
2) However, as explained in post 1,069, which The Atheist doesn't seem to understand, the virus didn't mutate into a milder version of itself, which becomes clear when we look at people, who weren't exposed to the weeding-out process generation after generation: They still haven't got much natural immunity, but this is not because they are "only a small group of idiots." It's an evolutionary process, and even idiots can be protected by congenital immunity passed down by their parents.
3) As for unnatural immunity, i.e. the one induced by vaccines, it is true that "a small group" of antivaxxers help keep the virus alive. However, many of the people who don't vaccinate their children aren't idiots. They are just ignorant and sometimes disinformed by professional antivaxxers who ought to know better and often do.
4) In fact, fans of natural immunity come in all shapes and sizes. One of the proponents of natural immunity over vaccination in the case of COVID-19 is The Atheist.
This article explains it well. Notice again that the virus doesn't evolve to become benign. Instead, the virus weeds out people and lets only those with a level of natural immunity survive and procreate:
The history written in our genes
Like the rings of a tree, our genetic code can tell a story about events in our ancient past.
Random mutations to our genes mean some people are naturally more susceptible than others to being infected by viruses or developing serious symptoms of disease.
For instance, a recent study found that people who carry a cluster of genes inherited from Neanderthals some 50,000 years ago have a higher risk of developing severe COVID-19 symptoms.
But other mutations do the opposite, and can give us a survival edge when disease outbreaks occur.
And people with these gene variants are more likely to reproduce than others. “So what happens over several generations is the gene variants that are beneficial will rise in frequency," said study co-author Yassine Souilmi, from the University of Adelaide.
"And that leaves a very distinctive mark several generations later.”
But it takes a minimum of 500 to 1000 years for this signal of "adaptive markers" to show up in a population's genome, Dr Soulimi added.
Coronavirus epidemic broke out in East Asia around 25,000 years ago, gene study shows (ABC.net.au, June 25, 2024)
However, there is a reason why it won't happen with SARS-CoV-2 any time soon (soon, in this case, being "500 to 1000 years"): Unlike the measles virus, for the most part, it doesn't kill children. It kills mainly people beyond reproductive age, and thus it doesn't leave much of a "signal of "adaptive markers"."
For the same reason, the virus itself also doesn't gain much of an advantage by mutating into a benign version of itself. What we have seen so far is that it primarily becomes more contagious. I have lost count of how much more contagious it is nowadays than it was in early 2020, and I am not sure that anybody is still keeping track of it. Another change is that different variants appear to be better at infecting some organs rather than others. Omicron and its descendants seem to be better at infecting the gut and thus affect the gut microbiota, but it is not as if people still don't get scarred lungs, brains, hearts, kidneys etc.
Some of you may still imagine that SARS-CoV-2 is on the path to becoming benign because you have been fooled by people who ought to know better.
Beware of the people who preach the gospel even though they do know better. Some of them are well-paid for their efforts. Others are just part of a very large "group of idiots" who don't question what they are being told. Many of them are much like MAGA in this respect.
ETA: I think it is obvious that this never happened: "Nice of you to walk back on your attempted and idiotic conflation with HIV, though."
The Atheist sure enjoys his small pretend victories.
Last edited: