• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Evolution: the Facts.

Kumar said:
There seems to be an issue here;- The above definition in other language, can be called as inherant sense of right & wrong or natural sense. Here we have to take it, either inharent since many previous generations OR inherant from parents?
Click to expand...

What basis have you got for belief that a sense of right and wrong is inherent and passed on? I reckon it would be more likely learnt and cultural. I am basing that on the diversity in opinion on what is right and wrong appearing along cultural lines and not genetic lines.
 
Sideroxylon said:
What basis have you got for belief that a sense of right and wrong is inherent and passed on? I reckon it would be more likely learnt and cultural. I am basing that on the diversity in opinion on what is right and wrong appearing along cultural lines and not genetic lines.
Click to expand...

"Instinct or innate behavior is the inherent inclination of a living organism toward a particular behavior.
The simplest example of an instinctive behavior is a fixed action pattern, in which a short sequence of actions, without variation, are carried out in response to a clearly defined stimulus. However, instinctive behaviors can also be variable and responsive to the environment. Any behavior is instinctive if it is performed without being based upon prior experience, that is, in the absence of learning. from wiki"

Let us first clear that whether instinct is genetic lines(somewhat genotype) or cultural lines(somewhat phenotype) because inherent can cover both?
 
Kumar said:
"Instinct or innate behavior is the inherent inclination of a living organism toward a particular behavior.
The simplest example of an instinctive behavior is a fixed action pattern, in which a short sequence of actions, without variation, are carried out in response to a clearly defined stimulus. However, instinctive behaviors can also be variable and responsive to the environment. Any behavior is instinctive if it is performed without being based upon prior experience, that is, in the absence of learning. from wiki"

Let us first clear that whether instinct is genetic lines(somewhat genotype) or cultural lines(somewhat phenotype) because inherent can cover both?
Click to expand...

A "sense of right or wrong" or our ideas of morals clearly are not of this type and are learnt not innate.
 
Dancing David said:
Again I have seen most dogs engage in the shake and toss behavior. But I do not know if dogs raised in isolation from other dogs will engage it in, thats ort of thing helps to define an instinct. That it is expressed by most members of a species and that it expresses itself without training or conditioning.
Click to expand...
What about the game of throwing and fetching that every dog seems to love? I believe I have known dogs who have not had a chance to learn this behaviour from other dogs, and they react to fetch a stick the first time you ever try it. No coercion is needed.
 
steenkh said:
What about the game of throwing and fetching that every dog seems to love? I believe I have known dogs who have not had a chance to learn this behaviour from other dogs, and they react to fetch a stick the first time you ever try it. No coercion is needed.
Click to expand...

I really don't see how someone can not think a great deal of all behavior is due to instinctual responses. I'd think they have issues with free will or something to be so opposed to the idea that a great deal of not only animal behavior but human behavior is in fact instinct and emergent in isolated conditions.

A multitude of animal behaviors in zoos in isolated specimens can be observed that correlate with wild examples. I don't know where to begin.
I can see how someone could have trouble with making distinctions between subtle learned behavior and instinctual behavior, but to deny instinct all together is something I think is just wrong. I'm not prepared to argue the case however, but I'd love to see the distinction explored in another thread.
 
Kumar said:
Is there any relation of genotype & phynotype(genotype+environment) to instinct?
Click to expand...

Its either that or divinely placed and given the bee example I gave before, I am going with it being in the genes.

Feelings of right and wrong (a sense of morality) are not instincts as defined earlier in this thread.
 
Sideroxylon said:
Its either that or divinely placed and given the bee example I gave before, I am going with it being in the genes.

Feelings of right and wrong (a sense of morality) are not instincts as defined earlier in this thread.
Click to expand...

Can't learned behaviour be placed in genes--eq genetic predispositions?
 
Kumar said:
Can't learned behaviour be placed in genes--eq genetic predispositions?
Click to expand...
No. By the time you have learned the behaviour, all the genes have already been expressed. There is no way to influence genes through learning. Genes can be influenced in other ways, such as environment, or stress. But these gene changes will only rarely be beneficial, and certainly not in a way that can be predicted.
 
steenkh said:
No. By the time you have learned the behaviour, all the genes have already been expressed. There is no way to influence genes through learning. Genes can be influenced in other ways, such as environment, or stress. But these gene changes will only rarely be beneficial, and certainly not in a way that can be predicted.
Click to expand...

Does it suggest that instinct in all humans--husband & wife is same?
 
Dancing David said:
Again I have seen most dogs engage in the shake and toss behavior. But I do not know if dogs raised in isolation from other dogs will engage it in, thats ort of thing helps to define an instinct. That it is expressed by most members of a species and that it expresses itself without training or conditioning.
Click to expand...

If most dogs do it, and it is a learned behavior, then what we're talking about is culture. This would also apply to such behaviors as kicking up grass after urinating and turning around three times before lying down, something we've all seen dogs do.

I find it hard to believe that dogs have a universal culture that is the same all over the world, while humans do not.
 
Kumar said:
Can't learned behaviour be placed in genes--eq genetic predispositions?
Click to expand...

I think certain species will TEND to engage in certain behaviors, and these behaviors will TEND to convey a survival advantage.

The tendency is carried in genes and is reinforced by application of the behavior.

Using the example of dogs again--the shake and toss behavior has not been put there so the dog can kill; rather, the dog can kill because he is predisposed to the shake and toss behavior.

In practice, it is usually a mode of play and is not actually used to kill anything. However, if a dog does kill something and finds that it is good to eat, then he has applied the tendency to a concrete action that will help his survival.
 
aggle-rithm said:
I think certain species will TEND to engage in certain behaviors, and these behaviors will TEND to convey a survival advantage.

The tendency is carried in genes and is reinforced by application of the behavior.

Using the example of dogs again--the shake and toss behavior has not been put there so the dog can kill; rather, the dog can kill because he is predisposed to the shake and toss behavior.

In practice, it is usually a mode of play and is not actually used to kill anything. However, if a dog does kill something and finds that it is good to eat, then he has applied the tendency to a concrete action that will help his survival.
Click to expand...

I think, this only mean--survival of fittest & natural selection.
 
Kumar said:
Does it suggest that instinct in all humans--husband & wife is same?
Click to expand...
If humans have instincts (and I think they do), these will be stored in our genes, or another data medium that is replicated along with them, so yes all humans will have the same instincts - with variations, just like we do not all look the same.

Kumar said:
I think, this only mean--survival of fittest & natural selection.
Click to expand...
And I think not. The tossing and killing is not necessarily beneficial for dog survival in a human world. Natural selection, in this case selection pressure from humans, will probably weed out dogs that tend to do too much killing.
 
steenkh said:
And I think not. The tossing and killing is not necessarily beneficial for dog survival in a human world. Natural selection, in this case selection pressure from humans, will probably weed out dogs that tend to do too much killing.
Click to expand...

From personal experience, one of my dogs beats himself senseless trying to shake a soccer ball attached to a short tether. Time will tell whether this is a survival disadvantage.
 
steenkh said:
What about the game of throwing and fetching that every dog seems to love? I believe I have known dogs who have not had a chance to learn this behaviour from other dogs, and they react to fetch a stick the first time you ever try it. No coercion is needed.
Click to expand...

And there is a way to control for conditioning, how?

ETA: Learned means a lot of different things, like aquired behaviors.
 
steenkh said:
And I think not. The tossing and killing is not necessarily beneficial for dog survival in a human world. Natural selection, in this case selection pressure from humans, will probably weed out dogs that tend to do too much killing.
Click to expand...

Not unless they actively kill dogs with the trait.
 
aggle-rithm said:
If most dogs do it, and it is a learned behavior, then what we're talking about is culture. This would also apply to such behaviors as kicking up grass after urinating and turning around three times before lying down, something we've all seen dogs do.

I find it hard to believe that dogs have a universal culture that is the same all over the world, while humans do not.
Click to expand...

The turning thing is not really investigated, but a possible modal behavior. Kicking grass is another, but again it is not really investigated.

learned behavior does not always mean modeling, if something causes you pain you will usually learn avoidance behaviors to the pain.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom