Amanda Knox guilty - all because of a cartwheel

[Dan O.]

Edited by LashL: 

Removed moderated content

Are you implying that there is a repulsion to wearing another persons bra that is a built in animal instinct that all woman have? Where is the evolutionary root for this trait? I think you are projecting your own beliefs on the whole population and haven't accepted that other people grow up in different environments.

 

[Fiona]

If the evidence for this happening is a yahoo answer then why was the yahoo question asked?

 

[Fiona]

Are you implying that there is a repulsion to wearing another persons bra that is a built in animal instinct that all woman have? Where is the evolutionary root for this trait? I think you are projecting your own beliefs on the whole population and haven't accepted that other people grow up in different environments.

You are really not very good at attributing nonsense to other people Dan_O. But I know you are fond of trying so don't let me stop you

Edited by LashL: 

Removed personal remarks.

 

[Alt+F4]

Are you implying that there is a repulsion to wearing another persons bra that is a built in animal instinct that all woman have? Where is the evolutionary root for this trait? I think you are projecting your own beliefs on the whole population and haven't accepted that other people grow up in different environments.

In other words you have zero evidence that Meredith and Amanda shared bras.

 

[Dan O.]

The point is, do you claim that Meredith was wearing Amanda's bra when she was murdered?

My claim was only that the concept wasn't nonsense. There is no evidence either way with the possible exception of the incompatible sizes.

 

[Kestrel]

Edited by LashL: 

Removed moderated content

I suspect that Dan O. knows enough women to realize they don't all have the same phobias that Fiona does.

 

[Agatha]

So, no evidence then. Just asking questions - or throwing mud around in the hope some of it will stick?

 

[Alt+F4]

If the evidence for this happening is a yahoo answer then why was the yahoo question asked?

If I asked Yahoo! Answers if it's okay to have sex with rats would Dan take that as evidence that sex with rats is widespread?

Why can't those who support the innocence of AK and RS do that without trying to defend all the the obvious lies both have told?

 

[Dan O.]

You are really not very good at attributing nonsense to other people Dan_O. But I know you are fond of trying so don't let me stop you

Edited by LashL: 

Removed moderated content

Try attacking the argument and not the arguer.

 

[Fiona]

Try having an argument

 

[Fiona]

If I asked Yahoo! Answers if it's okay to have sex with rats would Dan take that as evidence that sex with rats is widespread?

Clearly!

 

[Alt+F4]

I suspect that Dan O. knows enough women to realize they don't all have the same phobias that Fiona does.

It's not a phobia, it's just gross. Dan thinks that women only have one bra, do you?

 

[Agatha]

Where does Fiona claim to have a phobia about bra-sharing? Where is the evidence that sharing bras among acquaintances is common?

I'm not trying to sound like CFLarsen, but really, shouldn't you have at least an iota of evidence that any of the "sharing a bra notion" is credible, never mind actually happened?

 

[Kermit]

My claim was only that the concept wasn't nonsense. There is no evidence either way with the possible exception of the incompatible sizes.

.
This is like watching a tractor-trailer / 18-wheeler / TIR trying to back out of a narrow, winding, one-lane European village street ...

I suspect that Dan O. knows enough women to realize they don't all have the same phobias that Fiona does.

... and on top of it all, the driver's buddy blames their predicament on the local folk.

 

[quadraginta]

My claim was only that the concept wasn't nonsense. There is no evidence either way with the possible exception of the incompatible sizes.

There's no evidence either way that hostile aliens weren't responsible.

Maybe we should check Yahoo! Answers and find out how likely aliens are.

 

[Kestrel]

Except for the fact that Amanda murdered her.

Circular reasoning. You assume that Amanda was the murderer, therefore it's evidence that she hated Meredith enough to murder her.

 

[Alt+F4]

You assume that Amanda was the murderer...

I assume no such thing, she is the murderer. If you however feel there was a miscarriage of justice here than the best help you could give to Amanda is not to defend the obvious lies and coverups coming from RS and his camp.

 

[Kermit]

Circular reasoning. You assume that Amanda was the murderer, therefore it's evidence that she hated Meredith enough to murder her.

.
No, it's more cause and effect.

Now what we could call non sequitor reasoning is to say "Meredith and Amanda went to the chocolate festival together, therefore they wore each others bras"

 

[Kermit]

... So what is Meredith to do? Miss a party, wear a wet or dirty bra or borrow a freshly cleaned and dry bra from her close friend that's sitting there on the drying rack in the hall outside their rooms.

.
Actually, there is something useful which we can glean from this surprising comment, which is that beyond the contamination argument (DNA on winged dust), there is a recognition that that is Raffaele's fully fledged DNA, and that he got it there through intimate contact with the person wearing the bra.

 

[quadraginta]

I'm liking hostile aliens more and more. I mean, they've got invisibility, matter transfer, teleportation, their malignant, evil intentions towards humanity are common knowledge, as is their fascination for attractive young girls. The whole thing fits together.

Prove me wrong. Ask Yahoo!

ETA: I forgot mind control. That even explains the injected memories.