If you take the thermally expansive element out of a thermostat it is no longer conscious.
Unless you consider the element all by itself to be the thermostat.
In any case, the principle is simple -- if a decision is made, it is conscious. So no, the element all by itself is not conscious with respect to the information about it being hot or cold enough to trigger some external event.
So...just to get this clear, you are claiming the stat is conscious and the rock not whereas Pixy agrees neither are conscious?
BTW, no decisions are being made here. Materials are altering their physical characteristics according to environmental conditions. This happens anyway.
Nick
Last edited: